Originally posted by: breathing_irony
Mallu: HE was pathetic---how did u lik him! 😕
Suno Na is a easy melody to sing. The trick lies in adding the right feel to it, and Parleen didnt add the right romantic and fantasy-world feel to it. Besides, if u listen to Shaan or Amey sing this song then u'd notice tht the chorus (dil ne tumko chun liya hai part) is sung differently each time. Parleen didnt add the variations in the chorus. For example, the word 'suno' can be sung in so many diff ways but parleen sang the word in only one way thru' out the song.
The song is supposed to have a persuasive touch 2 it which was MISSING. It was almost lik he was 'dictating' rthr thn persuading the person to 'suno na'!
N the beauty spot in this song is the part: keh raha hai jahan jo-ooo.... Parleen didnt extend the 'ooo' long enuf n failed to get the echo which is clearly present in Shaan n Amey's version. How can u mess up the most beauty spot of a song??
Even Debojit sang the song very well. Mybr Im being critical coz i had high expectations frm parleen.
ok sneha yes i agree lol to everything u sed d variations in suno na n jo--ooo bit yes yes yes i get what ur saying but it wasnt PATHETIC, c'mon dere were worse performances today n i found his one d best out of dem!
but still parleen is much better dan dat..maybe it was d weird band but ok i agree wid d details u have sed hehe i need to listen to his version agen now..but i still liked d parleen touch to it..like some of his expressions in d song was different to d original one..like shaan's singing is all smiley smiley his one was like ahh i cant explain it i can sing it..he added his expressions to it..n i found it very much romantic, it was liek he was singign it to me.
n i personally think that a singer is great wen he adds his own lil touch to it..people can just COPY d song by copying every expression in d original song but its about how u make an already famous song ur own n parleen did dat..he parleenfied it..n dats what i liekd about amey too..he sang in his own voice n he used to amey-fy d song..dats a great thing n i love dem for dis!
btw d lines..door hokar bhi door tum nahi ho pass ho lekin pass kyu nahi ho..i felt he was asking me dat 😆😆
Edited by yu.r.fat. - 18 years ago