2nd Round Winner - Judge vs. Judge

Page

Next Last

kggk_fan01

@kggk_fan01

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Hello everyone!!!😛

We have received the results, Thanks to lashy for being our judge for round 2.

The following write up is by lashy regarding her judgement and winner details

***********************************************************

Comments:

As is always the case, it's very sad to pick one winner when you wish you could complement all of the participants equally!... lets look at it this way one person was slightly better than the rest not that the rest were worse than the winner in any way!

I complement DB on her command of the language and her expressiveness. A very intelligent debater with admirable stance... but one can truly feel for the debate by manshaa – it came from the heart, was the most convincing and her rebuttal-tackling stood apart!!!

Hence the winner of this debate contest is manshaa from the udit narayan gharaana!!!!!!!👏

I wish mrs sk did not have computer problems and could participate more. Her debates (in just the two topics that she was able to post) were really shaping up very well. If she had more time to participate she would have put up a tough competition for the other two. I also sincerely wish poonam was here to participate but she could be a part of the next debate

The biggest reason all of you were winners is the temperament of the debaters.. i wish the rest of IF got to read this thread and learn how to maintain one's integrity from you three (and your cute little supporters/cheerleaders😳!)

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this thread... three cheers to all of you!!!!!!!!!!!!👏

😳

DB –

JAVED AKHTHAR

MANSHAA -

UDIT NARAYAN

MRS.SALMAN KHAN -

ANU MALIK

POONAM - ALISHA CHINOY

Language

excellent

8.5

very good

8.2

very good

Variety of points raised (i.e. Not being repetitive)

(About 5 points)

(About 6 points)

7.5

(About 4 points)

Tact of dealing with rebuttals

8.5

Very good

Excellent

8.5

Good

How convincing your debate is

8.5

Pretty convincing

Very convincing

Convincing

Temperament

Excellent

Total

44/50

45.5/50

42.2

**********************************************************

Join with us Congratulating MANSHAA for winning the first round for Udit Narayan Team

Congratulations to DB for being the runner up👏👏

So those who didnt win this round, not to worry you still have 5 more rounds to go 😳

To check out the scoreboard go here:

https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=617953

Get Ready for the third round everyone,

The contestants are:

saan1997 for Anu Malik

coolprince143 for Alisha Chinoy

angelforu for Udit Narayan

siddh_v for Javed Akhtar

Good Luck and all the best! 👏

Regards,
II Dev Team