Ankita or Richa - Page 2

Richa...I personally think she has beautiful voice regardless of comment of her childish voice. I also found Javed ji's comment to be bit ridiculous. As some of you pointed out, the judges should have told her earlier that she should come back after couple years when her voice matures. It is judges' mistake to bring her in piano round at first place when everyone can clear see the childish voice in her.
As for Ankita, she has been bit disappointing because so far she has only sung one type of songs. She is great performer but in order to declare herself as a good singer, she should singer variety of other songs.

yesterday's

didn't like richa or ankita

ankita was still better than richa...

Originally posted by: jhansiv

Richa any day over Ankita for me...

Ankita, she goes out of sur even in simple songs and that too at many places...(exception is her today's mehbooba performance where she sang well). Also she sang only

Richa has more knowledge of sur... she goes out of sur only at a few places and that too for difficult songs... When she is singing each and every note is heard so clearly... she understands the finer nuances of difficult songs like 'piya tohse naina' and sings them well... only few of her notes have dropped...

I find the childish voice comment quite silly...

Also except in the theatre round she did not add unnecessary classical touch to any of the piano round songs...

One short coming is that she needs to add more expressions to her songs...
To some extent she has added in the songs 'kabhie neem neem' and 'pal pal pal' songs... In the older songs its difficult to add expressions even for the current established singers... .. (because in the older songs the story and plot used to be quite rich and only those old heroines could emote and those old singers could add right expressions to them...) In fact the current generation hardly identifies with those emotions..

I think Richa should sing more of modern songs like Kabhi neem neem etc., which are high in musical quality as well contain emotions/expressions that the current generation identifies with...

👏

ANKITA
richa thinks she's better then everyone but since Javed sir feels she's not ready it's the truth...

VOTE FOR EMON!!!!! 😳 👏

I really dislike Richa..She has terrible attitude, and that was shown in the theatre rounds when she refused to do a duet with Prashant. She forgot her lines..yet she still got through. Her voice isn't mature enough yet, no doubt she is a good singer but really she's too young and her voice is too too meethi.
I thought both were not too good, I Personally thought Suhit was still more decent..out of the two, you could tell he was really trying. I don't think he should've gone out just yet, he should've had a chance to prove himself in the Galas.



Anjali