Adnan & Anu's contradictory judgment - Page 2

Anu always argues back. He has never failed to argue back. When Sonu told him to listen to the recording, he agreed with Sonu that maybe he had gone wrong. Personally, Anu's comments on everybody be it Amit, Emon or Prashant were very sugar coated today. He was praising all three and not giving constructive criticism. Only Adnan Sami was giving constructive criticism. Even Javed Ji was judging well but comparing Rafi's voice and then Amit's was a bit too much. Legends should not be compared to anybody.

If javed is happy he praises the contestants more than needed if he is unhappy he takes them down so badly. He is only a writer he doesn't have a good knowledge about music and singing than Anu and Udit. He should only stick with words not the singing quality.

im happy he didnt argue back , as for adnan's comment , i agree with him

well listen to the original song by kunal ganjawala..even he doesnt pronounce the whole words....javed A himself said in hard songs like this it is hard to pronounce whole words completely...and again says you try to do that..that is impossible man...how will he do it when even original singer did not...if he does then who knows same judge might say..u sang the whole words u were supposed to leave that part...these judges are never happy with him..

sonu nigam is the most baised judge ever..as soon as he enterd the stage he said " dont vote regionally...indirectly to prashant..when he performed him and JA said easy song was chosen..now they dont get to choose the song their music directors does...they always look for the chances to get prashant down...

who knows better??AM or AS??? well AM is here for more than decade so i agree with him...i felt myself how difficult that song was and he did full justice to that song..he roc ked it

Originally posted by: maraizaa

well listen to the original song by kunal ganjawala..even he doesnt pronounce the whole words....javed A himself said in hard songs like this it is hard to pronounce whole words completely...and again says you try to do that..that is impossible man...how will he do it when even original singer did not...if he does then who knows same judge might say..u sang the whole words u were supposed to leave that part...these judges are never happy with him..

sonu nigam is the most baised judge ever..as soon as he enterd the stage he said " dont vote regionally...indirectly to prashant..when he performed him and JA said easy song was chosen..now they dont get to choose the song their music directors does...they always look for the chances to get prashant down...

who knows better??AM or AS??? well AM is here for more than decade so i agree with him...i felt myself how difficult that song was and he did full justice to that song..he roc ked it

You being a Prashant fan supporting him is right, but it is wrong to state wrong facts. I have heard this song about 10 times and Kunal pronounces every word entirely. Do not make false accusations. And Sonu and biased - something must be wrong with you. Sonu is the most unbiased and fair judge. He is the best playback singer in the industry currently and knows more about music then this whole forum combined. Even Anu agreed with him when Sonu corrected him.

Sonu corrects people when they are wrong. And what is wrong in saying vote for talent and not someone from your region? He said the right thing.

well listen to the original song by kunal ganjawala..even he doesnt pronounce the whole words....javed A himself said in hard songs like this it is hard to pronounce whole words completely...and again says you try to do that..that is impossible man...how will he do it when even original singer did not...if he does then who knows same judge might say..u sang the whole words u were supposed to leave that part...these judges are never happy with him.. [/quote]

Agreed 100%. The original song was sung like that and Prashant could have been in bigger trouble if he deviated from it. As far as I'm concerned, he did full justice to the song.

I have heard this song about 10 times and Kunal pronounces every word entirely. [/quote]

And I have listened to it more than 20 times, in fact listening to it right now too. Kunal doesn't sing the last words completely, he leaves it. Just listen to the 'guzaaaa' and 'pyaaaa' part closely the last 'r' can't be heard.

I am surprised that people are finding faults with the original singer of this song, Kunal to support their favourite. Kunal completed every word in the song. Kunal sang the song brilliantly. Seriously people can support their favourite and say he sang well but I don't think it is right to make false accusations on the original singer of this song.

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I am surprised that people are finding faults with the original singer of this song, Kunal to support their favourite. Kunal completed every word in the song. Kunal sang the song brilliantly. Seriously people can support their favourite and say he sang well but I don't think it is right to make false accusations on the original singer of this song.

Who is saying it was fault in the original singer? How about, it was meant to be sung that way? The original singer sings the way the music director wants it to be done. Further, the originals are recorded/stitched, if it was a fault, it could have been rectified. I doubt any music director would let a faulty song pass by.

I think Prashant did his best too...however, I don't think he can do better that that. I thought it was just an OK performance. 🤢 🤢 🤢