7th gala - Sony Vs Judges Vs Contestants

Members this is not a topic where you favour your contestants. please give your views and opinions by not favouring your idol.

yesterdays episode was quite disappointing. no one gets a B+, except Emon.

my question is whether the judges and sony is doing right to the contestants.

1. Deepali - She sang a song which is not related to theme but we can understand it was dedicated for anil kapoor. I dint find her performancce outstanding.

2. Amit - the person who disappointed me yesterday was him. He was missing sur badly,shaky and it dint touch my heart.(i always thought he will be the II3) but what comments did judges gave to him. its a hard song - choosing sucha song is blah blah so willl give full points. come on judges dont do this. we all know that amit is a good singer and has capability to be II3. but if he sings badly you have to point it out. for that reason only sony is giving you money and we are calling you judges.

3. Ankita - her confidence ruined her song, she thought to do some thing different and messed up. judges except Javed Saab were too much favouring her. For what??

4. Chang - I dont know what to write about him. i think judges doesn't want a chinese origin to win this competition.(i also have opinion that he is not a strong contender to amit,emon). but yesterdays performance, that was not toooo bad. ok it was average performance, if judges can comment on Amit's and Ankita's performance like this why cant Chang's also.

5. Puja - Here comes Sony's Scape goat. Have you ever noticed Mini's face when in Rubaroo Ganesh Hegde made Puja the Winner over Ankita. I felt that Mini was hoping that ankita will win the competition. We all heard the news that Puja was not well when they shooting and we dint find her in the begining of the show. Sony never said that where is puja (they can show in tension ankita's shaking legs but not Puja's situation where she was hospitalised for chest pain)event though Puja dint need sympathy votes to win the competition. if amit can choose a hard song and get good comments from judges for chossing a hard song rather than singing ity quite well. why notPuja.

6. Emon - the only contestant who sang quite well, even though his starting was little shaky. and for only one contestant the judges comments were same and all point out that the starting was shaky and after he sang it good. why cant judges give this type of comments to all. where they made the mistake and whaere they sang good without favouring their favs.

7. Prashant - he also chose a hard song - he's not a trained singer, so choosing a hard song and to sing it (murder it). i think according to his capability he sang it very good, so waht, chang is also not a trained singer, he also sang according to his capability. this is a show where we are looking for II who can sing according to their capability or who sang outstanding than others.

why so called judges judging like this.

and Hussain i want to tell you one thing - Udit Narayan is a honourable judge in your panel, if he want to say some thing let him speak, why you want to make him shut. and it was his good manner when you started speaking he kept quite. but you should also show the same when others speak listen to them and speak after that.

i think no one got bored reading this. till i saw yesterdays episode i had a feeling that puja wont be out today. but yesterday sony made such a manipulation that today will be her last day, even though i feel any day she is better than chang,ankita and prashant

according to me, yesterdays performance i find - Puja,Amit and Ankita are in bottom 3.

well then i wud like to add bottom 3- Deepali,Ankita,Puja.

no not true, i don't agree at all. amit in the bottom 3?????????. anyway bottom 3 according to me is puja, ankita and chang, and ankita should just leave now. Deepali amit and emon are my top 3

I absolutely agree that if judges praised about ankita ,amit and others with the same mistakes that chang did(which I dnt think he did it at all),then chang shud also have been praised that he selected a difficult song but sang it beautifully.He was really rocking .
Even emon was off-sur and I dnt even like the lakshya song.

disagree..i thought amit sang he song very well.he was off here and there..he could have done better.but it was in the top 3 performance not bottom 3....and puja..i agreee...she should have gotten more respect...i thoguht she did good..the only bad person tonight was anikta...however i feel chang should go..cuz none of his performances have been great

agreed with ur analysis. I also noticed that Udit ji wanted to say something, but Hussain cut him.
Anyway, i don't know who will be out toady.

i opened this topic to discuss what judges/sony is doing right to the contestants.
my bottom and yours bottom3 will be different.
but i'm asking the judges comments towards each contestants, sony's manipulation against Puja, Hussain's anchoring.

is sony doing a right thing or not
judges are giving right comment or not

well i gave the bottom 3 acc to public votes....as ankita n puja messed up they are surely invited to bottom 3 n though deepali was good but you knw she was the frst performer....so do we ever remember who performed the frst.....she's comin in bottom 3 jus for the heck of it.

Not just that...ankita sucked BIG TIME today..but Mini actually said that "because ankita has set high standards, its difficult for her to match her standard." I mean Give me a break......Ankita has been performing terrible..there are a gazillion others in India who are much better off...what standards are we talking about?

And Javed Akhtar the so called feminist actually said in the last results section that "there are many men but not as many women with this kind of style." (with reference to why ankita should not be out). One ankita does not have style, and two, Javed Akhtar's comment was really a sexist comment. In US, he would have been taken to task for this comment..atleast in my campus he would have...

I agree with you more or less on everything you said.. Especially the Puja part! 👏