The two nations theory

Page

Next Last

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Finally y'day Shaad spelt out loud and clear why he is keeping a strange woman sans memory captive.

It's not to avert a nuclear war between two neighbouring countries, nor to nab a sexy little terrorist called Shashi Kapoor, Michael Jackson is on the job.It's because he is afraid of being all alone in this big bad world ,he wouldn't let go of the mentally unstable woman,who innocently sought his help.

Thank you Cv for rubbishing the two nations theory floated by confused/invested viewers and making it clear for all what this guy wants and what his intentions are presently.

Edited by simran_singh_24 - 10 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

JShukla

@JShukla

Inactive

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: simran_singh_24
Finally y'day Shaad spelt out loud and clear why he is keeping a strange woman sans memory captive.
It's not to avert a nuclear war between two neighbouring countries, nor to nab a sexy little terrorist called Shashi Kapoor, Michael Jackson is on the job.He is afraid of being all alone in this big bad world and he can't let go of the mentally unstable woman,who innocently sought his help.

Thank you Cv for rubbishing the two nations theory floated by confused/invested viewers and making it clear for all what this guy wants and what his intentions are presently.

frankly... it was always clear that Sanam's captivity had nothing to do with national/international security after the first few episodes.

It is also becoming clear that this guy definitely isn't the best of the lot when it comes to defense personnel...

It was clear as a day yesterday night😆 that Sanam's captivity is only related to his own mental condition and less about Sanam's

In fact I could finally connect with him yesterday. I would like some more such monologues from him so that all delusional viewers can see the light..ummm darkness in his heart.

If you clear your stand Mr Shady, I might even mildly root for you ... but then love can NEVER be achieved via lies. So say the truth and try to win the woman(very difficult coz your opponent is way too...much!)

Edited by JShukla - 10 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Juhi" Sanam's captivity is only related to his own mental condition and less about Sanam's"👏

Yes, more monologues for him as SaHil are lost in some indefinite eye-locks.

Some of us could see thr' the veil early on, y'day's monologue was for the delusional and confused.

Quote

minnie2308

@minnie2308

Dazzler

Posted: 10 years ago

Simmy, I had not expected a triangle of caliber- 'saagar' or 'kuch kuch hota hai' or 'dil toh paagal hai'...

but a triangle I certainly expected. instead we got a weird character sketch we could not connect to...

At certain points in above stories, I so wanted Kamal Hassan to get the girl or Kajol to get the guy or Karishma to get the man...

Here the 3rd angle was so poorly executed that some viewers did not even know his reasons for lying. So yeah the 2 nations theory is BS🤢

Quote

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: minnie2308
Simmy, I had not expected a triangle of caliber- 'saagar' or 'kuch kuch hota hai' or 'dil toh paagal hai'...

but a triangle I certainly expected. instead we got a weird character sketch we could not connect to...

At certain points in above stories, I so wanted Kamal Hassan to get the girl or Kajol to get the guy or Karishma to get the man...

Here the 3rd angle was so poorly executed that some viewers did not even know his reasons for lying. So yeah the 2 nations theory is BS🤢

Minnie, we know the theory was BS from start, y'day it got officially trashed😆

I applaud the Cvs for correcting their wrongs and making it all official, so that innocent viewers are not confused about the character of the third angle they wanted to bring.

Yeah, it's all overboard now.He is delusional.selfish.and an incompetent army officer.

I also liked the way they showed SaHil FBs y'day.Hope it makes the bond between the two to new viewers and they don't see aahil as the new villain😆

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

They finally made it official. Otherwise, u just cant connect with him. it was a poor executed character. he was like faiz. but i liked faiz n his acting,that i am nt able to do to this character. if they make it clear n nt so confusing n said i might like him. It is like he does wrong n it is shown great then u know i would absoluetly dislike him. thanks for the official thing n clearing the confusions otherwise some people still think it is for 2 nations. 😆

Quote

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: darlingpinks
They finally made it official. Otherwise, u just cant connect with him. it was a poor executed character. he was like faiz. but i liked faiz n his acting,that i am nt able to do to this character. if they make it clear n nt so confusing n said i might like him. It is like he does wrong n it is shown great then u know i would absoluetly dislike him. thanks for the official thing n clearing the confusions otherwise some people still think it is for 2 nations. 😆

Faiz was good & the actor did justice to that role,disgusting as it was. I watched very little of HaRaFa, mainly HaRa failed to keep my interest.

May be Shaad is supposed to come across a conflicted man,instead...

Finally, we know where everyone stands or lies here, under the bed or on the couch or on bed😆

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: simran_singh_24

Faiz was good & the actor did justice to that role,disgusting as it was. I watched very little of HaRaFa, mainly HaRa failed to keep my interest.
May be Shaad is supposed to come across a conflicted man,instead...
Finally, we know where everyone stands or lies here, under the bed or on the couch or on bed😆

Yeah Ididntwatch HaRa but Faiz scenes, he actedvery well. He came in Fear Flies episode I think, someone said. Still I cant root for him. Maybe stands nowhere n is sleeping dreaming about sk.😆

Quote

Mandy

@MrDarcyfan

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

@ Juhi:

Do you know I agree with that statement of yours that you finally "Connected" to Shaad! Newsflash so did I! Finally he admitted WHY he is doing this, and why he is afraid of someone from Jannat's past coming to claim her! Yes what he is doing is wrong, but at least he admitted that he is deliberately keeping her with him, because of his feelings for her and his current loneliness in the world! You know I actually felt bad for him for the first time! It proves that only a little HONESTY is needed for someone to actually make a connection with a character. Even if you think the character is wrong and acting badly!

That is why I always connected to Aahil! He was a jerk at the start, but he was an honest jerk! Who and what he was was totally clear! Good or bad! No one is one dimensional! So I connected to him! Same with Rehan, and now Saif. Whatever their issues were, they were never white washed. It was always clear to us that they were not perfect and we didnt try to pretend they were! Finally Shaad himself admitted that he is doing this for his own self interest, and that was the first true acknowledgement of his actions from HIM, and also the makers of this show! So thanks for that CV's! Finally you have made him accept out loud what his true intentions are what motivates his intentions! Like it or not, I always respect honesty! So this is good!

Yes Simran, the "Two nations" and "National security" theories have now been dispelled by Shaad himself. Actually like Juhi said, after the first few episodes, this was not about any national security, or saving Sanam, as staying as Shaad's wife was in no way any special help to Sanam. Because her life was never in danger from SK, as she had NO idea Sanam witnessed Liyaquat's murder and I dont think she even knows now! All dangers she faced after the riots, came directly as a result of her involvement with Shaad! So in fact he has put her in harms way! So whatever he does to look out for her, he is doing his duty, not a favor to her. That is the long and short of it. I don't think CV's ever intended for everyone to think that Shaad was some perfect person who is doing everything out of his need to be heroic. I think it was very clearly shown to us what his shortcomings are! The difference is if we want to see it or not! So maybe CV's thought they will spell it out finally!

Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago

Quote

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

@Mandy- now everyone knows the "WHY" of his actions. I would like to see some more reflections from his side and him recognising the "Rights" and "wrongs" of his actions,as this track progress and as he witness' the real love between SaHil.

The Cvs have to spell that too loud and clear to the deluded.

Quote

1 2 3 4

The two nations theory

Related Topics

Explore Topics