Adnan & Anu's contradictory judgment

When Prashant sang his 2nd song, Anu said he sang it well, but Adnan said he took the wrong scale and was out of sur. Anu usually argues back but didn't say anything.I understand that Anu was the music director of this song, but Adnan is a great composer too. I remember Anu Ji said something similar about Prashant when Sonu was the judge and Sonu corrected him at that time too. Personally, I thought this was Prashant's best performance so far.

I am not technically knowledgeable about music, so could someone who understands music comment on which judgement was right.

Ya I want to hear somebody else's comments on his song too. Adnan may have had higher expectations from Prashant as he himiself said Prashant could sing it much better than he did. But for me, it was one of the best performances in this gala. The song was in high pitch or whatever it is called, so I think Prashant did the right thing by singing it the way he did. I did kind of flinch when he crooned that falsetto or whatever it is called :D.

i dont know much abt music too..but imo anu was right..prashant was really good...he rockkedd!

i guess no-one can judge more perfectly than anu malik,cuz' he's a musician .n even javed saab has been agreein wid anu ji .but don kno wht happened today?
why were adnan n javed saab so biased abt. prashant?
he rocked it today!!infact one of his best performance .
may b cuz' javed saab just favors his favourite,earlier it was chang n now amit..haha...he even didn say tht good to emon in da 2nd song!!!
anywyzzzzzzzz...........PRASHANT ROCKEDDD IT TODAY!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Oh so that is what falsetto is... 😳

And as for Javed Akhtar's comments, I think the only complaint was that Prashant did not say some words complete, nothing to do with tunes...

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

When Prashant sang his 2nd song, Anu said he sang it well, but Adnan said he took the wrong scale and was out of sur. Anu usually argues back but didn't say anything.I understand that Anu was the music director of this song, but Adnan is a great composer too. I remember Anu Ji said something similar about Prashant when Sonu was the judge and Sonu corrected him at that time too. Personally, I thought this was Prashant's best performance so far.

I am not technically knowledgeable about music, so could someone who understands music comment on which judgement was right.

I agree with Sonu and Adnan. Anu would have argued back, as you said, if he was sure he is 100% right. Like he did in Emon's case or any other singer's case.

Yea I was shocked when anu didnt fight back lol. He never misses an opportunity. 😃

Originally posted by: abru07

I agree with Sonu and Adnan. Anu would have argued back, as you said, if he was sure he is 100% right. Like he did in Emon's case or any other singer's case.

Yes right.I agree with Sonu and Anu and also that Javedji said he eats up the last word. That is also true bec he goes breathless sometimes. Acutally Anuji does not want to be very critical now as he knows how the votings are going on and who would be top. SO WHAT IS THE USE NOW SAYING ANYTHING. THEY THOUGH I AM SURE WANT AMIT TO WIN .

I really wished Adnan should had been II judge. He wasn't biased at all but very honest.