I want them to JUDGE AND SCORE Subhreet just like everyone else! :)

Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Hi there. Okay guys I know my previous posts have been taken lightly I mean in a joking manner or amusing or whatever but this time I'm serious and here with a proper serious post.
Okay so I've noticed this ever since the show started and many of you must have too.

I really feel for Subhreet as a person. In terms of emotions etc. Anyone would. But then I'm not a judge. In fact her story is really REALLY inspiring that never give up and get back and move on with life. Don't give up ever. She should be really proud of herself for what she does!

BUT BUT BUT!

Just like all the other contestants I want her to be voted on her ability to dance as she IS on one leg. Which is a huge thing! 👏 I really genuinely feel judges, audience and everyone else SYMPATHISE WITH HER. Which isn't fair. To her, and to everyone else participating.

It's not the right way to go on.

She herself said she wants to be in the show judged and performing on her one leg as she is and show her talent BASED ON THAT!

I don't see why that's not possible or fair.

I feel judges over score her, don't have much realistic improvement points or any flaws which EVERYONE's perfomances have!!!!

I'm nobody to pick those and don't know how but I know the judges do and you can clearly tell they don't say it or give the slightest hint unka dil rakhne ke liye! 😳

When it comes to the judges (back to my first words in the post) you don't just think as a normal human being with loads of emotions etc BUT you think as a emotionless technical or straightforward judge who is not partial and judges everyone on individuality ONLY! There's no partiality whatsoever!

I feel bad for Subhreet now. Not because of her disability. (That makes me proud of such people ⭐️) BUT the way people are lying to her or telling her things to keep her happy and basically cheating her because that way she won't get a chance to learn and improve just like everyone else in the competition. She's too strong for any sympathy. Mark my words.

No harsh feelings for this woman. Now I hardly see posts on her perfomances or in the show any improvements comments. No just no? Just because everyone wants her happy and cheats her unknowingly?

Not fair.

Even the audience are cheating her.

IF YOU feel she's not performing up to the par in the show then don't vote for her vote for a deserving one. If she gets eliminated let her. Because that's the ONLY way this competition will be fair and not bias or sympathetic. That's the most truthful and honest approach for this wonderful woman. Show her she's just as good and EQUAL as the others. There's no point of colors not eliminating her in the future just for the sake of TRPS or sympathy because that's pure cheap. Cheapness at it's best Chii.

I'm not saying she deserves to be eliminated right now but in the future if she does then my request to the audience don't be sympathetic be fair! Subhreet has chosen this show for a reason. She's here to show she's not less than anyone. She could have chosen another show where there would be lots more easier ways to win or go further in the competition but not she wants to be just at the same competitive level as these pros or celebs or whatever!

That's all I had to say. Hope you like my post. No harsh feelings once again. Do comment and like and share YOUR personal view. Would love to see it. God bless. :)

Thanks.

-PP

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

1.8k

Users

18

Likes

65

Frequent Posters

rachuroxxx thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
I just the same thing abt shubhreet in some other post. Yes judging her on d basis of her handicap situation n n over scoring her for simple mediocre perfrmances is both Unfair for herself and also other normal contestants.
the judges leaves no room for her improvement , no constructive criticism for her..
and how long they will continue with in this competition
meenji22 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
totally agree with you both
meenji22 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: pinkpearl5

Hi there. Okay guys I know my previous posts have been taken lightly I mean in a joking manner or amusing or whatever but this time I'm serious and here with a proper serious post.

Okay so I've noticed this ever since the show started and many of you must have too.

I really feel for Subhreet as a person. In terms of emotions etc. Anyone would. But then I'm not a judge. In fact her story is really REALLY inspiring that never give up and get back and move on with life. Don't give up ever. She should be really proud of herself for what she does!

BUT BUT BUT!

Just like all the other contestants I want her to be voted on her ability to dance as she IS on one leg. Which is a huge thing!👏I really genuinely feel judges, audience and everyone else SYMPATHISE WITH HER. Which isn't fair. To her, and to everyone else participating.

It's not the right way to go on.

She herself said she wants to be in the show judged and performing on her one leg as she is and show her talent BASED ON THAT!

I don't see why that's not possible or fair.

I feel judges over score her, don't have much realistic improvement points or any flaws which EVERYONE's perfomances have!!!!

I'm nobody to pick those and don't know how but I know the judges do and you can clearly tell they don't say it or give the slightest hint unka dil rakhne ke liye!😳

When it comes to the judges (back to my first words in the post) you don't just think as a normal human being with loads of emotions etc BUT you think as a emotionless technical or straightforward judge who is not partial and judges everyone on individuality ONLY! There's no partiality whatsoever!

I feel bad for Subhreet now. Not because of her disability. (That makes me proud of such people⭐️) BUT the way people are lying to her or telling her things to keep her happy and basically cheating her because that way she won't get a chance to learn and improve just like everyone else in the competition. She's too strong for any sympathy. Mark my words.

No harsh feelings for this woman. Now I hardly see posts on her perfomances or in the show any improvements comments. No just no? Just because everyone wants her happy and cheats her unknowingly?

Not fair.

Even the audience are cheating her.

IF YOU feel she's not performing up to the par in the show then don't vote for her vote for a deserving one. If she gets eliminated let her. Because that's the ONLY way this competition will be fair and not bias or sympathetic. That's the most truthful and honest approach for this wonderful woman. Show her she's just as good and EQUAL as the others. There's no point of colors not eliminating her in the future just for the sake of TRPS or sympathy because that's pure cheap. Cheapness at it's best Chii.

I'm not saying she deserves to be eliminated right now but in the future if she does then my request to the audience don't be sympathetic be fair! Subhreet has chosen this show for a reason. She's here to show she's not less than anyone. She could have chosen another show where there would be lots more easier ways to win or go further in the competition but not she wants to be just at the same competitive level as these pros or celebs or whatever!

That's all I had to say. Hope you like my post. No harsh feelings once again. Do comment and like and share YOUR personal view. Would love to see it. God bless. :)

Thanks.

-PP



you are right well said
armyofspooks thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
I agree with whatever you pointed out in the post. Absolutely reflecting my thoughts. I do feel she improved by leaps and bounds this week, and if given a chance she can showcase her best. However, she does get over scored A LOT - more than anyone I've seen. Really though, they only got her for increased trps as cheap as it sounds 😵 Hoping she'll get a chance to stay and do better.
Paytonlee thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
I can see pity in the judges eyes with admiration. i dont think she wants to be favored because of her disability. she wants to be treated like a normal person.
Shruti21 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
I dnt think anyone can pity her for her condition l. If anything, you can only be inspired. And I guess she judges are for once being totally fair in Judging her. I can tell you the reason like in cricket if a batsman is injured though he can bat he get a runner because it will be unfair if we expect him to run like other players. A runner is given to bring upto the mark to the other players in terms of physical fitness.
Subreet dance with one leg others with two. It makes a big difference. To bring her upto the mark of other contestants either she should be given a leg or others should dance with one leg. This can't be done. So judges should keep this factor in Mind.
princessunara thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
I have been saying this for a long time now. So I couldn't have agreed more!! Amazing post!! 👍🏼

She came to this show to prove to herself that she can be like the rest of them.. that she is deserving to be a normal chance at life too..

So they r cheating her of her self respect also here.. I cringed when the judges cried first week! Please don't insult her like that!! Don't feel sorry for her, simply treat her just like everyone else

Be it judges or audience, I feel treating her as just another regular contestant is the best gift they can give her!
I am sure she would appreciate that very much too..

Because she is not there asking for sympathy. But is there asking for acceptance!! Give her that!!
meenji22 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: princessunara

I have been saying this for a long time now. So I couldn't have agreed more!! Amazing post!! 👍🏼

She came to this show to prove to herself that she can be like the rest of them.. that she is deserving to be a normal chance at life too..

So they r cheating her of her self respect also here.. I cringed when the judges cried first week! Please don't insult her like that!! Don't feel sorry for her, simply treat her just like everyone else

Be it judges or audience, I feel treating her as just another regular contestant is the best gift they can give her!
I am sure she would appreciate that very much too..

Because she is not there asking for sympathy. But is there asking for acceptance!! Give her that!!

👏 👏 👏 👏 👏
Chaiya_Chaiya thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
As much as I would like that, it's going to be very hard. It's almost like comparing apples to oranges. Her case is not like Vinod's from NB either. She has one leg and she has lot of limitations with steps because of the balance issue. I myself find it difficult to judge her. The only way you can judge her is by comparing her performances to her previous ones. But she definately has scope of improvement with her upper body.
I would love it if Diwakar is super creative and comes up with a way to avoid balance issues, but that kind of creativity week after week and then twice a week is extremely difficult.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".