A better show WITHOUT......

Page

Next Last

Chitra_11

@Chitra_11

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Wish the show was without...

1. Sonakshi Sinha...I do like her confidence BUT declaring favourities especially being a judge is a big No-No and further an open offer to Nahid (she deserves) by an actress is again a big No-No. The reason is simple...

When the judges didn't take their role seriously of pin pointing the plus-minus of singers and were busy singing the tune of soothing lyrics of ...' Superb, outstanding, ready for playback, u r beyond something, v r proud of u all'...etc etc... and making them feel special ...how come their control button was not working on that particular day by declaring favourite and offer...looks like Sonakshi is having a control button over music directors...M sorry..but she gave a wrong signal. I did feel very bad for Nithyashree ( especially...this girl...4 the judge gave her the tag of ' ready for playback' which again is wrong on their part...for they didn't bother about how the other kids will b feeling...since judges were careful in their choice of words).

2. Lata Mangeskarji comment - There is nothing wrong if she liked any particular contestant but the judges taking her comment seriously and continuing HER tune on further episodes...harmed Ronita...she just couldn't take it ...yes...she was good but not that good compared to the remaining contestants.

3. Salim...I do like his shower of good words on contestants (since judge role is being good to all) but it looked like he reserved some special words for Nithyashree ( as if he was going to give her an offer in next movie ) thus sending wrong signals to Nitya and audience. Wish he didn't show his extra care...as other kids too were in the game.

All in all...wish the judge were The Judge ...the show would have been much better for the audience as well as the contestants...it would have been a learning experience for the talented singers.

As a viewer...I love all the four remaining contestants...Nahid and Nitya..a bit more...A word for Nitya...giving an average last two performance will definitely not take away the credit of an overall fantastic performance she had given so far...she deserves the title but so do Nahid...Vaishnav and Ananya - I won't be shocked if any of these two win. Best wishes to these four.😃

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sumanthy

@sumanthy

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

I am fully agreed with u@

All the judges should encourage, motivate

& sometime compliment the contestants

That s all!

I am very suprised that Mr Vishal & Ms Sona

openly their favourite is Nahid & they want her

for Akira playback singer!

This is too much!

As a judge, should not have any favourite

& justify fairly!

Disappointed

Singapore Viewer

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sonal99

@Sonal99

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

I think all judges, including established singers, have at some point in the show expressed their extreme likes for some singer.

They are ALL that good!!

Being crowned the winner is by no means the end of the journey.

The real struggle begins after the show.

Before Nahid was pointed out as a favorite; Nityashree and Vaishnav, had already been given the limelight.

As such, there is nothing wrong in Nahid being selected for playback singing for one song. She does indeed have a melodious voice that tugs at one's heart strings. Playback singing is more about feel than it is about being technically brilliant.

They have all had their fair share of being in the limelight at some point in the show. Let us not take away that privilege from Nahid.

Edited by Sonal99 - 10 years ago

Quote

megh12

@megh12

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

this time there seems to be a lot more favoritism from the judges than last time also last time all the kids aged between 10-13 this time theyr almost 16 the only exception being vaishnav whos 13 and his voice still needs to develop a bit it sound quite thin sometimes when compared to to he other 3 this may cause a disadvantage to him as people are thinking he's femenine while others voices are matured by now

Quote

jyothi

@pjyo

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

The show had become all about movie promotions rather than showcasing the kids singing talents,half the time it was the movie stars on stage,even the episodes were preponed /postponed to coincide with movie releases ..Then the kids had to sing songs of these actors promoting their movies thus limiting song choices ,sony should have made more genre based episodes🤔 ,maybe a quawwali,classical ,gazals,golden oldies ...

Sonakshi should have waited till finale episode to offers singing contracts,open favoritism is unfair to the other kids.Seriously,ms sonakshi shouldn't have been a judge in the first place😵, should have been a cheerleader only ..

My favorites -nithyashree only😊..although i agree last few weeks haven't been her best ...while the other kids have upped the ante she seems nervous ..vaishnav is good but still sounds like a girl

Edited by pjyo - 10 years ago

Quote

978187

Hibernated

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Sonal99
I think all judges, including established singers, have at some point in the show expressed their extreme likes for some singer.
They are ALL that good!!

Being crowned the winner is by no means the end of the journey.

The real struggle begins after the show.

Before Nahid was pointed out as a favorite; Nityashree and Vaishnav, had already been given the limelight.

As such, there is nothing wrong in Nahid being selected for playback singing for one song. She does indeed have a melodious voice that tugs at one's heart strings. Playback singing is more about feel than it is about being technically brilliant.

They have all had their fair share of being in the limelight at some point in the show. Let us not take away that privilege from Nahid.

i agree with you . i am still unable to understand why suddenly so much of problem occured with nahid getting an open offer for a movie . it happens a lot of time in many reality shows that a particular singer gets offer even before the competition gets over.

i personally felt nityashree was extremely over hyped during the initial phases of the show . the episode where aman and armaan came . salim openly told them to take nityashree for their next song or something ,but there was no problem from anyone.

salim already took ranita and made her sing a jingle too , still no problem

last week he openly said that he wants ananya to win.

so when there is no problem when others are getting chance and over appericiation , i don't think there is anything wrong if sonakshi ASKED nahid to sing for her and she agreed . vishal also seemed ready for it .

the simple fact NAHID deserve it and she got it . end of topic. ⭐️ . a lot of favoritsm for done for nityashree too .

Quote

978187

Hibernated

Posted: 10 years ago

@TM - i agree that sonakshi is a complete misfit for this show and the same kind of comments are simply boring , i just ignore them .🤢

Quote

ryukie

@ryukie

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Sonal99
I think all judges, including established singers, have at some point in the show expressed their extreme likes for some singer.
They are ALL that good!!

Being crowned the winner is by no means the end of the journey.

The real struggle begins after the show.

Before Nahid was pointed out as a favorite; Nityashree and Vaishnav, had already been given the limelight.

As such, there is nothing wrong in Nahid being selected for playback singing for one song. She does indeed have a melodious voice that tugs at one's heart strings. Playback singing is more about feel than it is about being technically brilliant.

They have all had their fair share of being in the limelight at some point in the show. Let us not take away that privilege from Nahid.

I completely agree with you

Quote

AABHA

@anjalirawat

Beginner

Posted: 10 years ago

There is nothing wrong in nahid getting the chance for playback singing because she deserves it.i don't know why pepole are making this a big issue i really hope she wins the show because she deserves it 😊

Edited by anjalirawat - 10 years ago

Quote

Chitra_11

@Chitra_11

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

😃

Originally posted by: ashvikian4life

i agree with you . i am still unable to understand why suddenly so much of problem occured with nahid getting an open offer for a movie . it happens a lot of time in many reality shows that a particular singer gets offer even before the competition gets over.

i personally felt nityashree was extremely over hyped during the initial phases of the show . the episode where aman and armaan came . salim openly told them to take nityashree for their next song or something ,but there was no problem from anyone.

salim already took ranita and made her sing a jingle too , still no problem

last week he openly said that he wants ananya to win.

so when there is no problem when others are getting chance and over appericiation , i don't think there is anything wrong if sonakshi ASKED nahid to sing for her and she agreed . vishal also seemed ready for it .

the simple fact NAHID deserve it and she got it . end of topic. ⭐️ . a lot of favoritsm for done for nityashree too .

There...U said it all....and that is the reason for my topic...' A better show WITHOUT...'...all the additional things that u mentioned above.

I have a feeling...my post gave a wrong impression dear...am not good at expressing...kindly reread my post...as this post can be made ONLY after watching all the events that took place...as the show is nearing its end and not before or in the middle...this has got nothing to do with the deserving candidate Nahid / Nithyashree....the post is more for the Judge to be just - THE JUDGE...and the role that should be played by them...but then as someone rightly pointed out...it is a reality show...and I am here JUST expressing my point...for participants and a better show.

Let me add...would be happy if Nahid or Nitya wins as according to me both are fab...kindly read my previous comment..to clear ur doubt and my liking towards my fav 2...here is the link https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/indian-idol-junior-season-2/4457153/hain-performer-of-the-day?pn=2😃

Hope it explains what I want to convey...my best wishes to ALL four😃

Quote

1 2

A better show WITHOUT......

Related Topics

Explore Topics