Snape:Truly evil?

Okay. So what do you think?

Personally, I think Snape and Dumbledore had a big plan all worked out--remember their fight in the Forest that Hagrid mentions to the Trio? Maybe it was because Snape didn't want to kill DD, but Dumbledore was reminding him that he had to do it.

And remember how Dumbledore only took Harry along with him to find the Horcruxes when he promised to follow whatever DD said, even if he didn't want to? Methinks Dumbledore made Snape promise him the same thing...

PS: Some of the poll 'choices' reflect my poor version of humor. Ignore them if you get confused.😛

lol...sorry, but that was too funny to pass up

S'ok. After all, the ship wars in the HP fandom have gotten way too serious, I thought some humor was needed...

Good to see someone (else) thought it was funny too! 😉

And yeah Mistystar! Go R/H!! Ron/Hermione forevaa!!!

😛

ah i love humor...the more the better...wherever there is humor, i will be there 😆

I always stood firm and will say again that although I hate Snape with intense passion, I think he and Dumbledore concocted up a scheme to have Snape "kill" Dumbledore to show Voldemort that Snape is actually loyal to him and truly still is a Death Eater.

But in actual fact he is a true member of the Order....that is just me wanting it to be this way but I could be wrong. Even is Snape is loyal to Dumbledore, I still will not endear myself to him cos of what he has been putting Harry through. I hate him, loathe him, despise him....all the hate words in the dictionary put together.

very imaginative options... 😊
see i definitely think it's VERY fishy that dumbledore should have been arguing with snape in the first place... but i do not feel that dumbledore is still alive... no... 😆

actually i think tht the second and third one r sum wht similar....

Umm, what I meant with the third option was that Dumbledore is still alive. And in hiding somewhere--which means that the white tomb is empty, and Hagrid had to have been in on The Plot.

And what I meant with the second one was that Dumbledore is dead, but that it wasn't that he was actually killed, but that he sacrificed himself for the Cause, and he had Snape 'kill' him so that Voldy would think Snape was a loyal little Death Eater.

See, it was way too long to fit into that tiny little box I was given for writing the options--that accounts for the confusion... 😉

ohh..... thankx 4 explain me tht 😃

i personally think tht snape is not truly evil donno why but then the situations and circumstances are always different we can never guess in novels because the author will alwayz write sumthing which is not quite obvious so tht people can say tht this novel is different and so jk did the same don't you think we could never think tht dum wud die and rather wude be killed by none other than snape so i think there will be a climax quite different from wht we have thought 😃