Aliya questioning zain's honesty NOT justified?

Yuvika_15 thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Gulaal-e-Jung Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
hey guys
did anyone else find aliya questioning zain's sachai and imaandaari a bit wrong... I mean she herself has been in a situation where she had to lie to zain and hide things just to save someone (fahad's track) so shouldn't she know better that if someone is hiding something and lying about it there must be a reason to it...
the way she was sarcastically saying "kya kaha tumne, sache ho...imaandaar ho... tum?" her tone was one of disbelief that him calling himself an honest and imaandaar person is totally wrong... and if that's the case then the exact same things can be said about aliya too...becos she wasn't completely honest with zain during the initial stages of the "fahad - don track" either so it doesn't make her any better
I know u all will say that In tht scene aliya didn't know abt ayat...but becos she herself has experienced a situation where she had to hide things she should understand that if zain is hiding something there must be a reason behind it, jus like there was a reason behind her hiding fahad's reality during that track.
when zain was questioning fahad about how could he mortgage Barkat Royale property, aliya was the first to jump in his defence and say he's already ashamed u don't need to pick on this matter and make things worse. but now with ayat she's gone ahead and slapped her...why is it that when zain raises questions on his brother's actions or hides things his honesty is questioned but when aliya does the exact same, hide things and slap ayat, its all ok...? isn't that double standards... ayat's escort incident was something which happened without her knowing, while fahad knew exactly what he was doing...so if aliya can forgive a mistake tht a person did knowingly, why cant she forgive a mistake ayat made unknowingly??
Edited by Yuvika_15 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.7k

Users

18

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
even i felt the same watching that scene...
i wanted aaliya to realize and be proud ki zain ne sach kaha tha...uske ek ladki ko bachaya hain...
it doesn't matter if she dint knew ...it was ayat...saving a girl from such a dangerous mess is lovely thing itself...but she kind of thought kaun hain woh ladki...zain jhooth kyun bol raha hain uske liye...when zain had cleared ki woh sharif khandan ki hain...and police told that zain saved her...
was expecting something else from aaliya...i know she was worried about zain security...but still...i just can't stop myself from saying that aaliya did disappointed me in that particular scene...
Edited by EtherealRati - 11 years ago
Yuvika_15 thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Gulaal-e-Jung Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: EtherealRati

even i felt the same watchjing that scene...
i wanted aaliya to realize and be proud ki zain ne sach kaha tha...uske ek ladki ko bachaya hain...
it doesn't matter if she dint knew ...it was ayat...saving a girl from such a dangerous mess is lovely thing itself...but she kind of thought kaun hain woh ladki...zain jhooth kyun bol raha hain uske liye...when zain had cleared ki woh sharif khandan ki hain...

exactly, I cant help but feel aliya maintains a level of hypocrisy at times... if she does something its k..but if zain does it...allah tauba its so wrong... like even when fahad read the Quran and decided to tell his family the truth, aliya had taunted zain for not following the "sach ka raasta" becos he was simply hiding things from her...but she did the exact same thing (hide fahad's reality from zain) so she can't accuse zain of being dishonest and taunt him for it when she's done the exact same thing.
priya185 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
she found out truth after she said that so after she will regret it for sure
escort service in my opinion is much worse than giving barkhat royale papers as its a matter of reputation which aliya finds to be of more worth than money
Edited by -Priya- - 11 years ago
xox.iloveyou thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
I understand where you're coming from but its a initial reaction. I think its justified to say that if you find out your husband lied to you (even tho you've done it yourself) aaliya's reaction would be one's first reaction.
As far as the slapping situation goes, again, its your initial reaction and the fact that your younger sister did such a thing your first reaction would be to slap her and lash out at her rather than calmly listening to the whole situation
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Yuvika_15

exactly, I cant help but feel aliya maintains a level of hypocrisy at times... if she does something its k..but if zain does it...allah tauba its so wrong... like even when fahad read the Quran and decided to tell his family the truth, aliya had taunted zain for not following the "sach ka raasta" becos he was simply hiding things from her...but she did the exact same thing (hide fahad's reality from zain) so she can't accuse zain of being dishonest and taunt him for it when she's done the exact same thing.

sometimes we just dont realize what we are saying...i was shocked that aaliya dint felt even a bit for the girl in question...dint had a smile on her face knowing zain saved her...
because all she was thinking was zain , his security , his not telling her the girl name...his risking his life for the girl...
she kind of forgot everything which happened at fahad's time...how badly she wanted to save him out...he actually kept his dad life there at that don house...but aaliya was with him...and today without even kowing the truth...she reacted this way...
but then its human...that's all sudden reactioon...it was a big big shock to her listening ayat name...there...involved in such a case...and then thinking that zain life is in danger because of her own sister...her anger just grew more...
but the line which she spoke in precap...kya soach rahi hain woh ????...can her sis do something like that...atleast question her first...
zain waiise itna immature hain but when he was in aaliya place in fahad situation...he acted more maturely...
Rozzzy123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I think Wotever Aaliya said,was just a frustration and sudden disclosure of the truth which involved her sister and husband who didn't utter a word since so much has happened.Even Zain had shouted at Aaliya,even said more bad things when he learnt that she sold the Jewellery,but even after knowing the truth,he didn't apologize or thank Aaliya.And in this case,Aaliya is gonna say Thankyou to Zain as per spoiler.So ya I think it's not a very big deal questioning Zain abt sachchai.Well,outof everything, I loved how Aaliya slapped Aayat.Fully deserved it
TheRowdiest thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
agree ... and she knew he did it so save a girl yet she said that
ash91 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
I guess what hurt Aliya more was Zain denying that he knows Rocky.. I think thats what she was referring to when she questioned his honesty..
Coz later in the police station, when she gets to know its Ayat, she does connect all the dots.. Everything that Zain told her during the happening.. Him mentioning that the girl is from a good family etc etc...
Taniya20 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
There is no such trust/understanding from Aaliya's end till now on Zain(Like, when he is hiding something, which means he is doing something good)...So far, He never made her feel so with his actions... She considers him immature... Then how will she?? After this incident She will think the way your expecting her to be...Remember even Zain didn't trust her n think that way till he got to know the whole truth... They are taking baby steps in their relationship...


Next, Aaliya hearing her sisters name in ESCORT service girls list is FAR FAR MORE hurting than Zain getting to know that her brother is involved is betting scandal... Her Slap is totally an acceptable reaction...

Finally, we don't know how that scene takes forward, so its early to judge based on single glimpse of precap... 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".