J&B Treated Like Stepchildren by Creative - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

137

Views

5.4k

Users

29

Frequent Posters

juney thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Maybe a few of her Salwar Kamezees have thinner straps.

Biggest letdown of a Bani scene: Bani has been missing her children for 5 years. .....Than when she does meet her children it should have been the most mind-blowing scene. PD has proved with her past performances that she can give heart wrenching scenes - MA/Jail/Post oNS reveal. What we got was a half-hearted pat on the checks for the kids. No hug nothing. ... The creatives blundered what should have been one of the highlight scenes post leap. ....all she is doing is highfiving them. She showed more emotions when she did not know atharva was her son. I blame the creatives here as PD is not a mother and they have completely failed in conceptualizing this crucial scene that could have been a masterpiece

cheers,

meghna


absolutely right meghna. That was the most anticipated post-leap scene. I was looking forward to it more than JB scece... and what a downer that was. It fell flat. She didn't even give them a hug. even @ the preschool, she seems more like their masi than their mom. Hinestly, Rano seems (& acts ) more like a mother. Both ranvir and rano are giving some dignified perfomances. 👏
As far as Bani/Durga is concerned, both in dressing and histrionics. it was a complete letdown. Please, don't get me wrong here, but I think even Ronit Roy is giving a decent performance with the idiotic lines they are giving him.
My 2 c
Jojo_han thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: rose467

ohhhh yeah, the creatives thought that we will follow JB to kumbh mela... but i am sure we both haven't been there yet... 😉 atleast i am sure i haven't gone😊

You should do, at least that way you will be able to help Amma and Bhudha to come clean about what's going on in their head. Using the standrad language either Hindi or English but must be high quality.... meaning no kekta land dialogue... the speech should also be from a -z 😉

555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Cordelia


Farah / Megs,

I totally agree with you guys!! The creatives have messed up big time!! What could have been a story arc to bring KS back into the top 3, and have everyone hooked to their screens, has turned into a confusing joke, with a very crappy punchline! 😡 😡 😡

I also think KS would have been riveting again with Bani's revenge track. I would have loved to see the love hate relationship between them, their interaction with the children, the revenge against Pia and co. It would have been a fantastic trrack, but alas we got picture burning and adbhoot bhaiyya

The things that used to annoy me about Bani like her jasoosi tendencies, senseless self-sacrifice etc that have been prevalent from the very beginning of the show - have suddenly disappeared when at this juuncture they would have been so welcome!!! 😕

I cannot belive I am saying that but can we please have Bani Bond back again. I so miss the strong independent Bani, rather than this puppet we are seeing on screen everyday

It would have been great to see Bani finding out everything about WM in its current state, using all that info to destroy her enemies - just imagine, if she had gone snooping around WM like Jannat apartments then we could have had scenes where:

- she came across the children playing and realised who they were (instead of the stupid bloody footprint)

That was one of the biggest letdowns of the leap. The first scene with bani and the kids should have been mindblowing, instead we got just a badly concieved, badly directed scene.
- or a scene where JW would have felt her presence in the house and she could overhear him talking to her pic,
- or even something like, Rano is cooking in the kitchen and the dish tastes odd or something and Rano goes off to check on the kids and Bani (maybe watching from behind) adds something in... then when Rano comes back and tastes it she wonders how it tastes like what her Di used to make etc etc

(silly i know, getting a bit carried away... 😆 )

all would have been great scenes cordy, a lot better than what we are being dishedd out lately

... someone made the point that PD is not a mother and perhaps couldnt connect with the scene which affected its portrayal, however, it cannot be denied that considering her lack of experience she is a stunning actress - in a well-written scene she would emote anything well!!! the lack of poignancy in that scene had little to do with her talent and much more to do with the terrible writing of the scene!!! 🤢 🤢 🤢

So agree and also I think KS got a new director and I think he is the newest addition to the growing bunch of incompetent people in charge of KS these days

As for JW's scene, I actually liked the symbolism of him giving everything away, however, because of the 3rd-rate extras and rubbishy screenplay the whole scene was ruined!! 😡 RK is the best actor in the Balaji stables by a mile, and the fact that even some of his scenes aren't interesting anymore, shows how badly they have been written. 🤢

Agree. When sis JW become so OTT? Another lost opportunity for a fantastic scene. When you have an actor who can express 6 diff emotioons in 30 secs through his guys, people use him

Kekta, if you are listening, I seriously advise you change your staff, otherwise you are going to destroy what little is left of one of your best shows. 😡

Please ekta change your staff starting with

1. new creative head

2. new dialouge writer

3. new screenplay writer

4. new director

Edited by m3ghna - 18 years ago
rose467 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Jojo_han

You should do, at least that way you will be able to help Amma and Bhudha to come clean about what's going on in their head. Using the standrad language either Hindi or English but must be high quality.... meaning no kekta land dialogue... the speech should also be from a -z 😉

no way honey to get them directed to one side... u know what as per the nature of the two... jai walia will be looking into one point, where bani is ... but she had a nature that her head never stay in quiet, it will be turning in 360 degree continously because she is a born bond-girl... so what i will do... no way... that too in water...

bani failed me totally today... i expected a shock in seeing jai in an injured condition for the sake of love she atleast once felt for him... but in the update i read she was cold.. she failed our trust on her

555W59 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: juney


absolutely right meghna. That was the most anticipated post-leap scene. I was looking forward to it more than JB scece... and what a downer that was. It fell flat. She didn't even give them a hug. even @ the preschool, she seems more like their masi than their mom. Hinestly, Rano seems (& acts ) more like a mother. Both ranvir and rano are giving some dignified perfomances. 👏
As far as Bani/Durga is concerned, both in dressing and histrionics. it was a complete letdown. Please, don't get me wrong here, but I think even Ronit Roy is giving a decent performance with the idiotic lines they are giving him.
My 2 c

Juney,

Today they destroyed another highly anticipated post leap scene, JB coming face to face with each other for the first time. I did not expect them to rush into each others arms but I did expect more pathos and feelings - Banis' heartbreak, Jai's helplessness. Why are they destryoing just good scenes with so much clutter and non-sense. They don't need all these scene feelers. Each day they are diluting KS a little more till nothing will be left.

meghna

rooj-i thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
i guess im really late to such beautiful post!
megs bravo!! 👏 👏 👏
you are absolutely right they are butchering such special scenes not to mention our Protagonists and today's epi. is another one of the examples of such sheer stupidity of the creatives and not so much creativity..
i mean take how JB met and then Bani didn't show even one emotion...she was stone cold towards the man she still loves but have put up a parda against it...
its just plain stupid...
then JW...come on this guy is showing great way of running after his wife and i admire him...but please see what is happening around you yaar...
now to AD this guy is heading the Pia way and if he keep doing stuff like this then there will be no turning back just like Pia can't now..
even if the creatives tried to redeem her now it won't even work...she's below hell in my eyes...
and if they do that to AD before time then he will be too...
sorry just my POV
rooj
juney thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: m3ghna

Juney,

Today they destroyed another highly anticipated post leap scene, JB coming face to face with each other for the first time. I did not expect them to rush into each others arms but I did expect more pathos and feelings - Banis' heartbreak, Jai's helplessness. Why are they destryoing just good scenes with so much clutter and non-sense. They don't need all these scene feelers. Each day they are diluting KS a little more till nothing will be left.

meghna

Yes,there was no sensitivity in the scene. It was diluted with clutter and utter nonsense. And, there was no emotion from bani at all. Is it only me or does any one share my sentiments also.. PD for some reason is not able to emote as well as DDG. I hope she brings back her verve in the coming episodes. At least, I want her rudra avataar when she avenges Pia

june

moudeb2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
I agree with the sentiments so wholeheartedly. Jai and Bani are being treated very shabbily by the whole creative team. It seems the motto is to kill these two characters for the glorification of Pia and AD.

Nothing works for them
1. clothes are bad
2. dialouges are bad
3. scenes are bad

The only thing worth is that when they are in the same frame I want to keep on watching instead of turning off the tv when Pia and AD comes on. It's really sad as I would see any Ronit scenes multiple times in Kasauti and here he drives me mad.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".