Amaya, where were you born and brought up ?

Page

Next Last

dey.bh

@dey.bh

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Not India, definitely not India.

First of all, yesterday's episode was hilarious and the best I have seen from this show. Keep it up. The sudden change in their life, the sleepless night in the train, the environment that made the two girls fall sick and then the case of missing luggage was very natural. The song was also very appropriate. The desperation of the family and the song was very well put.

But it also gave us an insight of what Amaya is. She gave the description of the theif without realising it was an uniform. I am wondering how come anyone not notice that it was an uniform. Half of theIndian population have grown up watching Bacchan's Coolie. Remember the song,' Sari duniya ka bojh hum uthate hai ?'. If that is too old then every Indian show has a train moment. Not allowed on IF or else I would have given a long list of shows where I have seen coolies.

Let assume Amaya still is ignorant about it. Didn't she notice the men who were arguing to carry the luggage were all wearing the same dress ?

By the way, who is this Rudra who didn't turn up to receive the family ?

Edited by dey.bh - 10 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

cherrypansy

@cherrypansy

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Exactly my thoughts...agree they were not living a life of common Indian, but what about knowing what's happening around in your own country, how most people around spend their lives...nothing, seems mathurs never made their children aware of the reality even in conversations.

Still, loved the episode...and waiting to see their Haveli...and first step towards being independent. No idea about Rudra...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

charuta

@charuta

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

Same thoughts here! but frankly I don't understand the character of amaya. I mean she born and brought up in Mumbai not in Paris. Agreed with the point they were not living a life of common Indian, but what about knowing what's happening around in your own country, how most people around spend their lives. If You are from Mumbai and you don't know nothing about trains journey? Mumbai's environment ? its impossible. Her body language, her thoughts and her behavior is look like she was never before in India.

Quote

priya

@priya2607

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

we cannot say amaya is unique in her behaviour

most of the indians are like that

esp those who stay abroad and return home feel as though the country is dirty and traffic is too much and weather is too hot

people d'ont know to drive ect

while they themselves would have been here for so many years

few years abroad will change ther behaviour

few of my relatives are also like this

Quote

dey.bh

@dey.bh

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: priya2607
we cannot say amaya is unique in her behaviour
most of the indians are like that
esp those who stay abroad and return home feel as though the country is dirty and traffic is too much and weather is too hot
people d'ont know to drive ect
while they themselves would have been here for so many years
few years abroad will change ther behaviour
few of my relatives are also like this

SHe is definitely unique as far as the coolie is concerned. I know people like Amaya may find Indian roads too crowded or small towns quite poor in comparison to Paris or other foreign countries. Yet I cannot believe a literate woman like her could not figure out it was all but an uniform even when at least three to four of coolies were quarreling over their luggage. Even air hostess and air steward have uniform. What is so not understandable about a coolie's uniform ?

Quote

_shadesnature_

@_shadesnature_

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: dey.bh
SHe is definitely unique as far as the coolie is concerned. I know people like Amaya may find Indian roads too crowded or small towns quite poor in comparison to Paris or other foreign countries. Yet I cannot believe a literate woman like her could not figure out it was all but an uniform even when at least three to four of coolies were quarreling over their luggage. Even air hostess and air steward have uniform. What is so not understandable about a coolie's uniform ?

She is 'great ."😉 I mean seriously travelling on two stations she can't be aware of coollies it's common sense

Quote

Ecrivain

@Ecrivain

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Debby

I will believe tht Amaya is the baby born with a silver spoon in her mouth n has NOT travelled in India much , let alone know the coolies ...😲..yes yes I know it's admitably over exaggerated but tht is how the Indian shows work ...😆

But yes she has been given a whole NRI sort of a feel to her ..which I dont know how far they will continue to keep in the upcoming epis

Rudra was the guy the lawyer sinha appointed to take care of the Ladies , n I think he is one of the leads 😉

Quote

priya

@priya2607

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

yes in case of coolee u r right she di'nt know it was their uniform and it also had a number in it

Quote

SStephy

@SStephy

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

I think Amaya has never travelled by the trains... when they reached the railway station in Mumbai, she asked as to why couldn't they travel by flight...

Quote

dey.bh

@dey.bh

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: NATURESHIVANI
She is 'great ."😉 I mean seriously travelling on two stations she can't be aware of coollies it's common sense

I dint get your point. What two stations ? Mumbai and Benares ? And what about 10 or 15 stations the train has crossed before reaching its destination or she was hanging up there until they reached Benaras ?

Quote

1 2

Amaya, where were you born and brought up ?

Related Topics

Explore Topics