Dil vs Dimaag July 13th 2015 - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

37

Views

2.3k

Users

16

Likes

122

Frequent Posters

Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Coolpree


@ bold, I disagree Devki. During Atifa track when she was pregnant with 2 heirs he publicly hurt her at every opportunity in his so called "quest for the truth". And most recently during the divorce drama ( Shah e Iran) she was publicly humiliated in the DEk whereas when he had to confront MM he requested all coutiers to leave the DEK. Does Jodha not deserve the same courtesy?


True, he did go beserk in the Atifa track, but with the assasination trap closing in on his family I will still give him the benefit of doubt in that situation.

The Shah-E-Iran DEK scene was definitely unacceptable. The thing is that whether we like it or not Jo is Jalal's verbal punching bag sometimes and the fact that this happens in front of others at times is very sad. I don't know why this is.😕

Devki
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: Sandhya.A


Excellent Analysis Devki. Reminds me of Divya's Take 5s.😊

Finally we got the Akbar we have always wanted. Understanding and feeling yet firm and smart and determined. His reaction to Salim, Jo and Ruqaiya was excactly how an Emperor of Akbar's stand would. We got glimpses of him in Abba-Huzoor track with young Salim. But then he was back to his marshmallow ways too soon. Hope this avatar stays till the end of the show so that it stays in our memories when the show ends instead of the prem pujari version.


Thanks Sandhya.

Honestly, I like RT's Akbar in all his forms, be it the strong Emperor or the prem pujari husband but yes, at this stage of the game they need to focus on the strong Emperor side of his and not the lover boy.😊 I hope this is who we get till the end.

Devki
Edited by devkidmd - 10 years ago
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: mishtidoi


If only MEH comes to fore...this track will shine...SEH is doing his part too well, its a team work, if only MEH comes to stand tall along side him, the track will be more meaning full.
The thing is not about being right or wrong...no one is wrong here, the thing is trying to understand other side's perspective...sometimes instead of samjhaofying, for once she can do samajhane ka prayas. May be she is trying to balance and understand, but as a viewer I'm not able to get that emotion of her across...CVs need to buck this up.


True, Jo's thinking in this track is coming across as very one dimensional. Maybe they just don't want the viewer to see the mental conflict she is going through.😆

Devki
soumyamurali thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#34

Hi Devki, with ur post u made a nice discussion thread. very nice. Now a days its really not happening with our show. so many different views. But I'd like to differ with some of them as they r saying JA always shouts at JO publicly n insults her etc.. But another thing we all have to remember is he always listens to her, He praises her n gives credit to her that also publicly. so we have to accept that also. Even JO is also like that . When ever she thinks he is wrong, she openly challenges him n do any thing to prove her point. So these 2 r made for each other.😉

Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: srilu321

hi devki awesome analysis and i loved it , episode was excellent.

hi to all - i liked all views and right too
my views are -
i think AKBAR has a balance nature to control his mind and heart . i wrote in fridays post jl very well aware of sanar love and he is concern about their love and he has no doubts on anar love but jo tested anar love for his son to convince jl for their marriage. jo never valued her position for her first relation then position esp jl sa when situation demands then only she uses her position but jl always balanced his relation and position . i observed till now jl is cool and explaining the importance of duties of a king and he is just convincing his son and wife as a father and husband not a king but if salim do anything in future def jl will take serious steps as a king not as a father like he did by sending anar out of agra.for me ultimate looser is jl (as a father an d king) not jo . as a king he is saving his kingdom but he will lose his beloved son like jo said in child salim track.i dont think jo is not thinking like MEH but she is more worried about jl sa relation both r important for her and maan future too thats why she is convincing jl to accept sanar marriage and may be jo siding salim but she is not against jl because she knew jl is right. and jo very well know jl s nature that if anything happens to salim or jl sa relation jl cant bare that may be he never shows openly like jo said in old episodes that his heart is very soft like a kid but jo is not like that she is mentally very strong. and my strong feeling is right now she is not telling anything to salim but when time comes she will tell and convince salim and shows right path too in this way this track may end.
about jl scolding ruq is waste scene because she never change her nature and she will create more problems to salim .
about RTs acting excellent .i loved it

Thanks for this lovely post Srilu. You write so well, very insightful.
Ruks will never change, I agree.
Devki
Edited by devkidmd - 10 years ago
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: nhbr

Agree with u Devki.


For those ppl who are in a respectable and responsible position,some kind of sacrifices are inevitable.

The episode was good and the best part was Jalal warning Rukaiyya to restrict her participation up to the prep for Jashn.Loved his expressions👏.The horrified expression on Ruks' face was a treat to watch😆😆.Hope she got the message right.

But I don't think Ruks would stop playing cheap tricks..aadat se majboor hai😉 and Cvs can't progress without her smirks and ghatiya plans.

@bold: Salim has to learn that yet.
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: ndi.anggraeni81


yes true .. jallu never let anyone saw how vulnerable his heart, he only show this side to jodha thats why if we recollect in talaq track jodha scold salim for taking side her and go againt his father, she said to salim his father love him a lot and he will very hurt if you oppose him, and yes jodha have more strong heart than jallu thats why she become his rock in emotional department.

and regarding jodha, may be because she never thirst for power so she never think too much meh or muz, for jodha her position as a wife and mother come first then meh/muz, she care for her people and help them anyway she can and never expect anything in return, she never boast about her position .. only once she boast her position as muz when she clash with ruq when ruq want to punish one of chef. jodha mostly think use her heart while jallu maitaint between his heart and mind 😉 but they are perfect to each other lol

And ultimately that's what matters. I get irritated with Jo sometimes but it is her simple innocence and straightforward nature that endears her to Jalal and why she matters so much to him. She is one person who will always have his back. She is so cute in spite of sometimes making me want to bang my head against the wall.
Devki
Shah67 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: soumyamurali

Hi Devki, with ur post u made a nice discussion thread. very nice. Now a days its really not happening with our show. so many different views. But I'd like to differ with some of them as they r saying JA always shouts at JO publicly n insults her etc.. But another thing we all have to remember is he always listens to her, He praises her n gives credit to her that also publicly. so we have to accept that also. Even JO is also like that . When ever she thinks he is wrong, she openly challenges him n do any thing to prove her point. So these 2 r made for each other.😉

Thanks Soumya. All of you make it so much fun.
My intention is not to make the best post or the most likeable post but just to put my views forward and hope that others will also step in and give their views, whether similar or different. That's what makes for a scintillating discussion. Hopefully we'll have an episode worthy of another one today.😉
Devki
Edited by devkidmd - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Blacktulip

10 months ago

New akdha VM - Ae dil hai mushkil

It has been more than 8 years probably since I made one .. hope you like it....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".