Harry.. and a Horcrux? **new info** - Page 4

I tought he was a horecurse to cause it really makes sence! But I really really hope he is not cause I wood 😭 my eyes out if he is.
-Aastha

Originally posted by: ~PuNk PrInCeSs~

well i dnt think tht harry is a hocrix coz if he was, voldemort wudn't try 2 kill him in hp1,2,4 n 5..this is wat i think..ny1 is welcum 2 challenge ma thoughts

I have a theory to counter that... Look Voldy did not realise making Harry his horcrux could make him lose his powers... Eventually he might have realised the implications of making a living being that can think on its own as his horcrux... Cuz as Dumbledore says its dangerous to make an object/person capable of thinking as ur horcrux...

Moreover....

In book one he had posessed Quirrel and needed to get back to life... So killing Harry and retrieving a part of his soul would have made him stronger...

In book 2 it was a memory... Tom Riddle that was trapped in the diary.... And the memory was perhaps not aware of Harry being a horcrux.... Since the diary was made a Horcrux much before Harry was made one...

By book 4 and 5 Voldy became completely aware how big a threat Harry was to him... Thats why he decided to kill Harry... But the point to be noted here is that he wants to kill Harry personally... He doesnt want the Death Eaters to kill Harry... That could be since he wants to kill Harry and retrieve his own soul from Harry's body...

He has surely given some warped reasoning to Snape and Bella as to why he wants Harry Potter... ALIVE...

When Dumbledore says he has LOVE, a power that can defeat evil... It is probably Harry's power to love that is suppressing Voldemort's soul inside him and not letting Voldemort like characteristics surface on Harry... However... Other characteristics like Parseltongue and Disregard for rules which are apparently harmless are evident in Harry...

Originally posted by: swordfishh

I have a theory to counter that... Look Voldy did not realise making Harry his horcrux could make him lose his powers... Eventually he might have realised the implications of making a living being that can think on its own as his horcrux... Cuz as Dumbledore says its dangerous to make an object/person capable of thinking as ur horcrux...

Moreover....

In book one he had posessed Quirrel and needed to get back to life... So killing Harry and retrieving a part of his soul would have made him stronger...

In book 2 it was a memory... Tom Riddle that was trapped in the diary.... And the memory was perhaps not aware of Harry being a horcrux.... Since the diary was made a Horcrux much before Harry was made one...

By book 4 and 5 Voldy became completely aware how big a threat Harry was to him... Thats why he decided to kill Harry... But the point to be noted here is that he wants to kill Harry personally... He doesnt want the Death Eaters to kill Harry... That could be since he wants to kill Harry and retrieve his own soul from Harry's body...

He has surely given some warped reasoning to Snape and Bella as to why he wants Harry Potter... ALIVE...

When Dumbledore says he has LOVE, a power that can defeat evil... It is probably Harry's power to love that is suppressing Voldemort's soul inside him and not letting Voldemort like characteristics surface on Harry... However... Other characteristics like Parseltongue and Disregard for rules which are apparently harmless are evident in Harry...

Hmm swordfishh you have made very strong & valid points here ..esp Voldy dear want to kill HP himself .... also sorting hat said that he strongly debated .......to sort & put HP in Slythrin or in Griffendor.

It will be intersting to read what JKR writes and if she write something similar to what we are discussing then guys we just blooped ourselves.

i dont think he is a horcrux,if he were,then voldy would be killing his own soul's part,in order to kill his enemy,harry
that doesnt make sense..just imagine,killing his own part in order to kill his enemy
further more ,when voldy cant even tough harry,how on earth could he transfer a part of himself into harry
and in the end wormtail would save harry coz of that bond formed betn the two
so harry can never b ahorcrux,even though nagini can b one

I don kno there is a possibility that he is one , but I really hope he is not or else I will cry my eyes out 😭
-Aastha

i dont think he is a horcrux and didnt voldemort make his last horcrux by killing an old muggle man. i thought that the last horcrux was nagini the snake.

yeah i think he is a horcux but we have to read the book to find out.....any of you have it lol