8.12.15 - Ke tera yahan koi nahin..

RestlessWriter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

It honestly feels as though the CVs and makers of Tere Sheher Mein are singing that famous song, "yeh Galliyan yeh chaubara, yahan aana na dobara ke tera yahan koi nahi.. Ke tera yahan koi nahi" to the fans of this show.

What else do they accomplish by showing such a twisted plot? Mantu messages Amaya to return his dad's watch in anger. He even tells Uma the same. Uma being the scheming b***h that she is, sends Amaya a couple of messages of her own from Mantu's phone asking her to return the dress, that he had lovingly bought for someone else more important to him, as well. And if that weren't enough, she calls up Amaya too and taunts her to no end and smirks in what she thinks is her victory. And what does Amaya do? She cries buckets and buckets for her lost love and then gets angry that how date he demand his things back in such a fashion. Because, you nutcase, you've been acting like a moron to him for no apparent reason for the past few days. Is he supposed to have a divine intervention to know all by himself that you love him and the only reason you are behaving like a psycho is because an educated, modern, smart, Paris return girl like you has suddenly been possessed by the soul of a deceased desi soap queen who feels it more necessary to prove her love to a scheming b***h than confess her love to the one she loves. And also that maybe sometime during the Sharavn pooja race, you hit your head on a rock and your brain fell out and you never bothered to find it so you've decided that even talking to Mantu normally is off limits for you because of an idiotic oath and you've been doing nothing at all except ignoring him and then giving him puppy eyed looks. What part of any of this makes any sense to you, Amaya Mathur?

And then Amaya decides she is going to return the things right then and walks out into the storm. I was supposed to feel bad for you but I feel nothing but anger. Mantu at least showed his concern and asked you why you took the trouble this late at night and in this brewing storm. But instead of telling him the truth (since you think you lost your bet with Uma, aren't you free from your stupid oath?) you decide to talk in circles. Heck! When you returned to dress, if you'd only said, you wanted this back too, right? Mantu would've said he never sent the text, you could've shown the text you got and the two of you could've put two and two together or at least, you could have made use of the empty space where your brain once resided and figured out the dirty tricks Uma was playing. If Uma is allowed to play dirty tricks to win, shouldn't you at least try to stay in the game Amaya? Your fatalistic attitude has started to sicken me as much as Uma's scheming and plotting.

And I was supposed to feel all kinds of sorry for the two lovers as they part but I felt nothing. If you think my rant was heavily biased towards Amaya, you are right. Mantu knows nothing about what's happened between the girls. He doesn't really have a lot of reason to doubt Uma. His biggest and probably only fault is that he trusts Uma a bit too much and he fell into her trap and did not confess to Amaya in time. On the other hand, Amaya has no bullcrap reason whatsoever to trust Uma or to prove her love or anything and yet she maintains such an irritating silence and plays the victim card way too much for my liking.

Rachita and Rama on the other hand are such a stark contrast to these too. Her own Nanaji, and Rachita knows his temper and temperament and the issues they've faced in the past coz of his taunts, places restrictions on them meeting boys but she has no qualms as she goes to meet Rama. Rama has already suffered a rather rude rejection from Rachia but does not give a damn as he goes all out to woo her. Amaya and Mantu need to learn the workings of love from these two.

Rudra and Dev's plan will spell doom for one couple but I think will only serve to bring Rama and Rachita closer because Amaya and Mantu, especially Amaya, is ready to assume the worst at a drop of the hat. I kept saying the astrologer that Uma and Amaya went to might be fake but maybe he was right, maybe the whole universe is against Amaya and Mantu's love and the sad part is, despite her tall claims otherwise, Amaya is doing nothing at all, zilch, to fight their fate.

I'm so thoroughly disappointed and let down by Amaya's character and this show in general, I might take a break from it. Wake me up when Amaya finds her lost brains!

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.9k

Users

10

Likes

68

Frequent Posters

ScarletNiki thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Never agreed more! Taking a break till I get some positive news from this forum 😭
TheAphrodite thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Well the episode isn't any better .

These are easily dismissible 'obstacles' . I don't empathize with Mantu or Amaaya anymore .

Rama and Rachita are incredibly strong and sorted characters wow . They're fit to be leads !

This show is majorly slacking , that's all I can say at the moment .

More like ' Sau Dard Hain , Sau Raahatein' Oh wait . No Raahatein . -.-
Edited by TheAphrodite - 10 years ago
tejaswiniwenham thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Preach. i started my break already. i don't even know why i bother with hindi soaps, they're all crap and the problem with 'different' shows is that they don't really know how to be conventional or different. mantu and amu have no spark left and amu has no character left, idk who this dukhiari nari is but she definitely isn't why i watched this show. rama and rachi are MARVELOUS, they should have a spinoff. i will say one thing though, love or not amaya hasn't been rude to mantu so i don't understand his attitude towards her, he's not entitled to amu's love just cos he loves her. did he love her with the expectation that she'd love him back, otherwise they can't be friends? so i don't understand why he's mad that she doesn't love him. he should learn something from rama, thats love-relentless, no ego and thats why I'm confident ramashrey dulhania le jaayenge! 100% agree with what you said about rachita. she doesn't even realize her love for rama and defies nana to see him and amu's 'epic' love can't even stand upto uma cos she's got some crazy zidh to prove. the show would do well with giving RaRa more screen time and reducing uma and even ManYa cos they're unbearable, id gladly watch dev plotting for a change. but alas!
loveleen12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Sad that today also proved to be disappointment, and don't blame you for honestly wanting to go on a break.

Some of us are still gonna try to hold on sadly until next week with the completion of 150 episodes hoping that it will bring something good for Mantu and Amaya.

I thought that atleast today Uma wouldn't be involved in the issue, but no Mantu has to tell her every thing that he does or is about to do as if she is his love guru. I personally wanted to see Mantu ask for his dad's watch, and Amaya return the dress on her own accord. Is she still gonna cry heaps for stupid Uma's nonsense? I don't understand why she cares. Honestly speaking even beyond these misunderstandings, if Mantu indeed didn't love Amaya and Uma had won, then Amaya could still go to her and say that she doesn't care. Her love wasn't supposed to be a competition and even after "losing" she will continue to love Mantu and be his true friend. If only Amaya would do this...

I have said enough about Mantu in other posts, there is something called trust and something called blind trust. It isn't even about trusting Uma actually, it is about not involving her in every petty matter. Why can't he for once deal with the issue by himself? I don't care that he perhaps goes to Uma for comfort, but this is ultimately his and Amaya's issue so she doesn't need to know all the details.

I might be bashing Mantu a bit more, but I just feel that he didn't give Amaya a chance. My issue with him is more than the confessing his love part. That is something completely different, and both Amaya and Mantu are wrong for assuming things and just not making an effort. But when Mantu figured that Amaya doesn't love him, he decided to break all ties with Amaya. A lot of people may say that this is because Uma has been manipulating him, but his bitterness towards Amaya started when she didn't tell him to renew his contract. Honestly even at that point Amaya said that she would want what is best for him so I don't understand why he acted as if she broke his delicate little heart.

He just doesn't trust Amaya enough, at least not like Amaya trusts him and I don't seem to understand why. Maybe he is confused, but saying things like you are rich city-girl and will never understand friendship and relationships when he knows her in and out is a little too harsh on his part. If he has shared some of the most intimate things about his life with her, than she too has told him everything some things that not even her family know. Maybe he is hurt, but Amaya was hurt too when Mantu left her after she played with her life to win the Amar Jodi race. It was unintentional on his part, but she isn't intending to hurt him now either.

It is sad to see that Mantu doesn't even want her as a friend when his reasoning to not confess was so that he doesn't lose her friendship.

Rama and Rachita are completely different, both stories were supposed to be fresh, but the makers decided to make this a bhagya ka khel type love saga.

RestlessWriter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: loveleen12

Sad that today also proved to be disappointment, and don't blame you for honestly wanting to go on a break.

Some of us are still gonna try to hold on sadly until next week with the completion of 150 episodes hoping that it will bring something good for Mantu and Amaya.

I thought that atleast today Uma wouldn't be involved in the issue, but no Mantu has to tell her every thing that he does or is about to do as if she is his love guru. I personally wanted to see Mantu ask for his dad's watch, and Amaya return the dress on her own accord. Is she still gonna cry heaps for stupid Uma's nonsense? I don't understand why she cares. Honestly speaking even beyond these misunderstandings, if Mantu indeed didn't love Amaya and Uma had won, then Amaya could still go to her and say that she doesn't care. Her love wasn't supposed to be a competition and even after "losing" she will continue to love Mantu and be his true friend. If only Amaya would do this...

I have said enough about Mantu in other posts, there is something called trust and something called blind trust. It isn't even about trusting Uma actually, it is about not involving her in every petty matter. Why can't he for once deal with the issue by himself? I don't care that he perhaps goes to Uma for comfort, but this is ultimately his and Amaya's issue so she doesn't need to know all the details.

I might be bashing Mantu a bit more, but I just feel that he didn't give Amaya a chance. My issue with him is more than the confessing his love part. That is something completely different, and both Amaya and Mantu are wrong for assuming things and just not making an effort. But when Mantu figured that Amaya doesn't love him, he decided to break all ties with Amaya. A lot of people may say that this is because Uma has been manipulating him, but his bitterness towards Amaya started when she didn't tell him to renew his contract. Honestly even at that point Amaya said that she would want what is best for him so I don't understand why he acted as if she broke his delicate little heart.

He just doesn't trust Amaya enough, at least not like Amaya trusts him and I don't seem to understand why. Maybe he is confused, but saying things like you are rich city-girl and will never understand friendship and relationships when he knows her in and out is a little too harsh on his part. If he has shared some of the most intimate things about his life with her, than she too has told him everything some things that not even her family know. Maybe he is hurt, but Amaya was hurt too when Mantu left her after she played with her life to win the Amar Jodi race. It was unintentional on his part, but she isn't intending to hurt him now either.

It is sad to see that Mantu doesn't even want her as a friend when his reasoning to not confess was so that he doesn't lose her friendship.

Rama and Rachita are completely different, both stories were supposed to be fresh, but the makers decided to make this a bhagya ka khel type love saga.





I see your point about how Mantu oscillates between having complete blind trust in Uma and having not as much in Amaya. But I feel he did trust Amaya because even when Uma would spew venom about Amaya initially, he would always tell her that I trust Amaya and I've seen it in her eyes and I know she loves me. Maybe I'm looking at things from just Mantu's perspective and not from Amaya's perspective. Since Mantu is completely unaware of what's been going on behind his back, think about it.. He and Amaya are friends and perhaps a lot more than friends and they love spending time together - at office and outside. Mantu realizes he has feelings for her beyond friendship and it's the day he gets to choose whether he wants to stay in the office or not. He asks Amaya and she brushes him off with "why are you asking me? You should do what's best for you." She doesn't say a single word to stop him. Abruptly, she stops texting him or calling him. The next day, he goes to brig her back during the strike but she goes with Rudra instead of him. When he beats up the goons who tease her, she yells at him asking why it should matter to him what they say/do to her. She does not invite him to the pooja and instead says Mom has called you. He still invites her to his pooja but (to him) she does not come. And when he asks for his dad's watch, she returns the dress too. What is he supposed to make of it all? I feel like more than being in love, Mantu just wanted a sign from Amaya, like he so often said, that he mattered to her and that's where she failed. I feel if she'd given the slightest indication that he mattered to her, Mantu wouldn't have minded even if she did not love him and would've been happy just being her friend. That's where I think Amaya, in her zid to prove her love to Uma, failed Mantu miserably. And also the reason why I have more resentment towards Amaya's character than Mantu's.

And yes, Uma's manipulations have a major part to play in Mantu losing his trust on Amaya. But again, like I said, maybe I'm looking at things only from or way too much from Mantu's perspective. Like you said, he should've at least suspected something fishy was going on behind her weird behavior and tried to find out instead of mopping around and playing these mind games. *Sigh*


Edited by neet06 - 10 years ago
RestlessWriter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

So I forced myself to go back and watch the rest of the episode and I must admit, the scene with Rama's parents arguing was hilarious. The actor who plays Rama's father is simply superb! He portrays the innate sarcastic, dry humor sense of the character so perfectly! But the purpose of the scene was to set the stage for the future. The way Rama's mom arm twisted his poor dad was to show us that she wasn't a character to be taken lightly in the story. And we know from the spoilers that she is going to unleash her wrath on the Mathur-Chaubey clan soon. Let's see how that goes.

And I know I said I was going to take a break from the show but I plan on reading written updates and watching it on and off so I'll probably still be around with my rants and raves. Part of the reason I had this change of mind is because i had to step outside to run an errand and of all the songs on my playlist in shuffle mode, the song that started playing was Laal ishq.. And that brought back the scene where Mantu sneaks in to see Amaya at night and I realized I couldn't give up just yet. *sigh* I know.. I'm a hopeless optimist at times!

clary thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Could you write something optimistic on your expectations for next week's grand ManYa scene. Have a loook at Alia's post and then if possible, could you write something like an OS on it?? 😉
I can understand..ManYa are hard to resist ❤️ 😆
RestlessWriter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: NiRajCraZey

Could you write something optimistic on your expectations for next week's grand ManYa scene. Have a loook at Alia's post and then if possible, could you write something like an OS on it?? 😉

I can understand..ManYa are hard to resist ❤️ 😆



I have no idea, yet, how we could go from the warring ManYa to a "hot" ManYa by next week but I'll definitely think about it and post it as soon as something comes up! 😊
clary thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: neet06



I have no idea, yet, how we could go from the warring ManYa to a "hot" ManYa by next week but I'll definitely think about it and post it as soon as something comes up! 😊


Lets not think about that..It depends on the mahan brain of the cvs which I hope they have 😆

Think of something..The hot Manya is whats something which should be on our minds 😉 ❤️

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".