There are so many clues yet...... - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.6k

Users

6

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#21
Children have the right to go to school IF THEY WANT TO.
It is the duty of every parent to ensure the child goes to school.If their child doesn't go to school then they are not punishable by law.
Parents can only be persuaded.

Social worker has no business to poke into a matter that is strictly between the child and her family.If the child wants education and parents not co operating with the kid and the kid tells her that yes she can ask the parents.

Here did the kid ask her for help? Illiteracy among girls is the morm in their society what is so unsual about Nimboli's lack of education??

The more important thing here is the child marriage taht has taken place.Of which Anandi is in the dark.
Anandi can't barge in and demand that they send their kid to school.Anandi can barge in along with police if she gets to know of the child marriage

At this point in the show ANANDI DOESN'T HAVE THE BENEFIT OF KNOWLEDGE THAT VIEWERS HAVE.
Edited by aparnauma - 10 years ago
Stalwart. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

99% of all educated parents do send their kids to school...unless there is a medical complication etc.

Most of the uneducated adults do send their kids to school because they don't want their children to miss the benefit of education. At least a half of them ensure that their kids get basic education.

And those who are not interested in education of children have an object behind it that is either child labour or child marriage which are illegal. They don't keep their kids in house feeding them without education. Unless they have some other plan they don't oppose education. This is the case with a majority of parents who don't feel the responsibility of getting their child educated.

So this girl doesn't seem getting her basic education means there is something to suspect.

Who said Anandi has to barge in and demand that they send their kid to school? Illiteracy, child marriages etc. happen in the society. Persuading against such practices is a part of social service. How will the kid ask for help when she doesn't know anything about the world beyond Akheraj's territory? Now she's like a frog in a dark well.

Even uneducated people know the meaning of some of the English words like thank you etc. they learn by observing the people around them. But Nimboli doesn't have this benefit.



GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
The topic here is that Anandi got clues she should have noticed some things which are unusual
But none of the so called clues are unusual to alert a person.

And all these clues are visible to only people who have known Anandi's daughter's story from the begining

The makers have been very clever in wiping away all the signs of child marriage when Anandi met the girl

Even her first glimpse of the girl was just a profile with her face partly covered up that too from a distance when she was crossing in front of car.

The girl is at home with her parents and she is not married there is no evidence of child labour so what signs has she ignored??


The child's lack of education is no reason to suspect anything that too in Riural Rajasthan .It is not unusual to find an uneducated girl.

It is just an assumption that everyone knows basic English words like Thank you.But from waht I ahve heard from my friends who spent yaers working in Rural North India it is not true. Most of them have very little exposure to English language.Nobody speaks English words too.


Girls may be made to stay at home whether they are married off or not.

The girl is living in Akheraj's territory but she doesn't have anything on her person to say that she belongs to Akheraj territory.

That girl is living with her family for an outsider. Nobody pries into details unnecessarily.


Education may be stopped because they want the girls to help mothers there could be so many reason for not going to school

Juts because a kid is not going to school that cannnot be termed as something extraordinary situation in our country leave alone Rajasthan

Social worker can barge in if she suspects child marriage. In all her talks that little girl has not told her about child marriage - that is the only time she can interfere

Lack of education doesn't rouse suspicions in our country be it among social workers or ordinary people.Because people know the reasons fro that and for that thye can't barge in and demand parents nor the situation looks suspicious.

I am out of here.

The simple reason is Anandi is not seeing the so called clues which in your perception or highly unusual don't seem to be unusal in Anandi's perception or in the perception of some viewers and MOST IMPORTANTLY IN THE PERCEPTION OF CVS.


Stalwart. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#24

Those clues aren't unusual for a normal individual but Anandi is not one of them. She is totally aware of the social issues that prevail in her region. I've said this earlier too. Anandi has been doing social service from the past 11 years and previously also. When she connects her experiences she should at least wonder what has happened. Girls who are not sent school may be made to stay at home whether they are married off or not but there are high chances of them getting married before they reach the age of 18. There could be many other reasons for not sending children to school but child labour and child marriages have higher incidence...and marrying children when they are young is quite a common thing at Anandi's place and she knows about it very well. Social workers deal with all kinds of social issues be it depriving children of education or child marriages.

CVs give more importance to drama. They can make any change for the sake of it. So what all they show need not be what they perceive or think and the characters of the serial are their own creation and shape according to their needs. I don't defend what all a character does because he/she is my favorite nor do I criticize any without a proper reason. I'm not here to change anyone's views nor do I want to.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".