Help can be a Hindrance - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

1.7k

Users

9

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

hanan72 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: reeha...k


You're welcome for the analysis 😆

I do agree to some extent that she's caught in a difficult position, but it's still really odd:
- Her first encounter with her son is understandable, but even after then she's been in a daze where we haven't been able to see her interacting or thinking about Rudra OR paro. Like another person said in another thread, It's almost like she's in her own little bubble 😕la bubble may be a depression that inhibits neurons and act consistently

As for the rest, I do think coming home would be a shock to anyone, but she's still awefully silent, and hasn't attempted to even communicate with Paro, after all Paro has been through hell and high water, and she has "raised" and been "like a mother" to her for all these years...I don't know I think the CVs have failed to reiterate this maternal side that they've SAID to us, but haven't SHOWN us via actions that should have occured lately 🤔. Maybe that's just for now, but they'll show it down the line? Wishful thinking I guess! 😕I agree, it seems that it has lost the maternal instinct with his smooth face expressionless, but may be this is the expected goal.
By cons I want to see a little emotion on his face

Paro, is defo a Saint, so I don't think a UN job is beyond her 😆oh no I do not want Mother Teresa I need the romantic scenes to follow😆

tttttt1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
nice post :-)
something is missing in the characterization of mala
a woman who decided to end the marriage because it was meaningless , choose to be happy , choose to mother a random girl can either be a and self centered manipulator or a nice soul
either ways she cant be clueless , she cant be this weak
she can be either a go getter (then there sgouldnt be any self pity )
or she is as nice as paro believes her to be (then she should gather by now any attempts of paro to mend her relationship is putting both paro and rudra into captive situation like you mentioned)
feeling guilty for leaving rudra i understand , but this doesnt explain mala behavior completely , i see a flaw here
180506 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Msfrootie



Reeha, well said.. I was just ranting on the same on Diya di's post..

I respected her for being strong enough to get out of a bad marriage and even follow her heart if that was the case with Teju. She made her decisions and she lived it. Now why this self pity and expectation from Paro to solve everything for her. To the extent that Paro has to almost resort to falsehood to console her.. I feel this is another character going the Laila way. Laila was turned into the evil witch and Mala will be the spineless tear bag. Hope she takes a turn for the better in the coming days..😕


Exactly! I would be completely OK with her being courageous enough to find happiness...but this whole dichotomey of being lost, not knowing what to do, relying on Paro to guide her...it's just too weird. There's no paramount concern for her in terms of understanding Paro, finding out what happened to her, how she's married to her son, what Tejawat did, what she saw..it almost makes me think her tears for Paro when she thought she was dead were not worth while. This character contradiction is either intentional, because there's a bigger picture here, or the CVs have made a lapse accidentally? I'm so confused right now! 😆
rendezvousvin thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14
Exactly my feelings... Thanks for making this post... I am annoyed with Mala because she is just a silent spectator when she should be the one trying to bridge the gap between herself and her son... If she is so innocent and loved her son so much, why can't she try explaining it to him?... Him listening to her or understanding her will only come when she try speaking... Or does she expect him to come to her and ask, Maa Sa How have you been all these years? ...
180506 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ttt1

nice post :-)
something is missing in the characterization of mala
a woman who decided to end the marriage because it was meaningless , choose to be happy , choose to mother a random girl can either be a and self centered manipulator or a nice soul
either ways she cant be clueless , she cant be this weak
she can be either a go getter (then there sgouldnt be any self pity )
or she is as nice as paro believes her to be (then she should gather by now any attempts of paro to mend her relationship is putting both paro and rudra into captive situation like you mentioned)
feeling guilty for leaving rudra i understand , but this doesnt explain mala behavior completely , i see a flaw here


Exactly...something about this all this that's just too flakey and unrealistic: and you're right she comes off as VERY weak. This character flaw needs to be reconciled, and if not they need to makes sure this conflict goes somewhere: Maybe she IS a bit more sinister than we know and realize; or maybe she's just a flake? 🤔 But this whole "inbetween" stuff doesn't work. she doesn't come off as a grey character, just a poorly written one thus far.
Dsntmatter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
They're ruining RangRasiya in my opinion. It began with a very realistic approach but now they're justifying every single character. Next we find out that Mohini was possessed by the dark forces and TakurSa was exporting toy guns to orphans across the border. I mean seriously they shouldn't lighten the sins of MalaMaa's rangeen life. Then after all said and done if RudraSa decides to forgive her without Paro Bhaisa's continuous interference then I would find it acceptable. Now I don't think they should show RudraSa lying on his mother's lap while she sings that godforsaken lullaby but a slow reconciliation between the two would be believable.
Another thing is I can't believe the ease with which Paro is forgiving her "supposed" mother's past - just how many mothers does this orphan have; in the beginning of the show MalaMaa was just a rich woman with a soft corner for a poor orphan and that does not make her a mother to Paro! And ughhh the poetically beautiful way in which Paro basically says that she was a replacement for Rudra all these years! MalaMaa's only path to redemption in my mind was something like this:
In an intense climax where takurSa tries to kill off the Sunsilk's unofficial brand ambassador, MalaMaa jumps in front of the bullet and dies. And then everyone forgives her on her funeral. Happy ending.
SherryGS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#17
Interesting take for sure. I think a huge part of the radon Mala is in this situation to begin with is that she is in fact a weak woman. She is easily manipulated and not able to stand up to people. Sad, but I think that is her character . I don't hate her, as most of RR forum does :) but I se that she is not a pillar of strength by any means.
Dsntmatter thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: SherryGS

Interesting take for sure. I think a huge part of the radon Mala is in this situation to begin with is that she is in fact a weak woman. She is easily manipulated and not able to stand up to people. Sad, but I think that is her character . I don't hate her, as most of RR forum does :) but I se that she is not a pillar of strength by any means.


The problem is they won't show her as weak, they'll show her as a victim in a huge conspiracy by God knows how many people.
SherryGS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Dsntmatter



The problem is they won't show her as weak, they'll show her as a victim in a huge conspiracy by God knows how many people.



I should really read other peoples posts before posting! Lol! There is another post here detailing the weakness of the Mala character. It is exactly what I was thinking of when I wrote this. :)
SherryGS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: _SenbonZakura_

When have you ever seen her do something Reeha?? I have always said, Mala is the weakest. I have no idea how her son and her pseudo-daughter turned out to be this strong.


Because, Mala, is not what you call strong.

Her sister influenced her. Her marriage wasn't good enough.. She left.

She tried getting her son back, once, maybe twice.. But that was it.

Fifteen years she spent in agony, I understand. But then, what did she do to alleviate that pain?

She was a Rani right? A Rani Thakurain... She had resources. Finding her son was THAT difficult? Nahi.

She was just weak. She just floated through her life. Never stepping up.

Aur uska kuch nahi kar sakte. She is like that only.

I really don't expect anything off of her.



Exactly!! I also believe she us just simply a weak woman who us an easy target for manipulation. I should have read your post first. :)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".