prashant rocked the final

akshay gupta thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Seeing yesterdays final gala anyone can easily notice that prashant was far better than amit... This is the final show and even single mistakes cannot be excused...... Will bharat ki janta choose the idol who forgot the lyrics not once but twice..... I think such a big mistake in the finals(also in the wild card)really puts backward than prashant.... one thing is sure that he is the looser at the final and the winner is one who finishes with the style and that is prashant..............

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.4k

Users

14

Frequent Posters

lrllover thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
will bharat ki janta choose an idol who was not in sur for most of the galas???????
or will they choose someone who has been consistent and have got amazing comments and standing ovations

by the way as far as lyrics are concerned both the finalists had forgotten their lyrics
Edited by lrllover - 18 years ago
addyydda thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Amit has redefined consistency..
Even the best in other shows have had bad days..but not Amit in the galas..
Amit will make us proud... Hope he wins this time..He so deserves the title now.
I support AMIT..Do you?
Yes? then what are u waiting for.....

SMS AMIT to 52525.
Or Vote via Landline dial 19024242525 01 (MTNL/BSNL)
MONICA0819 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: akshay gupta

Seeing yesterdays final gala anyone can easily notice that prashant was far better than amit... This is the final show and even single mistakes cannot be excused...... Will bharat ki janta choose the idol who forgot the lyrics not once but twice..... I think such a big mistake in the finals(also in the wild card)really puts backward than prashant.... one thing is sure that he is the looser at the final and the winner is one who finishes with the style and that is prashant..............



TOTALLY DISAGREE.... IN THE FINAL IT WAS PARSHANT WHO DID THE MISTAKE FIRST, AMIT DID THE MISTAKE IN TANHAYEE, BUT HE SOUND VERY GOOD B'CS OF HIS MANLY VOICE..
ZHCool thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
amit is totally off key in finale

and prashant rocked the show
😃 😃 😃
harirana1 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
I totally disagree with monica..... coz there is big diffrence between forgetting single word and forgetting the whole line..... don't u see that amit was singing without lyrics for more than 15 sec..
chance is given only once not which was already given in wild card...
maraizaa thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: lrllover

will bharat ki janta choose an idol who was not in sur for most of the galas???????
or will they choose someone who has been consistent and have got amazing comments and standing ovations

by the way as far as lyrics are concerned both the finalists had forgotten their lyrics

i dont buy wat u just said bout judges amazing comments and standing ovations.....same judges always find somethg to say to prashant even tho he sings excellent and same judges dont want to praise him from their heart even when he outstand Amit paul..coz they dont want ppl to think prashant can sing better than amit...

and ppl here even tho they know how judges comment on contestant they bring up judges good comments to support amit..which in my point of view is joker's comment.all i believe is ppl's vote and in the end thats wat matters...

when amit couldnt sing on wildcard round same judges said " janta bachaye to bachaye hum nahi bachayege" where did his good singin even tho he forgot his lyrics went that time..i thought his chal chale was mindblowin that time...but same judges can say that then and now they support him no matter wat..i dont think this is right....

if amit's bhulla ki waS amazing then wat bout prashant's badi muskil..it was flawless too...i think even he was supposed to get standin oviation but judges just said flawless singin and done no more to say coz they dont want to praise him...

tanhayi was sung by prashant very very outstandin but all the judges just said amit gana bhul gaya so hisab barabar..why didnt they have guts to say but prashant sang this one very good...except AM. were they scared that ppl will start to think prashant was better than amit???

so pl ppl...i'm not choosin anyone but dont go with judges comments here...we saw judges comments in emon's case...dipali's case and much more like alisha blindly supporting suhit and chang...

both guys have worked very hard...amit was good all the time...if u get 90 out of 90 all the time then its not improvement but if u got 50 out of 100 1st time and 70 out of 100 2nd and 90 out of 100 3rd time thaS called the true improvement...which prashant did...thas where ur consistency comes..

wasim007 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: akshay gupta

Seeing yesterdays final gala anyone can easily notice that prashant was far better than amit... This is the final show and even single mistakes cannot be excused...... Will bharat ki janta choose the idol who forgot the lyrics not once but twice..... I think such a big mistake in the finals(also in the wild card)really puts backward than prashant.... one thing is sure that he is the looser at the final and the winner is one who finishes with the style and that is prashant..............

Prashant has never sung well in any GALA /FINAL

His first 2 songs were sooo mediocre.

AMIT rocked the FINAL

wasim007 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: MONICA0819



TOTALLY DISAGREE.... IN THE FINAL IT WAS PARSHANT WHO DID THE MISTAKE FIRST, AMIT DID THE MISTAKE IN TANHAYEE, BUT HE SOUND VERY GOOD B'CS OF HIS MANLY VOICE..

I totally agree

AMIT sang both the songs including BULLA better than original.

Prashant trashed Himesh's ashiq banaya with his "too sweetened " voice

rabin123 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
don't compare Prashant speaking hindi with how he sings(he sounds weird while speaking hindi since, he only speaks Nepali at home)... if you are saying he is beshura then, why did AC gave him 10 out of 10 for the 2nd song(badhi muskil hai), JA said flawless and, AM said you are capable for the title... judges gave good comments for his 2nd song(they could have praised more but, they didn't)... what about the songs he sang(Bheegi Hont Tere, Rind Posh Maal, 1942 song, earlier round songs)... when he made a small mistake they pointed out the mistake even though he sang it pretty good. Listen to their comments for the Amit's 1st song(Hamma Hamma of Amit was not even close to it's original... compare it yourself by listening to both)... no comments on the 2nd song of Amit since, I have not heard it before(Prashant should not have selected the song and, Amit should not have accepted the song... it is hard to judge a song from a different language, if you don't know the language you can just comment on the melody)... 3rd song Amit did not even sing(he lost it completely... even after catching up after the paragraph he forgot, his confidence was not there anymore since, he was thinking about it the whole time). Amit is a good singer but, for the finals he did not perform... if you are judging by earlier performace then, don't even watch the finals just vote. If you watch the finals then vote according to how they performed on the finals. Host(Mini) and, the judges have made a joke out of finals with their biased comments. Look at Prashant who pulled in Amit to sing together the last lines of the 3rd song(after bringing the sur back to that song, it is very hard to bring the sur back when the sur is completely off, even Prashant took some time before catching the right sur)... public judge yourself who was the beshura on the finals(Where was all the sur, taal and words for Amit on the 3rd song).
Edited by rabin123 - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".