I liked your post, something to discuss other than the sad exits today. It is nice when we have difference of opinion. Atleast there is something to discuss. I agree I agree posts I don't know how to go forward with the post. Let it not build up in you and out in one post. Rather this is a forum so discuss makes it lighter with everyday replies to post. I don't think for that quits and byes are required by anyone. Nice to see all of you are frank but yes we should restraint ourselves.
I would like to add something in your last line
Juhi too has excelled even if she had only 1 dialogue or one emotion to project. She has done in more than 1 situation during the time when Renuka got her kidnapped. Her 1 dialogue and one emotion changed in its intensity as the days passed by and went aggressive to after knowing there was a duplicate in this world. During Manik time also there were few scenes like that. The firm kumkum during Sumit Brain Tumor. During the Nivi track when she time and again see Sumit with Nivi and goes cold. Then now with the lost memory trouble look she too has excelled. The 1 different dialogue for her love for sumit in all these situations had different colors, style, emotions, expressions and voice. So this time they decided to strike it off in her script lines
Same goes for Hussain has excelled even if he had only 1 dialogue or one emotion to project, when he knew from Abhay that Kumkum is dead and this is Chanda, Kumkum Brain Tumor, the Nivideta Track and now again in this track.
Hussain excels in various roles and get-ups too, the recent one was finding the evidence against Nivideta to save Kumkum.
Both Hussain and Juhi so many times had the same situations but with the same and different environments they both have put their creative best and has shown their versatility. Each acting against themselves and each other are so unique to have etched in my mind.
Now coming back to the current track, I too felt the same for some hidden feelings but I also wanted something different from movies so maybe they decided that she has a completely wiped off memory. New slate where Sumit can start helping her to fill it. I think it is something different then movies than I know of. Maybe there is a movie with such wiped off memory without hidden feelings.
Mann ki aankho dialogue was meant for her sisters as she was playing blindfold games with her sisters not with Sanjay. You will always tell your youngers that what she told. It was not meant for Sanjay.
That is nice atleast with everyone crying and calling for her she doesnt feel the goosebumps because like that they have added another shade to kumkum character and everyone will forgive her because she has lost her memory and the way she is crying in her heart for her family not come to take her from last 1 year. I have forgiven Sumit during the Kumkum kidnap situation when kumkum called for him. I felt when he knew kumkum so well why why why he could not differ Chanda and kumkum. But that is the situation of duplicate which left without recognizing kumkum nor could hear kumkum pukaar for him. Same could be said during the Salil, Yash and Nivideta tracks which bought different shades out. This enriched the shade to Sumits character. Here too the team has given Hussian and Juhi similar situations but different environments to perform. That what makes Hussian and Juhi going strong in kumkum. Touchwood for that. In every track different shades were out for the character and for the artists which enriched the character and the artists.
It was too quick for another love triangle after the Nivideta track but I am going with it now because the Krishna Sanjay chemistry is really getting better and nicer. So I am for it. From this week I felt for her helplessness.
Today I felt for Sanjay too because he goes out of his way to see that Krishna know her identity so that he can see her happy
Sumit had definitely repetitive dialogues but he had plenty to do with his emotions even though if he no different scenes. I am still crying for him. He had something to do today but alas the writers made him go blank while reading the newspaper.
This is just my opinion of this whole current track. Maybe by now I have got used to forgiving them. Sigh.
Edited by surakshita - 17 years ago
Book Talk
Ye Hai Mohabbatein
