Yudh 4: A big, fat, red herring & crossed wires aplenty - Page 4

Originally posted by: mishtidoi

Oh!! yup Mona too...and she's not a long time associate...even her back story is still untold

interesting! just wondering who could it be!

i do not know why i feel commissioner is the one who is playing games, he might be the one at the end! what say?

and the key thing was the device was not made in india, therefore someone with power and money can only do this!

Meeting between Yudh and Nikhil...

Yudh blaming him for being a party to the death of innocent people...

Your words were so well put and I've got to agree there...Amitabh is too good...

For me, the paisa vasool moments in this segment were, first, when Yudh, responding to Nikhil's startled Aap?, replies Han, main! , with all the arrogant self-assurance of Amitabh Bachchan in his prime. Next, when he is assuring Nikhil that he can trust him, Yudh, because Nikhil's affair with a married woman is not his concern, the voice says one thing and the face says another. The lips are drawn back in a mocking smile, and the eyes are amused but probing, trying to assess which way the cat will jump.

Mamta getting killed and Nikhil's change from anger to concern on who could have been the person behind her death.

Oh...the lucky break...dialogue and Yudh saying that he did not believe in luck!

Wow...Again after reading your long write up on the questions part...I was smiling at your perfect guess...

I expect that your head is spinning already, but there is yet another puzzle. Remember what Mamta's father is telling the police? He says Bolti hi ja rahi thi, keh rahi thi: Papa, jaldi yahan aa jao, nahin to wo mujhe maar dalega! There does not seem to be any reason for him to lie about this matter, so let us take it that it was true.

The angry young man was back when Yudh gets angry with the editor of the paper.

Loved his calm after the storm...

Nikhil attacking Anand thinking he was behind Mamata's murder?

A special mention yet again of the brilliantly enacted scene between husband and wife who are fighting it out with a special needs son...the growing years taking its toll on the wife who was unable to bear it despite being a mother ----very very imaginable --- and the father at a loss of what to do! Beautiful indeed!

What a beautiful write up on this by you --- WOW you said it all

At the other end of the spectrum, and harrowing in the tragedy it portends, is the scene between Anand and his wife, discussing about their autistic son, who is increasingly aggressive and very hard to handle for his mother. He has hit her and left a bad bruise , and things can only get worse from now on. She thus wants to send the boy to a special school for such children, and Anand reacts to this with stunned disbelief, saying, Hamara beta hai! To which she responds, with bitter resignation, Isi baat ka to dukh hai ki wo hamara beta hai.

Now 90 persons out of a 100 would blame her for not living up to the popular image of the ever patient, never discouraged, never tired mother of an autistic child. But I would not blame her at all. As the Lord Jesus said, Let he who has never sinned cast the first stone. No one who has not suffered as she must be doing, unable to cope, day in and day out, with a physically powerful but mentally challenged, and now increasingly aggressive child, and given a husband who is never there because of the demands of his job, can understand what she is going thru. It is not that she loves her son any less. It is rather that she is by now at the end of her tether, and if nothing is done soon, something has got to give, and she will crack up.

@bold --- ⭐️👍🏼

The takkar of Rishi with the girl yet again at the shop...may have something to offer in the future...The mother feels dall mein kuch kala hai as he had got up early and the father feels he is getting responsible.

A sincere Apology - Anand on the new car infuriating Mukesh understandable but I guess there is a catch here...

The wife finally hearing it in the channel that her husband has been responsible ...

The doctor yet again reiterating that stress can aggravate his condition...further ...vicious cycle

WOW is the word for your writings ---- I don't know how to address you maybe Ma'am as I don't know you like the others here...but even the last line of yours was so well put ---

PS: Once again, please do hit the Like button, of course providing you survived this and actually liked it!

But I am here to survive😆 and share and feel it great to have read some real AWESOME stuff here !!!⭐️👏

Superb indeed!⭐️

🤗

My dear Shanti,

This is an omnibus response to all your comments on my 4 posts, for I felt exactly the same after I had read each of them. And that is that I have rarely been praised with such precise and intelligent understanding in this forum. In saying this, I have said it all. And I was very taken with the personal touches and comments that you have added, such as why Trishul is so special for you!

Thank you, my dear, thank you very, very much! I am delighted that these posts give you so much of genuine pleasure. There can be nothing more satisfying for any writer. Now go and see my latest on Episode 5!

You can call me Shyamala Aunty if that seems age appropriate - I am 65. Or, if you are relatively closer to me in age, Shyamala Didi or plain Shyamala. I have so many appellations in the IF - Aunty, Didi, Chechi, Akka - so you can take your pick!

Shyamala Whatever!

Originally posted by: kmfan_2

Meeting between Yudh and Nikhil...

Yudh blaming him for being a party to the death of innocent people...

Your words were so well put and I've got to agree there...Amitabh is too good...

For me, the paisa vasool moments in this segment were, first, when Yudh, responding to Nikhil's startled Aap?, replies Han, main! , with all the arrogant self-assurance of Amitabh Bachchan in his prime. Next, when he is assuring Nikhil that he can trust him, Yudh, because Nikhil's affair with a married woman is not his concern, the voice says one thing and the face says another. The lips are drawn back in a mocking smile, and the eyes are amused but probing, trying to assess which way the cat will jump.

Mamta getting killed and Nikhil's change from anger to concern on who could have been the person behind her death.

Oh...the lucky break...dialogue and Yudh saying that he did not believe in luck!

Wow...Again after reading your long write up on the questions part...I was smiling at your perfect guess...

I expect that your head is spinning already, but there is yet another puzzle. Remember what Mamta's father is telling the police? He says Bolti hi ja rahi thi, keh rahi thi: Papa, jaldi yahan aa jao, nahin to wo mujhe maar dalega! There does not seem to be any reason for him to lie about this matter, so let us take it that it was true.

The angry young man was back when Yudh gets angry with the editor of the paper.

Loved his calm after the storm...

Nikhil attacking Anand thinking he was behind Mamata's murder?

A special mention yet again of the brilliantly enacted scene between husband and wife who are fighting it out with a special needs son...the growing years taking its toll on the wife who was unable to bear it despite being a mother ----very very imaginable --- and the father at a loss of what to do! Beautiful indeed!

What a beautiful write up on this by you --- WOW you said it all

At the other end of the spectrum, and harrowing in the tragedy it portends, is the scene between Anand and his wife, discussing about their autistic son, who is increasingly aggressive and very hard to handle for his mother. He has hit her and left a bad bruise , and things can only get worse from now on. She thus wants to send the boy to a special school for such children, and Anand reacts to this with stunned disbelief, saying, Hamara beta hai! To which she responds, with bitter resignation, Isi baat ka to dukh hai ki wo hamara beta hai.

Now 90 persons out of a 100 would blame her for not living up to the popular image of the ever patient, never discouraged, never tired mother of an autistic child. But I would not blame her at all. As the Lord Jesus said, Let he who has never sinned cast the first stone. No one who has not suffered as she must be doing, unable to cope, day in and day out, with a physically powerful but mentally challenged, and now increasingly aggressive child, and given a husband who is never there because of the demands of his job, can understand what she is going thru. It is not that she loves her son any less. It is rather that she is by now at the end of her tether, and if nothing is done soon, something has got to give, and she will crack up.

@bold --- ⭐️👍🏼

The takkar of Rishi with the girl yet again at the shop...may have something to offer in the future...The mother feels dall mein kuch kala hai as he had got up early and the father feels he is getting responsible.

A sincere Apology - Anand on the new car infuriating Mukesh understandable but I guess there is a catch here...

The wife finally hearing it in the channel that her husband has been responsible ...

The doctor yet again reiterating that stress can aggravate his condition...further ...vicious cycle

WOW is the word for your writings ---- I don't know how to address you maybe Ma'am as I don't know you like the others here...but even the last line of yours was so well put ---

PS: Once again, please do hit the Like button, of course providing you survived this and actually liked it!

But I am here to survive😆 and share and feel it great to have read some real AWESOME stuff here !!!⭐️👏

Superb indeed!⭐️

🤗

Yes, my dear, I remembered that a bit late, and then immediately edited my response above!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: kmfan_2

Aunty...I told you my name in my first comment on the first part of yours!!!!

Shanti!!!! Which makes me love Mr Bachchan more and more!😳

Brilliant post!!! I am on a reading spree of the paltry 3 pages of posts on this forum. Took a break to comment on this one for now, will continue to read after this reply. Of course the show deserves this and more. Absolutely enthralling storytelling, one of the best on TV right now, in my opinion. Good to see some content driven programming on TV for a change, rather than catering to TRPs.

Thank you so very much for such warm praise of this one. I am also so glad that you appreciate this brilliant show at its true worth. But unfortunately, we seem to be in a distinct minority.

Yes, Sony does carry such unusual fare, but their programmers then handle it disastrously. 4 years ago, they destroyed arguably the best and most authentic show on Indian TV before or since, Powder, and then the following year, the excellent Kismat, both from Yashraj.

Sony has the distinction of having made Yashraj close down their TV division. Now for Yudh, no repeats, no omnibus on the weekends, and this when Sony still telecasts 8 hours a day of CID reruns. Enough said!

But let us enjoy it for the next 3 weeks. Given its TRPs, we are not likely to get anything even remotely as good for the next 4 years at least!

As for this forum being thanda, I agree. I have done my best to liven it up with daily episode analyses, and have also tried hard, with indifferent success, to persuade many of young friends in the Jodha Akbar forum to come over to Yudh.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: notagain

Brilliant post!!! I am on a reading spree of the paltry 3 pages of posts on this forum. Took a break to comment on this one for now, will continue to read after this reply. Of course the show deserves this and more. Absolutely enthralling storytelling, one of the best on TV right now, in my opinion. Good to see some content driven programming on TV for a change, rather than catering to TRPs.

Sony has had a decent record of trying new concepts and contents. Nice to see them doing the same again.

The Forum however seems to be slow.