Judges being too hard on richa....

I was veryy sad to see richa cry 2dai..i thought she sang 'piya tose' very well 2dai..i agree her voice is childish..ofcourse it is ..but so is puja's and shifa's....y did they never get the comment tht they sound very childish.....and the way the criticised was very bad.....and hurtful... i mean thr's a way of saying the same thing in a milder tone....i really didn't think the judges shld have been soo hard on her 2dai...shez not the onli one who has a childish voice..and some ppl on the show are singing worse than her....i was sad to see her cry 2dai...

omggg we have the same topic 😳 I totally agree with u!

Her voice was too kacha in many places... it kept changing with different lines of the stanza...

Thankfully the Judges are not captivated by her innocent bacha smile and are actually concentrating on her voice.

(before her supporters come to lynch me, I was a staunch Richa supporter, till I heard her today. I had missed all the episodes in between, so dont know how she sang in them)

ohhh..is thr another topic like this..sorry i didn't notice...

I agree that the judges were being a bit too harsh but the truth is Richa is going down since piana round started. The judges have very high expectations from her..and if she fails to live up to it then critism is bound to come her way 😊 ..i think that she isnt so childish as she looks like..its time she should start working hard on her singing skills.

Originally posted by: s.priya

Her voice was too kacha in many places... it kept changing with different lines of the stanza...

Thankfully the Judges are not captivated by her innocent bacha smile and are actually concentrating on her voice.

(before her supporters come to lynch me, I was a staunch Richa supporter, till I heard her today. I had missed all the episodes in between, so dont know how she sang in them)

no yaar no body will be coming down on u..for talking abt rich..i'm just saying the way judges harshly spoke to her..was uncalled for...

Originally posted by: s.priya

Her voice was too kacha in many places... it kept changing with different lines of the stanza...

Thankfully the Judges are not captivated by her innocent bacha smile and are actually concentrating on her voice.

(before her supporters come to lynch me, I was a staunch Richa supporter, till I heard her today. I had missed all the episodes in between, so dont know how she sang in them)

priya di actually she was brilliant during the auditions and ppl were amazed by her talent..but during the piano round smth happened to her..she gets negative comments every week..im glad too that the judges didnt overlook her singing..their comments were absolutely flawless..

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

no yaar no body will be coming down on u..for talking abt rich..i'm just saying the way judges harshly spoke to her..was uncalled for...

U thought the Judges were harsh?? I dont think so... they gave her a fair comment... that she had a good quality voice.. she has a unique voice, just that even now there is a lot of childishness in it... which clashes with the songs she sings, thereby throwing them in striking contrast...

Originally posted by: Ananya_A

priya di actually she was brilliant during the auditions and ppl were amazed by her talent..but during the piano round smth happened to her..she gets negative comments every week..im glad too that the judges didnt overlook her singing..their comments were absolutely flawless..

Yeah Anu, she was brilliant in the elimns, isnt it.. Well, aage aage dekho hota hai kya

Richa was defenitely very good in auditions.
But even before piano round they had enough oppportunities to see that she has a childish voice. Personally I think she is a very good singer.
But if they didnt wnat a singer with childish voice in indian idol and they think its not indian idol standard then I think they shouldnt have selected her in top 28. I am not saying she doesnt deserve to be.. but its better they dont select her rather than select and say its not II standard because its childish.. one cannot change once voice over night..
alisha said she isnt taking it seriously.. what can she do.. her voice is like that at her age.. and its completely irrelevant that puja's or shifa's is more matured comapred to richa at the same age.. bcos there is no rule that every 16 yrs voice shud be matured. can she take it seriously and sing without any childish hint tommorrow? criticism on sur taal is fine.. but saying aap jab bhi gaati hai lagta hai ek bachhi ga rahi hai is stupid.. she has bachhi jaisi voice.. so obviosuly it wil sound so.. and I will not even comment on those who say she fakes it.. I mean yeah I guess I am supposed to udnerstand that a person who wants to win will fake a voice which will earn her only criticism.. isnt she more cunning than that in ur eyes?
I did feel sorry when she cried because her voice is not going to chage in tommorrow's episode.. and she knows it.. it will take atleast few yrs.. or maybe even 1 yr to grow matured.. not 24 hours..