I hate this show - Page 2

In my opinion,Adesh is doing wonderful job.The concept of asvoi is very clear,suro se samjhouta nahi aur besure bardasht nahi.I think Gajji is going back to the roots.Those were the days when Sonu Nigam in srgm used to ask every contestant before singing"aapne sangeet ki shiksha kisse prapt ki hai" and all the participant used to tell the name of some guru ji or ustad👏...Now we have three singing based shows going on for three types of viewers.If u like dramebaaji,Srgmp07 is there.Agar hasane ka man hai to I I 3 dekho.And if u want to see good singers performing their best"welcome to Asvoi" 😊.

time will tell...this show is head and shoulders above the other 2..
watched saturday night challenge-poor khayyam saab..after listening to the calibre of mohmmed vakil,parthiv,bela,sudeshna etc on sregama..it was simply too painful for me to watch.

last night on II3..well watch it yourselves.. 😒

Awesome post Ankita... The judges never make a show.. Its the singers, and this show has the best singers... Totally agree to the above post by Saans also... Its your choice, go and watch the show you like, you may have different criteria to like or not like a show...

If you want to listen to great musical talent, come watch this show.. else you definitely have other options going on.. but pls pls, do not come and make such hate posts!

Originally posted by: pungi123

friends, I have started hating this show. The attitude of the judges and the show reflects that they are the best. I have heard over and over from people and read in the books that the first step to success or greatness is being polite.I don't understand how people like Alka, Aadesh and Abhijeet are there where they are. They seem to have an attitude problem.
If a contestant is not singing well then that can be be said without being rude and thats why people will respect you and your judgement. I hate the show becase I hate the way Aadesh and Abhijeet discourages the contestant who are not up to the mark and I hate the show because of the way Alka carries herself in the show. Man, what an attitude and what a show.

i agree to you in all the points you mentioned, but i would not say i "hate" the show - that wud be a bit too harsh... i dislike the judges totally and they are a big time put off... i started watching the show with so much excitement coz it was from gajendra - who has given c2005 in the past... but sadly, the biggest loss to him this time is his choice of judges... and no one has any control over them - they can do wat they like... there is a serious flaw in the direction... also, every lil while they dont forget to remind us on the show that "suron se samjhota nahi hoga" but i think they r as good or bad as other shows... each show has one or two extraordinary talent, some mediocre and rest below average... same with voi...

this is just my viewpoint... no offense meant and i sincerely hope that this show does well and brings us some good singers 😊

All I will say that the musical sensibilities vary from person to person... Not really saying that the attitude of the judges is great and the show can actually do very well even without this forced rudeness, but all I will say that its not fair to use the tags like has-beens and stuff... These judges may not be eye-candy material like the judges of some other shows, but they have also contributed a lot to the world of film music in the last decade or so.. Jatin Lalit have almost been syonymous with melody, Alka has given the max number of hits in the past decade and Abhijeet has one of the best playback voices after Sonu Nigam... Why bring them down like this.. And yes, having said this, I agree that they have not been the best of judges on the show! As for liking the singers or not - well again depends on the musical sensibilities... For some, it may be just the voice and the tonal quality and the singing attributes that matter. for others, they may like a more complete performing package to call them a good singer... All depends on the person, and there are enough shows on air today to satisfy all...

Also - if someone does not like this show, its probably better not to spend negetive energy here!

sorry😛 - maybe my views were against the show, but i assure i did not wish to demean it 😊 i was just a lil put off by aadesh's disposure on the show this week in particular, so maybe i said so... i wont say anything negative anymore 😛

Originally posted by: smallwonder

sorry😛 - maybe my views were against the show, but i assure i did not wish to demean it 😊 i was just a lil put off by aadesh's disposure on the show this week in particular, so maybe i said so... i wont say anything negative anymore 😛

SmallWonder - respect your opinion😊 and I didnt think your comments were demeaning either... Even I thought that Adesh simply crossed the line this week.. I hope he does improve from next week onwards.. I am also hoping that once the audition rounds end, we will see the better side of these judges... after all those will be the singers selected by them😊

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

SmallWonder - respect your opinion😊 and I didnt think your comments were demeaning either... Even I thought that Adesh simply crossed the line this week.. I hope he does improve from next week onwards.. I am also hoping that once the audition rounds end, we will see the better side of these judges... after all those will be the singers selected by them😊

thnx 😊 ya i am also expecting the same... i feel once the auditions r over, we wud get the real show as far as singing goes - i dont expect the judges to change much😳... looking forward to sharib's bro next epi...😊

This topic is being closed now.

You can say anything to the show - good or bad. You can debate on it too. But demeaning other shows be it directly or indirectly will not be allowed here. That serves no purpose other than bring in bitterness among members of IF. Always remember IF is finally one sections may be different.

The member who made the post talked about this show. He/she did not like a particlar episode so commented. You all can make comment supporting SVOI but that does not give you the right to demean other shows.

Anyone can post his POV so long that does not break any IF COC rules. If you find comments you do not like, feel free to make use of the "Report" button. Members are being advised that NO ONE will suggest to another member to leave a thread or section if the POV does not match.This is totally unacceptable.

Take it as a warning. Next time anyone found doing it will face action from the Dev Team.


IF Dev Team