its totally wrong...the serial never gave this impression..serial always potrayed manik as a psychic character...he makes others believe or gives them solid impression that he can do that & he is evil & he doesn't do good deeds except 4 fab5, so due to fear they never try to hurt his near ones again & affect his music...& always keeps back up plan to save them indirectly when situation crosses danger line even in anger. ..manik gives punishment horrible one but he always keeps dangerline in check..harshad always knew this...whatever anger manik was in , he would have badly hurt harshad but kill is no no in manik's dictionary & also some other thing like sexual harassment etc...manik knew about soha's prev. murder attempts on nandini before but he just tried to solve problem by blackmailing khurana to send her to asylum & he guarded nandini meanwhile. ..manik works by mental manipulation...that let people think worst of you& never let them know your good side so they fear him & didn't dare to do anything. ..
manik expected nandini to be aware or trust his inner goodness & see past his mask becoz he had spent so much time together with her & she was his closest confident & he was sure that by now she can't think bad about him...what all encounter they had, atleast he behaved that way..drunk episode when he told about navya incident & shahid incident back up & even when she was enemy& shahid murder& saved her life & her brother life at his personal risk when he was enemy to her...& in harshad case he came back which she came to know later& he never gave justification. .
(2)second a common sense which nandini must have had even if manik killed soha by pushing her in in fire in self defense as per cctv, he would have have been in guity or on phone he would have said that I killed soha instead he said that he is accused of this act, after 24 hrs he meet her & she needn't worry..& or atleast angry/disturbed rather most importantly he was sending her gifts.. it was exactly like cold blooded murderer behavior if he had done it which nandini knew isn't that case.. that was clearly indicating that manik wasn't guilty of even self defense death...& don't forget nandini had a doubt that manik can do it in revenge ...even if u r unsure & u have shown video, u give benefit of doubt & look over loopholes in video which she didn't & it was clearly present..
(3)when manik walked away from nandini for sacrifice for dhruv , he didn't misunderstand her or doubted on her...he just couldn't include her in decision making of walking away from her& choose dhruv's happiness ..& he never gave her excuse, he just accepted his fault of hurting her, when she pointed out flaw in it & asked sorry through various ways & always came clean with her...if nandini would have walked away from manik for rishab/navya 's well being then I could have called it same situation & should have given her benefit of doubt..
(4) nandini in a way considered a posibility(because she said I m not sure) of manik as a cold blooded murderer who is sending her gift after killing soha be it in self defense (even nandini has tiny doubt that he might do it to avenge her) & in court hugging her & arranging date...& she had that flashback even after manik saying speak truth & with smiling stress free face...& she never had firm belief that manik can't do it in vengeance. .& cherry on top she couldn't say that loud & clearly to manik on date...that I had doubt & harshad episode was reason...I couldn't trust u in this matter instead she was giving excuses. ..manik thought nandini knew that monster's mask is for world & he can be anything but a cold blooded murderer...
(5) manik asked one question whether u thought that I can do soha's murder in vengeance. ..& being considered as a posibility of murderer accusation from your closest confident is worst..she still thinks worst of you..is worst thing when u expect least..& she can speak the truth of being unsure but can't answer his question honestly & just kept ranting on. .manik never thought worst of nandini after drunk night...if nandini would have thought that manik ill choose his friend over her I would've understand that manik is responsible for this mistrust. ..but manik never inspired cold blooded murderer mistrust in her...aliya couldn't trust him in relationship(inspite of more feelings) but manik trusted her & couldn't believe she could be that bad to send goons & even didn't believe her after that..
(6) only feelings r not enough...trust yr partner / knowing & believing in their goodness & look through their mask when world can't & trust them & their acts is important. .misunderstanding them & believing worst of them is hurtful..manik's reaction is accurate..nandini is 100 percent wrong. .she always assumed worst of him & claim to love him & not forget to her love is trust. .sacrifice for loved ones as manik did 4 dhruv or nandini was about to do before fire incident is understandable& forgivable to extent..but to assume worst of your loved one is not forgivable..even court says "innocent till proven guilty" & u should never doubt your partner in first outlook. .
(7)conclusion comparison to prev. manik incident to this is illogical. .no similarity as I explained above. .manik is more mature/sensible/clear in relationship compare to nandini..he might be naive in feelings but he knows that never believe worst / misunderstand yr partner(even aliya)...when u can't think good / trust yr partner relationship can't survive. .nandini always goes on face value while manik looks deeper..
(8)repeat a mistake is worse than fresh mistake because it's choice..&if u can't learn inspite consequences known then it indicate u can't grow...so what nandini was thinking of sacrifice prev was even more worse than manik's walking away.
(9) nandini lacks self confidence...how she boosts it???.how they r going to come together now is something to look forward to..
how nandini is going to convince manik??? how she corrects her mistake & learn??how manik comes on terms to start relationship again??? I have trust in cv's. .lets see..