Does it matter ................ - Page 3

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

i feel its the two sides of d same coin. where on one side vibha n parth genuine liking n chemistry n on d other side kamini mam who wants to jst ...
so d8 's hw it is different fo v n k.

Originally posted by: prc_fan1

I may be in the minority here,but no matter how much chemistry Anupriya & Laksh have together, I am not at all for a teacher/student romance, especially when that student is just a minor. A big NO. There are certain boundaries set when a teacher & student enter an institution. Their relationship is sacred. Yes, one can fall in love with anyone, at any age. But if you look at Parth (or most teenagers for that matter), they are emotionally unstable at this age & are unable to make the best decisions for themselves. The teacher, on the other hand, holds an influential position. This makes such a relationship unequal. There can never be valid consent in such a relationship, where the teacher is clearly in a position to exploit the emotional vulnerability of the student. A teacher, more specifically Vibha, should remain as a guide & facilitator to Parth & the other students in the institution.

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

most of d ppl over here think its unethical. vibha as per d story is arnd 19-20 yrs old whr she herself is not in a position to take right decisions for herself for eg d way she lied to her frnds abt her financial condition.
she is very swt n intelligent gal bt dis one thng of hers makes her not eligible 4 being a guide to others. she also needs guidance. d8's y her stay in warrior high is not gonna be easy. according to me her relationship wid parth is another aspect of making her life difficult whr she has to face criticism of society n that makes me scared d8 dey might brk up. bt dis is really a very interesting concept so we need to keep our faith in cvs. n kamini thing is a bit annoying bt its fun.

Originally posted by: firefly..

Totaly agreed as we can see Vibha's friends i.e. fab5 are also in college. They themselves are impulsive & immature to a lot of extent & so is Vibha. For her also it is difficult to chose right & wrong maturely. She is vulnerable & fragile..its difficult for her to figure out the barrier between a teacher student relationship also as in this age everyone loves to be loved. So the concept itself has some potential. Not only as a teacher student but two young person who has social barriers to be in love but still to deal with their feelings.

I dont know wheather I'm making any sense or not but I would love to see this track handled differently than a typical teacher student relationship.