Harry.. and a Horcrux? **new info** - Page 2

i don't think he's a horcux...horcux's are probably made willingly,i highly doute you can make one accidentily...and that night at godric's hollow voldy had no such intention..his soul purpose at that time was to kill harry not make him a horcux...and i do not think he could accidentily make him a horcux.
To me that seems a compicated process...i mean he's RIPPING HIS SOUL for crying out loud!

well there is a possibility...

i don't think that harry is a horcrux.
dylan.

Shreyasi.... hmmm nice name... interesting even... what does it mean...

we'll anyways.... Harry as a hocrux does sound interesting....

and the thoughts too have certain credibility... but we all know JKR too we'll she'll sure have a "Oh My! Not this..." kind of ending in store for us in book 7.

lets all quit speculation and pray to god that book 7 is completed and out soon...

Tejas

exactly thats wat..i also want. 😛

Your idea makes a sense.But,do you think People will like it?

Originally posted by: devilangel

Hey!

umm.. i'm new in this forum.. but i had a question which is kinda like an open topic.. so i thought i would share it with you guys.. i have read posts where it is said that the secret of harry's scar will be revealed.. and people think that it is a horcrux..

but i recently found it some website i forgot that there is a chance that harry IS a horcrux.. actually it kinda makes sense.. it takes a life to create a horcrux.. and voldemort did make his final and seventh horcrux that night in Godric's Hollow where Lily and Jame died.. if Harry is a horcrux.. then he has to die in order to kill Voldemort.. i mean even though dumbledore did say that living horcruxes are extremely dangerous and difficult to make.. its VOLDEMORT!! and nagini is a horcrux and she is living..he can make most things.. so is it possible that harry is a horcrux? and if he is.. is it possible for a horcrux to kill a part of its soul?? .... and also how wil Wormtail's Wizard's Debt come into it? i mean.. his evilness has shown that he is on the dark side.. but when a wizard saves another wizard's life.. abond is formed.. and i think the bond can only be broken by saving the life of the savior? ..

what are your views on it? umm.. just thought it will be good to discuss with yout guys whether there is a possibility.. i will search for the website and put it if i get it.. plzz reply soon! love you all and i would love to be friends,

shreyasi

I personally DONT believe that Harry is a horcrux. You said that to save the wizarding world from Voldemort, in the scenario that Harry is indeed a horcrux, then Harry would have to kill himself... that would make Voldemort mortal.. but what about the prophecy? it says that one needs to end the life of another, am i correct? how will harry get rid of voldemort if he's dead?

Originally posted by: charms16

i don't think he's a horcux...horcux's are probably made willingly,i highly doute you can make one accidentily...and that night at godric's hollow voldy had no such intention..his soul purpose at that time was to kill harry not make him a horcux...and i do not think he could accidentily make him a horcux.
To me that seems a compicated process...i mean he's RIPPING HIS SOUL for crying out loud!

true, and it would be extremely hard to make a horcrux when two wizards are first of all fighting with you to save ther son. along wid that, if he (Voldemort) made harry a horcrux, then was he gnna get rid of his horcrux afterwards? like he needed to kill harry, so wat was he gnna do? make one and get rid of it? whats the point of that/

heyy yah i too was thinking the same thing that he could be a horux which would really suck cuz he would die which i bet nobody wants 😭 but its possible JK Rowling is always coming up with un-expected and surprising things to include in her novels. u never know!! 😊

eZ breeZy ❤️ 🤓

Originally posted by: albusdumbledore

we'll anyways.... Harry as a hocrux does sound interesting....

and the thoughts too have certain credibility... but we all know JKR too we'll she'll sure have a "Oh My! Not this..." kind of ending in store for us in book 7.

lets all quit speculation and pray to god that book 7 is completed and out soon...

Tejas

exactly wht i wanna say....