Atifa beheads groom! Jalal sheds maulvi vesh to save the day!

skanda12 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Friends, after all these days of waiting for the climactic end to the horrendous Atifa track, how do you all feel about the big day of denouement we saw yesterday? Shall I tell you my frank feelings? I thought it was one the most pheeka climax scenes I have ever seen on Indian television, compared to all the hype and hoopla that was allowed to surround it for nearly a week.

The whole episode was so rushed, the dialogues were unintelligible, things seemed to happen in fits and starts, and people's faces and their expressions intersecting the scenes all seemed to be at odds with the goings-on in the plot. It was clearly a hasty cut-and-paste job of an episode, no doubt urgently produced and aired with a mixture of all kinds of previously shot and canned pieces of the story, just to end this ghastly track in haste and to assuage the irate public feelings that resulted in a TRP drop to 5!

The fact the the Creatives were up until the last minute re-drafting their sequences, and re-arranging what was to happen when the episode aired, was obvious. Even yesterday afternoon we saw SBS showing us the part where Maham declares she is behind the plot. In that SBS sequence Jalal was shown along with Atga in disguise as a sipahi. But suddenly when the episode aired, Jalal was dressed in disguise as a maulvi! Everything seems to have been put together at the last minute to somehow wrap up the track by Thursday ... and there's more ...

The precap suddenly showed that Jodha and Jalal were sitting on the same bed, where he was shedding tears about how much he wanted the culprit to be someone other than Maham, and she was mopping his tears. So it was further clear to us that a hasty retreat to a romantic track was being attempted whereby maybe we won't even get an adequate explanation from Jalal as to why he so insulted Jodha throughout, and we won't even get a question or a wee bit of petulance from Jodha that she was so hurt by him. All will be forgiven and forgotten like it all never happened and they may suddenly go from the nikaah-beheading and Maham unmasking to the bedroom scenes where they coochey-coo like the last three weeks never happened!

All I can say is this: see what a drop in TRPs does to the CVs. It lights a stick of dynamite under their bottoms - and hey presto, the track that disgusted audiences for weeks on end is tied down and completed in the space of 22 short minutes with some hastily assembled scene bits from the editing table, and the track is declared over by a single "back story speech" from the hero. And a precap is shown of the very next episode being a "romantic scene" so that the audience can eat their angry words and settle down to accepting the "epic romance" again!

OK, I won't say more on the negative assessment front, because I want to find at least three good positives from the episode, and unless I find something positive to say my atma will not be in shanti! So here are the three positives found with some difficulty:

One, it was great that they were able to show alternately the moves and countermoves of the pro-Jalal and anti-Jalal forces. There was a sort of match on between them as to who is now surrounding whom. That was interesting to watch. First when Atifa cuts the groom's throat, her men surround all the women in the hall. Then Amanullah Khan comes in with a posse of his men who surround the men in the hall like Mansingh and Todarmal. Then we have Maham doing her act at which point Jalal unmasks himself and shows Maham that he has caught her red-handed. He kills all the sipahis in the room, but Maham then tells him not to think too highly of himself for she has more men in the Palace at strategic places. Jalal then tells her he has his cannons ranged outside the Palace surrounding her extra men. Jalal then tells her "You are actually one man short" as he points to the bridegroom who turns out to be Maham's henchman! And then he crowns it all by saying he himself still has one additional man standing - and as Maham finds out that is Atga, who arrives with even more troops. So in the space of fifteen minutes we had both sides counting each other's men and some swift arithmetic going on. That was a nice touch!

Two, I thought they played Jodha into the scene quite nicely. For starters she was not wearing much jewelry which added to her beauty, and secondly, she was given a last minute eagerness to go to the wedding hall (despite being barred from it by Jalal) just to wish him for his nikaah and then to go back to Amer. She tried to enter the hall, but sipahis warned her off, but then when she insisted, the sipahis insisted on accompanying her. By the time Jodha got entry to the hall, the news that Jalal had been beheaded must have reached her ears for she came into the hall in a lather only to be held back by the swords of the enemy. After that I expected some major histrionics from Jodha, but thankfully the Creatives and the Director did not show us this hysterical side of Jodha. She stayed put, albeit with an aghast and nonplussed expression, as she watched the goings-on. When Maham did her speech at Atifa, Jodha's eyebrows touched her hairline but she still didn't say a word. She listened with incredulity. But when Maham came to the point where she said "I wanted to save Jalal from this liability of Jodha Begum, and I intended for him to be dethroned but not killed, and why the hell did you kill him Atifa?" ... that's when Jodha made her first move with a screech saying "I will kill those who killed him!" But then Amanullah checkmated her ... till Jalal appeared as the maulvi and began shedding the pieces of his careful disguise, saying "Don't you dare touch Jodha Begum!" ... and that's when the first smile spread across Jodha's face. After that she was all rapt attention as Jalal told all of his sizzling tehkeekaat! Thank God the Creatives did not make Jodha, Hamida, Salima and Ruq scream like banshees, and thank God they showed a Jodha with expressions and restraint! It would have been too much if the women had all collectively gone bonkers along with the swinging switches of power in that hall between the pro and anti-Jalal forces!

Three, I have to say a good word for Jalal who made that hero's entry in his maulvi disguise. It was a real catcall moment ... when he suddenly appeared from out of the crowd, and began undressing (ulp, removing his beard and balloon hat and extra paraphernalia, I mean!) as he took over the floor. The next seven minutes all belonged to Jalal as he berated Maham, told everyone the back story of his investigations and his ploys to foil the saazish, and Maham gaped at him open-mouthed while the women of the family suddenly turned all glad and proud of him! I thought Jalal's dialogue was a bit too fast and jerky but then if I managed to get his Urdu even at that speed I reckoned most people would have got it too! It's always nice to see these paisa-wasool moments when the hero turns up trumps and trounces the enemy with his superior mind, and especially for all of us who wanted in the end to see the "teda-Jalal", he was yesterday shown as teda through and through. He was so teda, in fact, that he needed no one else on his side but Atga to decipher the whole plot and to orchestrate its downfall. And even that Atga I suspect was a last minute addition to his Team of One! I liked the fact that we guys were in on the likely back story almost correctly. We too suspected that Jalal would have asked "How the hell did this chick Atifa get into the Shahi Hamam when only Badshahs and Begums could immerse themselves there?" ... and from there he zeroed in on the Kabul refugees not looking like they were Kabul-returned at all, and he also took Atifa alone for shikar in order to convert himself into the master shikari with her as prey! It was all in good filmy order to see that the hero had single-handedly worked all this out without any external help, so to speak, and then the same hero also showed his tender side in the precap shedding a few tears for the culprit who had meant a lot to him in his childhood. I now see it coming ... he will say to Jodha "How alone I am in this world of the treacherous souls around me!" whereupon she will say "You need no one but me and our two waarises who almost boarded the train to Amer!" The great part is that the episode has only partially revealed the whole extent of Jalal's tehkeekaat, and so we have another full episode today to look forward to the three things we most want: we want that he should be even more of a hero by saying exactly how he uncovered the saazish and the players, we want him to say to Jodha that he never meant all that he said to her insultingly as part of his drama-acting, and we want him to spend the rest of the month in her bed, doing whatever he thinks a man should do when in his wife's bed.

I hope for my own peace of mind, and sense of proper closure, today's episode is a little more easy-paced and well edited, and the expressions of Hamida, Salima, Ruq, Jodha etc. match the words that Jalal is going to say. I hope we see overall that Jalal did swing a masterstroke, and I am really eager to see what punishment exactly awaits Maham - and whether the infamous Zee man's theory that Maham will also bring down Ruq happens in some form or other? I am also waiting to see the lollipop love scenes between Jalal and Jodha which now seem like a distant memory!

For those who want a slightly more detailed look at what all happened yesterday, here it is:

Continuing from the last episode Jodha is standing sadly at her window as Jalal stares at her concernedly from within her room. Atifa then comes unexpectedly and says she is too excited to sleep so she wants to sing for Jalal. He agrees and goes with her.

In the morning Atga tells Jalal once more not to go ahead with this nikaah ... but Jalal rudely dismisses him from there and Ruq hears all this.

Jodha prays to Kanha that He should protect Jalal and give her share of punya to him.

Then all assemble at the marriage hall. Jalal enters and sits on stage as Atifa sits behind the purdah. Jalal asks if anyone there has guts to oppose his marriage - and the Maulvis present there gather courage to say they will not perform this nikaah. Jalal's men then bring another new Maulvi at swordpoint. Hamida objects to such treatment of respected Maulvis but Jalal just sneers at her.

Salima sitting in the marriage hall prays that this marriage should not happen.

In her room Jodha sadly removes all her jewellery and thinks back to the day she arrived at Agra - with ghrina. Now she feels so bad to leave.

Meanwhile, the nikaah ceremony starts and the groom wears the sera. Both bride and groom say "qubool hai" thrice when asked by the Maulvi, and are then declared man and wife. The bridegroom then walks to stand next to bride.

Jodha meanwhile wants to go to wedding hall to wish Jalal before leaving for Amer but Jalal's sipahis prevent her. When she insists, a few sipahis agree only if they can go with her. She agrees. She thinks this is all part of Jalal's plan to insult and sideline her.

In the wedding hall as people shout "Jalaluddin Mohammed Akbar Zindabad" Atifa takes out a knife and with a quick slash cuts the throat of the groom and he falls to the ground lifeless. All are aghast thinking Jalal is dead ... as Atifa laughs like a hyena and says her "maksad" is achieved. Her own face is splattered from the bllod of the corpse.

Jodha meanwhile runs in after hearing Jalal is dead - but enemy sipahis holds swords to bar her. Jodha, however, is unable to believe Jalal is dead. Atifa then declares that she is not even married to Jalal as she is not Atifa, she is Sakina!

Amanullah meanwhile comes in and with his extra sipahis surrounds all people in the hall and says first women will be taken as prisoners. Jodha says she won't leave Jalal ... but Mansingh tells her to be safe and sensible rather than so blunt.

Suddenly then Maham goes to Sakina and shouts "Why did you kill Jalal when I only told you to dethrone him. " People are aghast at this new turn of events as Maham condemns herself before all by her own mouth! Maham then goes and sits near the groom's body. She says to the dead body "I only wanted you dethroned as you were unfit to be king - as you had fallen for this worthless Jodha Begum. I decide everything that happens here and I decided that Jodha has become a liability for you. Besides I wanted revenge as you took everything from me ... my position, my name, my past record. So I brought Atifa here to entice you, take you away from Jodha, and bring you down - but not to kill you".

Jodha hearing all this shouts "You don't deserve to live" and tries to reach the body but Amanullah prevents her. Then suddenly a Maulvi comes forward from the crowd dramatically ... he removes all his disguise and it is Jalal! He gives dhamkis to Amanullah not to dare touch Jodha ... and Jodha becomes thrilled to see Jalal. Jalal then fights and kills all Atifa men single-handedly. Maham sees the carnage that Jalal has created and also sees that her game is up. She tells Jalal, "You may have finished off these men, but I have more men. Jalal tells Maham "Look again, you now have one man short" as he points to the dead body of the groom and Maham sees its her henchman.

Jalal then says "I have cannons all around the Palace and I too have one man short in this room." As Maham looks around she sees Atga arriving with lots of troops. Completely checkmated Maham sits in a daze as Jalal then tells everyone the back story of how he foiled this huge saazish of Maham.

It seems he suspected a big culprit and a big saazish when he saw that Atifa had been given access to the Shahi Hamam, where only he and his Begums were allowed. He figured out that someone was trying to entice him to fall for Atifa and he decided to play along to find out what was the saazish and who was behind it. He found out that the refugees who came to him for help were not from Kabul at all, and yet he let them stay at Palace under his eye. And then to study Atifa's behaviour from close quarters, he arranged the shikar trip in her company.

The episode ends at this point with the rest of the back story to follow in the next episode.

In precap Jalal is in Jodha's bed, with her sitting next to him - and he says "I so didn't want the culprit to be Maham" Jodha senses his sorrow and wipes his tears.

Looking at the larger picture of the tracks to anticipate after this Atifa track, I think there will be some four or five main ones now? We can probably expect the Adham-Atga death tracks, and the Chand Begum discovery track more immediately. The birth and death of the twins may come on a little later. In between we could have the assemblage of the Navaratnas at the court perhaps?

What all do you think is due to be shown to us between now and the threatened leap in October? I hope it is all interesting and not rushed through just to resurrect the TRPs with the leap.

I hope we have some real worthwhile romance between Jodha and Jalal. I am tired of this anger-separation-misunderstanding type of storyline. I hope the Creatives can go beyond that as a reward to us for having stomached 300 episodes. C'mon guys, give us a break.

And please keep your Zee man better informed about your plans so that he can tell at least partially correct stuff to callers! This Atifa track has exposed not just Atifa and Amanullah but also the Zee man!

Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

120

Views

10.9k

Users

32

Likes

545

Frequent Posters

NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Mansi I loved the episode yesterday. So Jalal was not aware the cul[rit was Maham till she revealed herself. The entire revelation will come today but I loved the way Jalal handeled the entire thing
I am happy that CVs have brought back itelligent Jalal

Will be back
vinitaj27 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Mansi, wonderful analysis as always. I agree the epi was rused but after bearing with jalal n atifa romance for so long i welcomed it with open arms n didn't care how rushed it was. Anything to see her gone. Btw did u notice jalal's expressions in the last scene when he says he took atifa out to shikar to investigate n that's y he had to take her alone he gave the explanation looking at jodha like he was apologising for lying to her n not taking her n she understood. I felt that was shot beautifully.
Ash1991 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Nyc analysis...
I agree that the episode was quite fast paced bt I guess as yesterday was trp day so they wanted maximum thing out to calm the people n do sm.damage control to some bring in the trps...I think today all what they showed in sbs jalal will narrate it in flashbacks because if we see properly he had sm other plan and I guess when he changed himself with one of maham's man he dressed as s sipahi and was waiting behind the curtains for the right moment to attack but then jodha came and he disguised himself as a moulvi to protect her...Change in plan is due to jodha coming...if jodha stayed in her hojra jalal may have attacked in the sipahi attire...I believe a lot wud be shown as flash back hopefully...
The best scene fr me yesterday was when jalal comes to Dave jodha n then gives his reason ofr taking only atifa to shikar by looking at jodha...
katana thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Exploding Episode. 👏
Usual Nice Post. 👍🏼
Charu.S thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Superb post Mansi . I agree with your views on today's mystery solving being dull and totally unexciting .
I felt that today's episode was a huge let down . After all that build up , prior to the Nikaah , the actual unveiling of Mahamanga lacked the punch .There were several loop holes in the execution of the story line . I felt that the only saving grace was the excellent performances by Rajat Tokas and Ashwini KalseKar .

I am relieved that the Atifa story is done and over with . I am sure that there is more of Jalal's mystery solving methods that we will get to see tomorrow in flashbacks . Now I am hoping that the Creatives will concentrate on showing us an unified Jodha Akbar whose love should grow stronger by the day .
SindhuMenon thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
mind blowing analysis Mansi..Love both your @green and @bold. It is very interesting to read your analysis as you have incorporated humor to your writing.

Agree they did rush with this episode but I am so relieved this Atifa track is ending.

Mu favorite scene was the scene where Jalal explains to Jodha why he could not take her. Loved it and how I missed them.. Rajat, Pardhi and Ashwini were awesome..

Just like u said, I do really hope we get flash backs as well as a JJ talk where Jalal does explain to Jo to why he had to do this.. Jalal taking Atgah saab into confidence will only make Adham mad. I feel sad that atgah saab will be killed soon but at least before his exit I am happy CVS are giving him some prominent scenes.

You have not still left your hope of Ruks getting caught. :):):)

Me too tired of all these MUs, anger, fights. Now can we see at least JJ working together..
Edited by SindhuMenon - 11 years ago
Rashmi81 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Mansi,
It was a blink and miss episode.Like it was so rushed that before we could get some grasp of one event ,other took place the very next moment.It seemed to me the last minute job a tailor does ,when we stand in his shop blasting him that it's been three weeks and still the dress or the sari blouse is not ready.But the performances were very good.Specially I liked Pari's the most.That all different expressions she showed were awesome from the start where she was so hurted while removing jewelry,then when she came to congratulate him at that time how she gathered courage ,the tigress she became when she wanted to kill MA and yes the expressions of pride she had when she heard her Pati parmeshwar's hero deeds.
Ashwini and Rajat were also good.And these scenes are now nothing to them as they are masters in putting up the act in such scenes.But Rajat's exp in the last scene when he gave explanation to Jo about hunting were awesome.
But the Precap was a let down.I did not expect them together on bed and discussing MA now.I wanted them to talk to each other about past three weeks.Pour their hearts out .If he was hurted in Khyber case then she was totally shattered here.Their own relationship was to be discussed and now Jo's health and mental state should be discussed.But they were into something else.
But all this was missed I think and they are ready with the next drama of MA punishment and now Atgah death scene's pictures are released.
The cvs are in no mood of giving any relief to viewers.
This superfast train of JA is going with a such speed without waiting at any station and changing tracks fast ,that it has become a ghost train with no guard and it seems to be on suicide mission.
Sorry for venting out dear.
AKT.JA thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
I have mixed feelings about this episode. It wasn't as good as we had hoped for, or as good as some of the earlier ones, but it was far better than the crappy dump we have been served lately. At least, if you suspended logic and rationality, it was enjoyable.

I don't know yet if this sub-track will eventually find a place in my short list of older go-to episodes; that will depend on how the next few turn out.

That said, here are a few comments and broodings, starting with general ones.

General Comments:

1. The CVs continue with their habit of dragging on boring depressing plots for weeks upon weeks, but anything even remotely exciting and enjoyable, and you'd think they don't have a few minutes to spare.

The same happened here. This material should have been explored and presented more slowly and throughly, but they rushed through it.

2. I think part of the general unstability comes from their original misjudgment about Mahachuchak, Nigar, and Khyber characters. With their usual lack of respect for the audience, they had worked out really childish characters with inconsistent story lines, and staked out a good chunk of the series on them.

These characters were introduced with great fanfare---and the audiences hated what they were shown. People simply hated Mahachuchak, her minister, and her Kabul palace. Nigar who used to be mildly annoying as Shehnaz, became truly intolerable as her real self. You barely see either MCB or Nigar now.

Similarly with Khyber's introduction and his artificially OTT inconsistent character: he was controlled by one man with a whip, but could trounce an entire army of heavily armed soldiers. In fact, people only warmed to him when he became a harmless hitchhiker with Jo and of course died with love that remained unrequited in this life.

To make a long guess short, I think the producers had staked a lot on these characters without a Plan B and have been fumbling around trying to recover from their collapse. However, habits do die hard, and they continue to drag on the empty boring junk and rush through anything interesting and exciting.

Specifically about Thursday's episode:

3. I don't understand why Saqina had to wait for the nikah in order to kill Jalal? She said that before killing him she first wanted audha as begum, but later she also claimed that she is not married to Jalal anyway? 😕

4. I was pleased that he called her badzaat! 😊

5. When was there any time to switch grooms and for Jalal to do all his make-up as a maulvi?

6. As always, unbelievable exceptions continue to be made for Ashwini. Even today she was given so much screen time and space. Good actress, but favoritism towards her and her character became a liability for this show long ago and remains so.

7. I have no idea why Amanullah would even think he can kill Jalal in a one-on-one battle? I mean, this guy is a small-time hired hand, not some great warrior he may be fancying himself to be. Oh well, whom gods wish to destroy...

8. MA's soldiers were so, so, so inept today that both MS and Tansen could simply shoo their captor's knives away and walk off? OK, MS at least has a reputation as a formidable warrior which could have intimidated a small-time sipahi, but Tansen?The singer?

Finally...

JA has forever changed the meaning of a few Hindi/Urdu words for me. Most people who know the normal meanings of these words will never understand why I become happy upon hearing badzaat or full of worry even panic upon hearing nikah and jashn.😊

Edited by AKT.JA - 11 years ago
neeshaa16 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Dear Mansi,
Yesterdays episode was too feekaa for me also. Like Khoda pahad aur nik;la chuha" We were waiting for the end of t his track so desperately but when teh end actually came.. it was not what we expected it to be. Yes it all appeared as if it had been done in a last minute rush. Only RT pulled the episode on his shoulders with his acting otherwise it was all dull episode for me. Maham was also good . (as always) Atifa was looking horrible..

I also hope we get enough valid expalantion for Jalal's rude behavior and his harsh words towards Jo.. Jo must also tell him that she attempted suicide.. He should realise that he was too harsh on his pregnant wife.. But if CVS just want to rush this track..then we cant expect much..

What an irony ..CVS care about TRPs but dont care about what we would actually like to watch..!!


Hope we get some good DEK scene of MA punishment and Ruks exposure too!


Related Topics

Jodha Akbar thumbnail

Posted by: So-So · 1 months ago

... but aaj ka din marks another event in history. On 14 February 1556, Jalal-ud-din Muhammad Akbar was crowned the third Mughal Emperor at the...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".