Does anandi s social work tracks even make an impact?

tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Why even they brings such tracks for Anandi if cannot present it properly?

Today Anandi was showing one move of karate to girls, before she completes her one move, she gets a phone call, why such a half baked scene? Then suddenly an uncle comes with OTT dialogs, first the girl isn't ready, that man said one word to Anandi "main Anandi ke Barein main nahi Sun sakti "then she is ready to go like a fool and tomorrow she will try to suicide and we are suppose to feel sory for her?????? There is going to be lecture and things will be fine... even day before yesterday Anandi stopped a wedding... the drama isn't making impact, it is just to show Anandi is doing social work.

If they want to show importance of karate then show some moves, make them do the moves. Let people also feel like learning karate. Don't show tracks for the sake of showing. Make proper security for students; anybody simply just can't enter the class. Make it look real.Otherwise no need to show such tracks, they consume screen space and don't make an impact on viewers also. Then what the point of showing such scenes?

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.3k

Users

6

Likes

5

Frequent Posters

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Agree the Anandi's social work tracks are being presented in a haphazard manner mainly because they are handling so many things at a time.
To top it all so much time goes into establishing Nandini's story which doesn't make much sense.
On one side they have kids causing trouble and adults handling/mishandling this trouble.
To show all this just ten minutes time is dedicated.
Why can't they just confine to one story per day?
As for the security - I guess the man would have been allowed into the campus because he is the guardian of a student in that school.
Anandi demonstrating those moves is just not enough and at the same time they need to address some issues along with that
I guess this track is about addressing the prejudice against girls and many parents don't like their girls learning these kinds of martial arts or don't generally like to encourage their girls to play sports or any kind of physicial activity - simply because they think it is not something that girls should be doing.
These scenes look choppy because they are way pre occupied with showing family drama and Nandini drama.
They abruptly cut scenes and move on to another scene - the impact is getting lost.
Edited by aparnauma - 10 years ago
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
The scene did not make impact - they are always abrupt in this so called social service. I did not like it because they are confused as always - it is not because Anandi went to attend a call just after teaching one move - it is about the concept of karate for the whole class. Does Anandi thinks karate is self-defence? In Indian context - karate cannot be an effective self defence technique. Everybody was in karate dress - imagine them in being ghaghra 😆. Since the girls as well as Anandi wear only ghaghra in daily life - how will they apply this knowledge in real life? Although they have already shown Anandi running a sprint and a marathon - outrunning tall and well built men and that too wearing floor length ghaghra (in reality, a woman will fall just after a few steps because she will step on to ghaghra).
Real impact will feel when they show a change in attitude, a change in changing costumes more like people in real life use to wear etc. This self-defence is anyways for outsiders - within family, Anandi and her students will always remain meek. And they show any person opposing Anandi as villain - if the guardian/elder in family does not like the child wearing those dress or learning to fight - he should have shown to contact the teacher and tell his reservations politely. Perhaps people of eternal village of Jaitsar could not imagine that a school (gurukul) will teach the girls these things. If indeed this is a serial which wants to send across message of social service - they should show some real stuff and not these unbelievable scenes.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Purpose of that track just doesn't come across

Many men not just in villages but even educated city bred men don't like to see their daughters dressed up in combat dresses and geared upto fight or take part in sports activities.Simply because they think these activities make their daughters seem less feminine.
It is even seen in many men who are all for educating their daughters and want to see them independent self sufficient too.
But instead they are taking the short cut route to address this issue making that man overtly negative.
As for wearing that dress while learning Karate don't see anything wrong in that.Knowledge and skills in martial arts may or may not make you fend off attacks but it does give a feeling that they can take care of themselves
These martial arts classes is just only a means to defend oneself ultimately it has to be in the mind of the girl.
Education financial independence or these lessons in martial arts are just means to empower woman so that she can help herself - if she doesn't want to help herself in spite of possessing all these she will still be in trouble and trampled upon or be subjugated
BV - Passes on a message - It is very important to defy society to do what you think is right but it is alright to let your family manipulate you in the name of love care and concern for you.
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Funniest thing for me in that scene yesterday's karate scene was even the little girl was giving kasam to anandi. DS just show piece there. Time and again CVs prove that they cannot show any kind of professional track for anyone.
jayshree1942 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
30 minutes mein kya kya dikhayenge?
nimboli dikhayenge?

shivam - abhi fight dikhayenge

anandi social work dikhayenge?

sab ko thoda thoda dikhate hai.

so obviously scene quality degrade hogi hi.

Actually too many cook spoil the meal.

and now i think anandi social work is not going to make any wonder, so her social work is like filler episode.
tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: jayshree1942

30 minutes mein kya kya dikhayenge?

nimboli dikhayenge?

shivam - abhi fight dikhayenge

anandi social work dikhayenge?

sab ko thoda thoda dikhate hai.

so obviously scene quality degrade hogi hi.

Actually too many cook spoil the meal.

and now i think anandi social work is not going to make any wonder, so her social work is like filler episode.



So my point is don't show! Why simply show us impact less scenes! Make fun of social work!
tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
instead of showing that man shouting OTT dialogs, just show students practising karate, doing moves, anandi looks proudly at the students. Isn't it a beautiful and satisfying scene.
umam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Haven't watched episodes related to Anandi's role as Sarpanch - so cannot comment on how Anandi's professional/social work tracks were handled..

Unfortunately post Ansh marriage, whatever little has been shown for Anandi's professional growth- starting with setting up Bhaili - none of the tracks have had a convincing writing. They showed how the idea got initiated, but the detailing on how she set up Bhaili - problems/issues she faced, how she overcame those-- none of the questions were answered. Then came the preleap vow of Anandi - root out bal vivaah - work towards betterment of women/girl children..post leap suddenly we get to see Shiv Niketan - Anandi teaching Karate..

Why Anandi felt the need to establish Shiv Niketan - what is the purpose?? It is left to viewers to deduce what is happening on the social work front..

No one is expecting writers to dedicate episodes on professional tracks, cos majority of viewers may not be interested - but cannot we expect effective writing, scenes/discussions to make Anandi's social work tracks convincing..

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
If they just show the girls learning karate moves and Anandi demonstrating them with no story around it it wouldn't make sense either.
The problem here is not with the content but the way they are executing the scenes and their approach.

Men resisting this kind of things often happen even in educated homes - simply because they don't think girls should learn all this.

It amy be a short track to address this issue - but it has a message in that - Only because of they are rushing it is losing it's impact.

They think if they show OTT dialogues and scenes the message will be louder and they can move on to next issue.

Every episode some 10 minutes is dedicated to Nandini story and in the rest they are show Anandi Abhi Shivam Anandi social work and Jagya Ganga - because of all this the impact is gone

They can dedicate to Abhi Shivam one day Anandi social work one and Ganga Jagya story another day so taht the attention doesn't get diverted.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".