Dumbest Alexander - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

1.3k

Users

5

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: sashashyam

My dear, this is how "twists" are manufactured. There is usually no logic to them.

Now what I want to know is the reason for this mega-twist. I have noted the only one that occurred to me on another thread: that it is to make Alexander's gesture of sparing Porus after the battle and rewarding him seem, not like stand alone generosity, but only a payback for Porus' past clemency towards Alexander.

Shyamala Aunty


In folkstories Alexander comes to porus court disguised as Greek rajdoot😛
siyarati thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#22
I don't think Alex was dumb. In fact he was quite intelligent.
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#23
Regarding @bold, I wrote on page 1 above:

He looks splendid in that golden coronet; I used to wonder why he had stopped wearing it. Every inch an emperor. Erect, unafraid, and wonderful to behold.

But not to worry, I have no copyright on descriptions of Alexander's superb stance and his cool, proud looks, so you can praise him to your heart's content!😉

As for the rest of your post, and all your fully justified carping, there is no answer to any of it. Especially as regards the incongruity of Alexander talking to his mother about her fears in front of an outsider whom, as you rightly point out, he does not trust at all, witness his caustic comment about Chanakya's explanation for his blowing up the bridge.

I too am beyond fed up with the kata hua sar syndrome. 😡 It now seems to be vying with Zeus ka beta, aaj ka khuda, with Puru koyi kaam adhura nahin chodta as a now distant second.😆

Finally, I am not at all sure that Alexander does not have a weapon on him. I am pretty sure he has something, exactly as in Bactria, and I would not be surprised if he whipped it out and halted Puru's sword at the end of its swing. And where are Hephaestion and Cleitus?

As of now, it seems to me to be a toss up between

a) Puru halting his sword at the very last and then making a speech on the one hand, and on the other hand,

b) Alexander stopping the sword with his own weapon and then fighting his way out of the hall with Hephaestion and Cleitus for support .

Let us see what happens tonight. I think option one is more likely, mainly because of the extra coat of gilt it will add to Puru's escutcheon.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: inlieu

Aunty, I think it was too much to expect the CVs to end this show a few weeks ago. I fear even more weird tracks are coming up! Much as I like watching the Alexander-Chanakya scenes for the potential mental games being played, I wish they could be used or shown to better effect in terms of upcoming tracks. A game of intrigue is what I was looking for but well, who am I to expect such things? 😕

Also, since Alexander doesn't seem to trust Chanakya at all, it's very annoying to see his stance of "A lion does not extend an offer of friendship to the other animals in the jungle" change to "let's go meet this king in Paurav Rashtra who wants this truce". Isn't he going to do any research before making this trip?

Chanakya knew how to push his buttons, but still. Alexander is known for sticking to his word/plan so why would he change his mind so soon, that too because of and in front of an outsider? Surely not just for his mother? He "appears" to be laying his cards on the table where this aalem is concerned, except this is no Aristotle. One more thing that I found jarring - Alexander's way of pronouncing "Chanakya" - too accurate and Indianized when he couldn't even say Ruksana!

Alexander without weapons? That seems so difficult for me to accept! Even in the jashn in Bactria, he seemed to have hidden that dagger in his clothing, which no one saw of course! 😆 The promo's definitely going to increase viewers' curiosity.

I wonder whether this will indeed be a repeat of the Faras track where Puru gives some lectures about bravery or whatever and lets Alexander go. Since Kanishk is in jail, I don't expect him to play any part in the upcoming events. The presence of other kings might mean something, though. Are they all going to do like Ambhiraj and choose to side with Alexander, leaving Puru eventually outnumbered?

I wish Alexander would stop promising the women in his life to offer a king's kata hua sar. Who's he going to get this time? Bamni, since in the absence of Kanishk he is the "king" and Puru doesn't seem to have been crowned yet? No wonder the other kings were confused because the ruler in Paurav Rashtra seems to be changing very frequently. Could this contribute to their lack of faith in the ruling family of PR and hedge their bets on siding with Alexander?

Can I say how royal Alexander still looks standing in that big hall, pure white amongst all the blue, his stature and aura not affected in the least by his being outnumbered?

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#24
That assessment, Siya, will depend on how he gets out of this latest scrape.

It was, a priori, incomprehensibly foolish of him to go into enemy territory with no back up but Hephaestion and Cleitus and a few soldiers, just because Chanakya made his mother nervous. Nor can I understand Alexander, who sleeps with his sword next to his bed, going to Paurav Rashtra unarmed. It is simply not believable!

In fact, I am almost sure he has a hidden weapon, as he had in Bactria. If this is so, we have to see what use he makes of it.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: siyarati

I don't think Alex was dumb. In fact he was quite intelligent.

luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: sashashyam

That assessment, Siya, will depend on how he gets out of this latest scrape.

It was, a priori, incomprehensibly foolish of him to go into enemy territory with no back up but Hephaestion and Cleitus and a few soldiers, just because Chanakya made his mother nervous. Nor can I understand Alexander, who sleeps with his sword next to his bed, going to Paurav Rashtra unarmed. It is simply not believable!

In fact, I am almost sure he has a hidden weapon, as he had in Bactria. If this is so, we have to see what use he makes of it.

Shyamala Aunty

Ship
Ship mein bande chupa ke le ayea Alexander...nnothing such will happen ...it will be Puru stopping his sword of course...
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#26
Well, soldiers hidden in the ship would hardly help him when he is alone in the hall with no weapons. I meant weapons on his body, as in Bactria.

This said, have you seen my post on prepage, with the two options? I prefer the first, that of Puru halting his sword and then making his standard issue bhashan, though I still wonder where Hephaestion and Cleitus are.

It would have been much more interesting if they had all three fought their way out. A sort of variation on the elephant story.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: luckySnow

Ship

Ship mein bande chupa ke le ayea Alexander...nnothing such will happen ...it will be Puru stopping his sword of course...

Edited by sashashyam - 7 years ago
luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Well, soldiers hidden in the ship would hardly help him when he is alone in the hall with no weapons. I meant weapons on his body, as in Bactria.

This said, have you seen my post on prepage, with the two options? I prefer the first, that of Puru halting his sword and then making his standard issue bhashan, though I still wonder where Hephaestion and Cleitus are.

It would have been much more interesting if they had all three fought their way out. A sort of variation on the elephant story.

Shyamala Aunty


There is huge difference between Alexander running and porus running.Puru is nobody but a struggler who isn't even a king...Alexander is the emperor or fvthe world...he can't run...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".