prashant rocked the final - Page 2

Originally posted by: wasim007

I totally agree

AMIT sang both the songs including BULLA better than original.

Prashant trashed Himesh's ashiq banaya with his "too sweetened " voice

thas ur opinion dear again for me i think amit spoiled both tanhayi and humma humma..but prshant rocked all threee songs....hurrey

Originally posted by: rabin123

don't compare Prashant speaking hindi with how he sings(he sounds weird while speaking hindi since, he only speaks Nepali at home)... if you are saying he is beshura then, whydid AC gave him 10 out of 10 for the 2nd song(badhi muskil hai), JA said flawless and, AM said you are capable for the title... judges gave good comments for his 2nd song(they could have praised more but, they didn't)... what about the songs he sang(Bheegi Hont Tere, Rind Posh Maal, 1942 song, earlier round songs)... when he made a small mistake they pointed out the mistake even though he sang it pretty good. Listen to their comments for the Amit's 1st song(Hamma Hamma of Amit was not even close to it's original... compare it yourself by listening to both)... no comments on the 2nd song of Amit since, I have not heard it before(Prashant should not have selected the song and, Amit should not have accepted the song... it is hard to judge a song from a different language, if you don't know the language you can just comment on the melody)... 3rd song Amit did not even sing(he lost it completely... even after catching up after the paragraph he forgot, his confidence was not there anymore since, he was thinking about it the whole time). Amit is a good singer but, for the finals he did not perform... if you are judging by earlier performace then, don't even watch the finals just vote. If you watch the finals then vote according to how they performed on the finals. Host(Mini) and, the judges have made a joke out of finals with their biased comments. Look at Prashant who pulled in Amit to sing together the last lines of the 3rd song(after bringing the sur back to that song, it is very hard to bring the sur back when the sur is completely off, even Prashant took some time before catching the right sur)... public judge yourself who was the beshura on the finals(Where was all the sur, taal and words for Amit on the 3rd song).

1.u say judges pointed out small mistakes of Prashant & were biased........so why do u count the judges opinion when AC gave 10 out of 10.Judges are only good when they give Prashant good comments & are biased when he doesnt?

2.u don't know bulla ki jana,but it seems the judges & even Prashant knows the song .it may be hard for u to judge but not them.

3.Prashant didnt bring back any sur,infact Prashant was off-key.

Originally posted by: rabin123

don't compare Prashant speaking hindi with how he sings(he sounds weird while speaking hindi since, he only speaks Nepali at home)... if you are saying he is beshura then, why did AC gave him 10 out of 10 for the 2nd song(badhi muskil hai), JA said flawless and, AM said you are capable for the title... judges gave good comments for his 2nd song(they could have praised more but, they didn't)... what about the songs he sang(Bheegi Hont Tere, Rind Posh Maal, 1942 song, earlier round songs)... when he made a small mistake they pointed out the mistake even though he sang it pretty good. Listen to their comments for the Amit's 1st song(Hamma Hamma of Amit was not even close to it's original... compare it yourself by listening to both)... no comments on the 2nd song of Amit since, I have not heard it before(Prashant should not have selected the song and, Amit should not have accepted the song... it is hard to judge a song from a different language, if you don't know the language you can just comment on the melody)... 3rd song Amit did not even sing(he lost it completely... even after catching up after the paragraph he forgot, his confidence was not there anymore since, he was thinking about it the whole time). Amit is a good singer but, for the finals he did not perform... if you are judging by earlier performace then, don't even watch the finals just vote. If you watch the finals then vote according to how they performed on the finals. Host(Mini) and, the judges have made a joke out of finals with their biased comments. Look at Prashant who pulled in Amit to sing together the last lines of the 3rd song(after bringing the sur back to that song, it is very hard to bring the sur back when the sur is completely off, even Prashant took some time before catching the right sur)... public judge yourself who was the beshura on the finals(Where was all the sur, taal and words for Amit on the 3rd song).

AMIT sang all his songs inlcding BULLA and HAMMA beter than original.

I have never seen prashant sing well. No one has. Prashant has nothing .

what about songs of prashant????

none of them are good . 1942 --that song was also ...bheegi hot that too.

No one ever saw Prashant sing well.

he is the worst contestant of II3.

AMIT sang the the first 2 songs better than Prashant. He sang all his songs better than prashant. He sang even TANHAYEE with a better voice. Prashant has a garbage voice quality

Originally posted by: crazy_x

1.u say judges pointed out small mistakes of Prashant & were biased........so why do u count the judges opinion when AC gave 10 out of 10.Judges are only good when they give Prashant good comments & are biased when he doesnt?

2.u don't know bulla ki jana,but it seems the judges & even Prashant knows the song .it may be hard for u to judge but not them.

3.Prashant didnt bring back any sur,infact Prashant was off-key.

Prashant is a total trash singer with horribel voice quality.

I have never seen him sung well

Indian Idol 3 judges are jokers. I don't want to point the guys name but he is from Bangledesh. He supports Amit only because Amit is bengali not because he is a good singer. So, it is pointless to agrue with racist people. Racist people are blind. They are brain washed. So, it doesn't worth to change their mind and they will never change. The sun may raise from west but racist brain wash people will never change.

Originally posted by: musica_1

PRASHANT ROCKS!!!

YES, PRASHANT ROCKS

Originally posted by: wasim007

Prashant is a total trash singer with horribel voice quality.

I have never seen him sung well

I was trying to point out the biasness of the judges... listen to the comments of AC & JA for the 2nd song of Prashant... AC says 10 out of 10 and no more additional appreciation, JA says flawless with no extra appreciation... if the judges did not like his 2nd song then just say it was not good... why give high marks without extra appreciation where as, for other contestants there are always extra appreciation when they sing well.

Prashant a trash singer is just your opinion(you don't know how to appreciate others hard work... I don't think you would be able to even stand up on that stage let alone sing a single line)... This is a competion and, if you cannot perform then you don't deserve it... Amit did not even sing the 3rd song... if you go back look at the video clips you will find that Amit forgot the song twice not only once... we are talking about the finals not the other rounds. India may beat other teams by 100 runs in other rounds of the cricket match but, cannot score 100 runs in the final then, will the competition declare India winner on the basis of earlier performance???

Since, being a Amit fan if you think all the songs Prashant sang was trash then, I can also say the same that all the songs Amit sang is trash and he is the most beshura singer I have ever seen... learn how to appreciate others talent, not just the one you like.

Go and watch today's clips of support for both Amit & Prashant, from all over India and, they are not only from Darjeeling or Sikkim or Meghalaya.

This is just a game so, let the results come out who ever wins let us move on... rule is that public votes and, whoever gets more votes wins.

Prashant is going to win.

Public is supporting him. every one know that Judges are biased and even the hosts.

So Prashant is the winner

I thought there were to be no more posts bashing either of the contestants. This is so sad!

No posts comparing who is better and who is worst.

Both are great thats why are they are at this point today.