Left a lot to be desired. - Page 2

I would like to partially disagree with you.
As you stated the two scenarios were different here, I would like to add that the two scenes were totally in different context.
For Asad it was his realization of depth of love he has for Zoya, he was always denying his feelings for Zoya but this situation brought out all his emotions, so it was intense and beautifully acted by KSG.
For Ahil it was humanity and moral responsibility of helping out a the girl that too the girl who is a part of his house, when he was the hope of that girl to save her life. It's only after mouth to mouth CPR, he looked confused, shocked, he kept staring at Sanam. KVB's acting was wonderful which actually gave out exactly Ahil's feelings. He was so subtle and natural.
Asad had tears of realization, guilt and desperation of losing Zoya forever.
Ahil had perspiration due to frustration and helplessness of not being able to save the girl who trusted him to save her life.
For AsYa it was the realization of love, turning point of a love story, for SaHil it's the beginning of a love story.
The two scenes context was entirely different though set up was similar.
And all 3 actors portrayed the scenes wonderfully.

Fanraya, you understood my POV completely..absolutely. That silent attraction, caring, concern..hasn't matured yet for Saahil as it had for Asya when this intense scene was placed.

Originally posted by: bbbccc

Why comparing two scenes, are they apple to apple?

Like you said, there was lot of interaction between AsYa and they were at some level of understanding and there was strong attraction and exchange of strong words, I don't think that scene would have been impactful if wasn't for "pata nahi kab aapse picha chootega". They were both in it from beginning from journey Bhopal to Mangalpur alone..

Would you want same scene? Same scenario, then we might have complained where is creativity..

This scene wasn't accident or incident, it was planned and well played. But this might be starting of something which in AsYa case should have been to, instead all we saw MU and Tanveer..

And you are wrong when you say the focus was on them, it was part of PV and QH MS, the two stories were mashed up together. Take out Yash Aarti part, that might have fizzled out too..

I agree that scene was quick and less impactful but then do we want to see Tanveer and her bullies, bullying Sanam and dragging? I wasn't, so ok with how it played out. SJ and KVB did they part with full sincerity like SJ and KSG did. Story has to move on and I am happy that it is..

Also such scenes are easy on eyes when villain is third party someone unknown or I would say unbiased, Mamu Vs Tanveer, hatred level for Manu was none with viewers and with Tanveer it already shoot off the roof..

Ummm...just want to clarify...I DID mention in my post that they ARE NOT the same scene or scenario...and there was no comparison about that.

My only desire was to see a bit more interaction between Saahil so that audiences got the urge to root for them more. It just seemed a bit rushed.

When it comes to focus...during the ASYA burial scene...it was two separate series...QH fans weren't even concentrating on PV arc...also the PV characters were in the QH scene with Asya.


I am really uncomfortable about your tone of accusation...I am not wrong in voicing my opinion. I just pointed my POV about the characters. Chill... 😊

Originally posted by: bhavnahm

I would like to partially disagree with you.
As you stated the two scenarios were different here, I would like to add that the two scenes were totally in different context.
For Asad it was his realization of depth of love he has for Zoya, he was always denying his feelings for Zoya but this situation brought out all his emotions, so it was intense and beautifully acted by KSG.
For Ahil it was humanity and moral responsibility of helping out a the girl that too the girl who is a part of his house, when he was the hope of that girl to save her life. It's only after mouth to mouth CPR, he looked confused, shocked, he kept staring at Sanam. KVB's acting was wonderful which actually gave out exactly Ahil's feelings. He was so subtle and natural.
Asad had tears of realization, guilt and desperation of losing Zoya forever.
Ahil had perspiration due to frustration and helplessness of not being able to save the girl who trusted him to save her life.
For AsYa it was the realization of love, turning point of a love story, for SaHil it's the beginning of a love story.
The two scenes context was entirely different though set up was similar.
And all 3 actors portrayed the scenes wonderfully.

Loved your post...thank you for making some sense of the scene. I mean SJ/KVB look so good together...I would love them in any scene...but randomly placed intense scenes are a bit hard to swallow. However, your justification makes a lot of sense.
Thanks :D

👏 well said!! asya scenes were alwaus very intense, their chemistry jus sizzling!!! but Sahil bonding not yet proven, chemistry there but not enough for this scene yet!!!

i have not seen the scene or the episodes in their entirety...I got a only a few glimpses...