Stockholm Syndrome among (Indian) Women - Page 34

Created

Last reply

Replies

334

Views

27.7k

Users

22

Likes

197

Frequent Posters

-bLEu98- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Rehanism



When we discuss issues like rape, bride burning, honour killing, etc we tend to see them in isolation however almost no effort is done to delve deep into this sort of deep entrenched and widely accepted culture of misogyny that breeds them.

The question is -- Isn't it our defeat that a large chunk of Indian women themselves (and that too educated ones using most modern technology) suffer from such Stockholm syndrome and consider feminists and liberals as their enemies and proudly lend their shoulders to a thoroughly sexist and abusive culture and its role-models? How does one, then, respond to arguments like **
see women here have no problem with it, then what is your problem**?

PS : The purpose of the thread is not to decide who was right in this interaction. So please don't bother to elaborate on that too much. Rather focus on the culturally institutionalized misogyny and women's role in its sustenance.


Well, on the whole conversation that you put up there, my sympathies. I've often found myself in such situations and believe me I'm coming straight from a Preity Zinta news article on fb where a lot of delusional misogynistic men were posting. 😆
So yeah, as a woman I do feel women are in many way reponsible for the miseries of women. Many women are masochistic and it's even more hilarious how they don't realise how misogynistic they are being in their self-righteous arguments.
I often hear some women proclaim, "I'm no feminist... but I do feel bla bla bla...". The fact that they feel this need to add this prefix of 'I'm no feminist' says a lot. The mistaken belief that feminism deals with women's issues only and that too issues of the 'aggressive' women is so widespread among even the educated classes.
The popular connotations of feminists have changed over the years as manipulated by the inherently 'male' mainstream media.
Initially they were the rebellious aggressive women you should keep your wife away from.
Then they were the bunch of bad looking geeks who'd never get a boyfriend.
Nowadays feminists are also tagged as 'lesbians', of course in a pejorative way. Well I'm happy that the society at least recognised lesbianism. Earlier gay sex was only about sodomy.
Now coming to why so many women feel the need conform to these patriarchal devices.
To gain acceptance mainly. You know it's like when you go to new school you feel the compulsion to do a lot things so that you get into the popular group. It's important to be lady-like. or sati-like. whatever!
Now why it is so important for women to gain acceptance of the men in the work space, family or even in buses, trains is something I'm trying to understand. Perhaps because the notion that men are some kind of higher beings bestowed with greater and nobler duties has been ingrained in their minds through ages. And why not? Look at our rituals, raksha bandhan- the brother protects the sister for she is vulnerable (bodily). Kadva chauth- the woman must fast for her man's longer life. I can go on... but you get the point right? Also she grows up seeing her mother serving her father when he comes home, bringing him tea, food. So the role of women in the domestic space pretty much defines her space elsewhere too, even though she goes to office now, a space where she co-habits with the man. She still comes back and serves her husband at the dinner table.
The woman's role in the family and her secondary status is obvious even to a child.
I've often faced that situation. "if she doesn't have an issue, what's your problem?" And I feel so helpless.
A friend of mine was getting beaten up by her boyfriend (who happened to be a friend too) and according to her, he'll change and her love will change him! I didn't know how to make her understand that to him she's like a pet, or even worse. Definitely not a partner.
One thing that works well is culture shock, that I've seen. They'll cringe, just like we cringe looking at them, but then being an alternative wave is far better than existing on the accepted lines.
And I agree with this being a predominantly Indian problem. Fealty by marriage to the man is very much an Oriental notion.
The west has its set of bigotries, but nowhere is it so difficult for women to command her rights on her body, her sexuality and her space. Cue: our crowded buses.
A man's hand all over my body but I hesitate to say anything and finally when I do say something, the women would look away as if I've disgraced them and entire womanhood. And the man would lecture me on how it's my problem and I should take a cab. It happens only in India.

Okay this became too long. I rant a lot. 😳




Edited by -bLEu98- - 11 years ago
373577 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: -bLEu98-

A man's hand all over my body but I hesitate to say anything and finally when I do say something, the women would look away as if I've disgraced them and entire womanhood. And the man would lecture me on how it's my problem and I should take a cab. It happens only in India.

Okay this became too long. I rant a lot. 😳

Now in which part of India did you se this happening ?🤓 From what I have seen in my city the girls give back as good as they get and a lot more. The decent guys are quite wary of them and prefer to keep a safe distance while travelling in any public transport. The slightest protest by a girl and the whole busload of people will stare at the guy like he is some freak from Mars
-bLEu98- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: zorrro

Now in which part of India did you se this happening ?🤓 From what I have seen in my city the girls give back as good as they get and a lot more. The decent guys are quite wary of them and prefer to keep a safe distance while travelling in any public transport. The slightest protest by a girl and the whole busload of people will stare at the guy like he is some freak from Mars

India has a lot more space than its urban areas. Even I grew up in city but I've seen the rest of the country too, well, some of it. And there are places where people would stare if a man and woman sit next to each other. Yes, I've been to such places. Is the urban women only entitled to liberty?
and believe me even in some cities, girls don't really find the courage to give it back good. The city where I live, we do, but not every other city.
*Woh Ajnabee* thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: K.Universe.



But I think I agree with the highly cautionary tone that one needs to adopt here.


Extremely late reply, I know, I know.

I'll give you the example of preimplantation genetic diagnosis - this biopsy is performed when the embryo reaches the 8-cell stage. The embryologist will then go in and aspirate 1-2 cells from the 8-cell embryo and that will be used for genetic testing. Extracting 1-2 cells from an 8-cell embryo is VERY different than extracting a few hundred cells from an organism with a thousand of cells. It's very easy to permanently damage the embryo at this stage - it's basic human error. A poking of a needle a fraction of a micrometer in the wrong direction.

---

But that's not why I came here - did you guys read the NY Times last Sunday? Great article about 3-parent IVF. This stuff makes me really excited, so I like sharing. Click, click.

K.Universe. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*



Extremely late reply, I know, I know.




Not a problem! Between karma, free will and reservation for Jats, I am not sure I can find time to talk about embryos and zygotes.

Besides, Rehanism is least appreciative of any of this so I will pass on commenting further.

Related Topics

Debate Mansion Thumbnail

Posted by: Viswasruti

27 days ago

🤱Surrogacy: Womb For Hire ! Is It A Blessing Or A Curse For Women?👶

🤱Surrogacy: Womb For Hire! Is It A Blessing Or A Curse For Women?👶 Infertility can be a challenging obstacle to overcome, but advances in...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".