Today's Take - Tashan - Page 5

Originally posted by: golpokobita

Loved your post, Diya, specially the red part..

I completely agree with you on the song part.. Both the song and Sanaya's acting are very powerful --- BUT not together. It sounds so odd! Why can't anyone creative team in the point this out?

About the emotional part, you are right .. Rudra's breakdown is really good and well acted, but its coming too often! I was happy when I saw there was a scene for Paro only to show her pain..but it was too short.

Thakurain's story is getting interesting day by day..

Originally posted by: PhoenixRising

Great take Diya! 👏

I was banging my head the entry time today because I have seen way too much of Rudra breakdown. It's like CVS is turning him into a total Devdas I wouldn't complain regarding his emotions because I know he's still a child deep down inside lagging for some love & affection but I was so irritated like enough already!

I agree with you I would love to see Thakurain & Paro in flashbacks.

Originally posted by: Malini1

Lovely take as usual. Thanks.
Somehow i felt that the episode was hushed up in the second half and a bit disconnected, it started well though. I too feel that they need to tone down Rudra's breakdown scenes, Paro's was more impactful.
Sadiya was good today, could feel thakurain's pain. But somehow the feeling that she may have left her family for love is not quite sitting with me, i hope there is more to it that i can empathise with her.
As usual PaRud were beautiful today. Is it me just me, i felt Rudra was behaving like a lost, confused and stubborn boy, not knowing what to to do.

Originally posted by: rithureuben

Agree about the singer's voice for Paro. Doesn't suit her at all.

And Rudra's meltdowns need to stop too. I know he has a tortured past, but they have to show him dealing with his pain slowly. It will show his emotional strength in a better light.

Originally posted by: ddFan2012

Another fantastic take Diya,

I will summarize two scenes in these two lines

Ek hiron ki titli sajj gayi Paro ke kangan pe

Ek gulaabi sehmi sehmi si titli sawar gayi Rudra ke aangan mein

Already too many comments on Rudra breakdown and stuff so wont add to that.

Now coming to Thakur and Mala. AFter seeing Thaukur crease his brows over his wifey's pain, most of us felt he love hers and she him. But I am not buying that.

Well Mala is the clean slate that a blood-tainted Thakur uses to write down his death sentences on. She is the white face of a very black (though handsome) Thakur. Its deception. He love his villagers more than Mala. He cant lose them. No Mala no villagers worship him.

A man who is involved in human trafficking and throwing girls to crocs ain't a man in love. Yes she is is obsession like he would place a high priced piece d'art in his home. He has hidden every dirty deed of his from her. IF they are both in love, it does not matter then. Its one sided just from Mala's side.

Being a very good looking man viewers find it hard to digest that he can be that ugly. But he is. The crime is not a personal family vendetta kind of. This is gun-smuggling, human trafficking of young girls across the border.

Wonder why Mala told Thakur she will tell him about it later. Is Rudra his son? An affair before marriage to Dilsher? OMG...that would be too much for Rudra to accept. And a bit too filmy...

Sanaya just looked stunning in pink. The hues of the color pink and orange (a previous dupatta) add a beautiful glow to her skin.

Originally posted by: pink.lotus

sorry i dint read all the comments, but i saw two episodes together, and this was a perfect one for me. I think i need to watch the whole story together for greater impact... the way they break for the day (each episode ending part) is not working for me.

so one day, kaka went to see mom, mom gave him a bangle for paro, rudy saw mom's eyes in the checkpost and is totally upset. then he buys red bangles to terrorize her and comes home, makes her wear them.. she is heartbroken to be wearing red bangles from her husband's killer, cannot sleep even if she wants to.. sings a song up on the terrace, in solitude and tears. the jallad hears it and comes out, shouts at her, and in the loneliness of his bedroom, remembers his mom singing it, and breaks down.

I dont think parvati's emotions were under represented, i dont think rudra's emotions were over represented. I only wish that they would not oversell the "chemistry" in scenes that imply more than should be implied, even though these two actors in an eyelock is a treat to watch.

the song sounds like it was sung for an open stage or temple.. the use of the song in a bedroom setting, both the first time in the hospital and then today in the haveli, jarred wildly, like everyone noticed. the same song can be sung in an indoor voice, right? imho, i think the older woman's lip syncing suited the song better. it was almost believable that she sang that song.