Why the disagreement??.....

Ok guys i have no idea why but Anu Mallik seemed to be having a disagreement with the other three judges during the first gala!😕..I mean it was so weird...😕.....J,A and U liked some of the contestants and suddeny AM says it was flat, besura, blah blah!

Well i just wanted to discuss the reason for this disagreement...and is it realli what Anu Mallik wants to say or is it just to "spice things up" ......i mean do u agree what he said fr people he said were not that good or do u rekon he was wrong??

Please dont respond just saying u dont agree with him coz he didnt like ur favs performance!!! Please be fair 😃

** and oh yeh once again no fights or attacks**

hmm...I agree wid wat Anu Malik said to most of the contestants in the first gala....except wid wat he said to Deepali...Actually, I couldnt understand wat was he trying to say to her!!I disagree wid Anu Malik on wat he said about Emon's performance, I agree wid JA about Emon's Mitwa!

I believe it could be for the following reasons:-

a) it spices up things
b) He cant stand it if insipid comments are offered by other judges, which dont really help the contestant
c) He believes in calling a spade a spade... instead of being a "good boy" all the time and giving sugar coated plastic smile responses.
d) He is called as a Judge and its a part of his duty to give whatever comments he thinks is right... and not do YES SIR to all what his co judges say...

I thought Anu was v fair in the 1st gala. He thought tat Deepali's song lacked lustre and she did go off-key while coming down the stairs. Otherwise it was gud. But i reckon he meant the feelin wasnt there in the song. He dint say she went completly besura.

Then Charu. She went off-key and Anu pointed tat.Javedji too felt so. Like he said, ntn can escape Anu's ears, u gotta agree! Alisha is the 1 who aint judging properly. It was v clear tat Charu went off-key!!

On the whole, in the first gala i thought tat Javedji and Anu were the most fair judges. Alisha's comments were not v fair quite a few times and Uditji as alwyz! Except i was surprized a few times 😆 😳

I kinda disagree wid u 😳 . I think Anu was quite fair!

they are jus speaking nonsense for nothing!!!!!!!!

Originally posted by: nsheena

I thought Anu was v fair in the 1st gala. He thought tat Deepali's song lacked lustre and she did go off-key while coming down the stairs. Otherwise it was gud. But i reckon he meant the feelin wasnt there in the song. He dint say she went completly besura.

Then Charu. She went off-key and Anu pointed tat.Javedji too felt so. Like he said, ntn can escape Anu's ears, u gotta agree! Alisha is the 1 who aint judging properly. It was v clear tat Charu went off-key!!

On the whole, in the first gala i thought tat Javedji and Anu were the most fair judges. Alisha's comments were not v fair quite a few times and Uditji as alwyz! Except i was surprized a few times 😆 😳

I kinda disagree wid u 😳 . I think Anu was quite fair!

Its ok!...Its ur opinion! I respect it!...But i just think the way i saw it Anu Mallik looked quite fake when he fired up saying he didnt like the performance!

i also think tht sanu, i think he is biased on performance, like 4 example deepali sang luka chuppi, so wht will she perform on tht, i think we all know its a singing reality show, so it shld b the first and formost priority!
its just my opinion
bw, gr8 topic sanu jaan!

even i am quite confused on his take on deepali's song....but fuh-get it now....