Udit - Amit - Page 2

Originally posted by: kyph_1fan

yepp....i think hes definitely baised towards prashant liek Alisha is towards Chang....no offense 😃

n like Javed saab is for Ankita..

I loved Amit's performance today. I was little bit disappointed with Udit's comment today and then I went to repeat Amit's show once again. I then felt Udit was true. Amit's sound was missing the flavor of entertainment at a couple of points. I could not understand why Javed needed to advise Udit.

Today's my ranking
Amit - best
Ankita - second
Chang - third
Prashant - fourth
Emon - worst

yupp he alwayz needs to say sumthin to him..

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

like i said, reasons could be many. but as i've also mentioned in another topic, it could be that udit wants prashant in the finals since he comments on prashant fighting on like a sipoy when he's supposed to be talking about his singing 😕 i don't like bringing regions into everything either but at the end of the day, it could be a factor affecting some people's judgements. yeah amit is from the north east too, but he's ethnically different since he's bengali. so you never know.

yada yada How about Anu Malik saying Amit you are my Indian Idol? How about Javed saying you are a blessing for Indian music industry? How about Javed saying Prashant accha tha lekin...? How about Javed saying Ankita tumhara performance aisa thaa ki galtiya maaf ho jaya?

Open your black goggles and see Udit and Prashant with the same eyes as you do to Javed and Anu Malik. My sincere suggestions to you.😊
BTW I have genuinely voted for Amit as well. Without Prashant and Amit both in the Indian Idol, the show is a spiceless nautanki. They are complements to each other and both of them will reach to the finals for sure.

hehe thanks for quoting MY post, but you can see a lot of members feel the same way. javed favours ankita a lot but he also gives his honest opinion about other contestants and praises them when they really perform well. anu malik does the same; he has called amit his indian idol, but he also generously praised emon, deepali etc. and even went on stage to hug prashant when he thought they did well. and going by javed akhter's advice to udit narayan tonight, he notices it too.
it's one thing to back your favourite, and another to find invisible faults in another contestant continuously while praising your favourite regardless of how he does.

Originally posted by: Pseudonym

hehe thanks for quoting MY post, but you can see a lot of members feel the same way. javed favours ankita a lot but he also gives his honest opinion about other contestants and praises them when they really perform well. anu malik does the same; he has called amit his indian idol, but he also generously praised emon, deepali etc. and even went on stage to hug prashant when he thought they did well. and going by javed akhter's advice to udit narayan tonight, he notices it too.
it's one thing to back your favourite, and another to find invisible faults in another contestant continuously while praising your favourite regardless of how he does.

I don't really know what is in Udit's mind but your allegations against him are unfounded and illogical. What's wrong if Anu fancy's Amit, Alisha wants Chang, Javed desperately needs Ankita and Udit is glad if Prashant wins? To be fair with Udit, he has given a lot of slaps to Prashant in many rounds. And he has praised Amit without any negative remarks many times. Rewind from gala 1 and you will find the proof.

Referring Udit's comment on Amit, you don't need to spill out your regional and racist feeling here. Neither do I think Amit could be any threat to Aditya. Aditya has a lot of advantage of his own network and connection of his father.

Also, notice that Amit is a half nepali. Do you remember he sang a nepalese song some weeks ago.

i already mentioned how it's different with javed and anu, and how they don't hunt for flaws in other contestants despite having their own favourites. i think you should go through all the gala episodes again to see what we're talking about. there's no point in arguing over this anymore 'cause you're going to insist what we're saying is illogical...deny it if it makes you feel better.

Javedjee does hunt for flaws in Prashant's performance sweety. Every coins have two sides and if I am insisting, so are you. But this is merely our opinions. I do love reading your perspectives, as much as any others'.