apalled by Alisha's opinions

I mean she somehow doesnt come across as a fiar judge to me . Her opinions are based on her liking for the contestant I feel. Today she felt Deepali was off sur and Richa was very good and on sur . As a singer , I can clearly see the difference between the two performances.

The same happened when she wasjudging the men too , she was cheering for Sujit like anything and that guy with the ulti topi Abhishek, but when the others some of them who perfiormed much much better , she said they werent in sur much , that was appaling.

I am losing all my respect for her judgement as she seems more biased towards some contestants.

I feel amongst all of them , Javed Akhtar seems fair .

No offense to any fans of any contestant or Alisha

feel free to debate , thanks

Yes you are right

Javed Sab - best and speaks his mind

Alisha - Doesn't seem to have a good ear for music though she is an extraordinary singer

Anu Malik - Speaks his mind

Udit - Vewry sweet and Meak - so cannot take is judgement seriously

well i never...all the singers looked good to me 😆 i mean deepali was good..so was richa...i really cant pick out the minor differences..unless its like they r braying 😆 .but i definitely feel that javed akhtar's judgement is fairer than the others.i feel alisha is a little biased since she cheers for suhit 😕 and even she was saying tht 'tumhare gale mein bhi sur hai'...means tht till tht time he was always out of sur.so then how did he come in the top 28?and sreejo was eliminated 🤢 i fail to understand why even established singers do things like this 😕

I somewhat agree with you..I sometimes feel that her comments are biased. I can't explain the reasons though 😆

never mind about her judgment, but wen she told javed sahab to dance with that gender crises person(ankit/ankita), and she said that javed should dance because last time she made her and anu dance, but it was udit who danced.

Originally posted by: rose82

well i never...all the singers looked good to me 😆 i mean deepali was good..so was richa...i really cant pick out the minor differences..unless its like they r braying 😆 .but i definitely feel that javed akhtar's judgement is fairer than the others.i feel alisha is a little biased since she cheers for suhit 😕 and even she was saying tht 'tumhare gale mein bhi sur hai'...means tht till tht time he was always out of sur.so then how did he come in the top 28?and sreejo was eliminated 🤢 i fail to understand why even established singers do things like this 😕

I donno why, but I couldn't stop laughing when I read the highlighted line .... 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣

On a serious note though, even the judges now agree that he doesn't really sing well and he is there only because of his X-factor .....

Originally posted by: RKhan

never mind about her judgment, but wen she told javed sahab to dance with that gender crises person(ankit/ankita), and she said that javed should dance because last time she made her and anu dance, but it was udit who danced.

Well, Alisha and Anu danced with her in the auditon round and Udit ji danced with her in the 1st Piano round .... hope that helps 😃