Emon and Amit

I have seen so many posts favoring Amit Paul and couple of posts comparing him with Emon however I humbly disagree.

I feel Emon is the best singer in Indian Idol, noone even miles closer to him. As far as Amit paul is concerened , he has a pleasant melodious voice but that doesn't make him worth comparing with Emon. Amit has a long way to go in his singing to compete with Emon, however he is the second best in the remaining males and compete with Emon beacuse of his personality adding on to it.

NO. emon is not the best singer in indian idol. i disagree with u. PRASHANT N AMIT R THE BEST........

PRASHANT N AMIT ROCKS....... 😉

Prashant better then Emon. Are you talking about singing? Emon and Amit have their own strengths. Amit's biggest strength is his manly voice. Emon has been the most consistent right from the piano rounds and managed to excel at showing his versatality. Amit is also versatile but unfortunately luck has not favoured him in giving his best performance everytime.

I agree, Emon is the best out of boy abd Amit follows him with his appealing voice. Prashant and Chang are good singers but not the best singers. They may be ahead of the race because of voting pattern so far but Emon is a trained singer and he will go far in his play back singer career.
In girls, I like Deepali better than Pooja but I cannot disagree with many than Pooja has tremndous potential. I don't see any weekness in both of them. I will be shocked if both of them are not gone to TOP THREE.

Originally posted by: qazi_luv

Prashant better then Emon. Are you talking about singing? Emon and Amit have their own strengths. Amit's biggest strength is his manly voice. Emon has been the most consistent right from the piano rounds and managed to excel at showing his versatality. Amit is also versatile but unfortunately luck has not favoured him in giving his best performance everytime.

Prashant isnt better than Emon... Prashant (bless him) has a bit of an accent problem which he works very hard on every week... and he has given some not so good performances so compared to Emon he is nothing. The accent isn't a problem to Emon and he is extremely good at every sort of music wheather it's slow or fast... but i still feel Prashant is good but still has a long way to go!

And as for Amit and Emon... they are good in their own ways, I luv them both so I wouldn't want to compare!

Originally posted by: prettyasjen

Prashant isnt better than Emon... Prashant (bless him) has a bit of an accent problem which he works very hard on every week... and he has given some not so good performances so compared to Emon he is nothing. The accent isn't a problem to Emon and he is extremely good at every sort of music wheather it's slow or fast... but i still feel Prashant is good but still has a long way to go!

And as for Amit and Emon... they are good in their own ways, I luv them both so I wouldn't want to compare!

I don't think only Prashant has an accent problem. If you hear Emon and Puja speak Hindi, they too have an accent and one that is more visible but maybe they work much harder not to show it.

he is the best singer...emon rocks 👏

wats wid all dese threads compaing dese two...
each hav a different voice ..style of singing and strengths...personally i liek amits voice quality better but i luv emon overall...including his buubbly personality and all...i wud b extremely happy if emon wins but i wudnt b dissapointed if amit wins either... 😊

Originally posted by: pungi123

I have seen so many posts favoring Amit Paul and couple of posts comparing him with Emon however I humbly disagree.

I feel Emon is the best singer in Indian Idol, noone even miles closer to him. As far as Amit paul is concerened , he has a pleasant melodious voice but that doesn't make him worth comparing with Emon. Amit has a long way to go in his singing to compete with Emon, however he is the second best in the remaining males and compete with Emon beacuse of his personality adding on to it.

completely agree.. lol u put my thoughts into words
amits great, no doubt, but in comparison with every one else. emons more trained and a better singer definitely. yea people are now saying that amits better/as good as emon.. to put it in kind words- no freakin way! but yeah if emon by some chance doesn't win (like amey last year :@) amits the only other person who deserves the title.. ok im done now :P