Page
of
1Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 25
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 18 Aug 2025 EDT
GAADI CHOOTH GAYI 18.8
BALH Naya Season EDT Week #10: Aug 18 - Aug 22
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai - 19 Aug 2025 EDT
Memory Loss?
Shradhanjali to Mr Anshuman Raizada
Disaster Monday: War 2 falls 75% to Rs. 6 cr, shows cancelled
Back to the pavilion when??
DAHII HANDI 19.8
KJO To Return In 2026 With Classic Hindi Cinema
Tiger or Kabir or Pathan. Which male spy you liked the most?
Param Sundari ..Yay or Nay ?
Still, my favourites among Rohit's Alexander moments are the one that showcased his ability to tackle despair and regret, after his blow up with Philip in the open court, as he is going to his mother's rooms, and his ability to convey nuances, as recently, at Halicarnassus, when the whole crowd is cheering Sikandar!! Sikandar!!!, and Queen Ada is smiling at him with tender delight in her eyes.
Alexander looks around as he soaks in the applause, his tawny green eyes light up, but he neither smiles openly nor does he given any other overt sign of delight. He does not want to seem overly excited at the new title conferred on him; it is his right after all! Still, deep inside him is the little boy who seeks praise, and that is the aspect of his psyche that peeps out at that moment. It was a wonderful piece of emoting by Rohit, using his eyes alone.
Before his Alexander, I had seen Rohit only in a small part in a crime series called Arjun, and I was taken aback by this new avatar. So I wrote elsewhere in this forum:
The choice of this boy is a remarkable casting coup, and it is one of the very few clever things the producers have done.
Alexander the Great was a superstar not only of his time but down the millennia. Neither of the other two military genuises of the last 3 millennia, Julius Caesar and Napoleon, came close to Alexander in sheer charisma and lasting fame. I wanted to name my son after him, but had to compromise by settling on Sasha - the Russian dimunitive for Alexander- as his pet name.
To revert, Rohit has the presence which is vital for a successful Alexander. Now presence is either there or not there, it cannot be taught or acquired. His Alexander looks every inch a very young world conqueror: the insouciance of youth, the effortless dominance, the unshakeable confidence, the innate shrewdness, the subtle grasp of human psychology. Plus he is very handsome - which too Alexander was, judging from the statues and busts - and he has the sleek grace of a panther when he moves.
I have not yet seen a single scene where Rohit failed to convey what was intended. The very best sequence, which drew him into hitherto uncharted territory, was after the blow up with Philip in the open court, which leaves Alexander crushed and deeply distressed at his naivete in trusting such a man. His face, as he walks to his mother's rooms. was a study in conflicting emotions, and he pulled it off to perfection. Again, when he was caressing the hair of the comatose Philip, the tenderness in his face was remarkable.
+++++++++++
The 5:46 minutes of Alexander (which is par for the course for him, for as I noted in my last thread, he gets only about 20% of the telecast time, less that is given to Puru's wavy locks and slo mo strides) that rounded off the episode (the one of Alexander's coronation) were manna from Heaven!
As those who read my post A hatchet job on Alexander? , would remember, I was afraid that with the baby killing scene, the demonization of Porus' antagonist had begun. It now seems that I was wrong, at least for now.
Alexander's revulsion at Olympias having used black magic to fuddle Arridaeus's brains was instant and strong, and he had made this quite plain to his mother in a manner that I had then felt was too harsh. It did not matter then to Alexander that Arridaeus had made an attempt on his life; he would not stoop to such underhand methods.
Innate nobility
The Friday closing segment made it clear that this display of an innate nobility was no flash in the pan. It is an integral part of Alexander's mental make up. He still feels guilty about what had been done to Arridaeus. Pehle hi Arridaeus ki zindagi barbad ho chuki, jiski wajah main hoon. Which other king would make such a confession?
His sharp warning that there should not, in the future, be even a kharonch (scratch) on Arridaeus, could not have been more blunt: Sab gaur se sunein...Agar kisi ne bhi...- and his eyes rake the assemblage, lingering just an instant longer on Olympias aur kisi ka matlab kisi ne bhi, mere hukum ki nafarmani ki, to use mere sile (?) ka saamna karna padega.
At one stroke, he makes it abundantly clear who is master, and Olympias stands warned against attempts at backseat driving. More to the point, all those present too realise that this young man is no pushover, that he can neither be manipulated nor conned into doing anything against his will, and that he will brook no flouting of his orders.
And yet all this is done with a silken deftness that would have made a seasoned diplomat proud. Alexander does not give any indication that he realises it was his mother who had ordered Arridaeus killed, and he sweeps the whole issue aside with a self-assured skill that exposes no faultlines that outsiders could exploit.
The high priestess of the Delphic Oracle seems disturbed when the sunlight fades after Alexander announces his intention to conquer Bharat, but not he, now raring to teach rebellious Thebes and Athens the lesson of their lives. As the episode ends on a close up shot of Alexander, his golden hair slicked back and confined by his coronet, the sharp planes of his face making it look narrower than usual, the eyes glowing at the prospect of the battles ahead, he looks for all the world like a noble bird of prey, a king eagle about to take flight.
The casting director should get a solid round of applause, for he or she has found the perfect Alexander in Rohit Purohit.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I am afraid this has become rather a long post, but I am sure you will not mind it!
Shyamala Cowsik
PS: The gap in the post is a software glitch. I can't get rid of it.
Originally posted by: Geniusreader
wonderful analysis shyamala aunty...
Hello Shyamala Aunty,
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this.I am not much of a writer, but love reading your posts!I agree that some of the less "flashy" scenes of Rohit are the highlights of this show and I'm definitely going to go back and watch them again so I can comment here in more detail. 😃His parting scene with Olympia is one of my favorites because it shows you what/how the core of him had developed up to that point before he embarked on his journey to become an unstoppable conqueror.I also loved the part where he sent a disguised warning across to his mother not to mess with Arrihdaeus because we saw not just his compassionate and fair side but also how Olympia's efforts helped him develop/show personality traits that may not always be in her favor!I am also looking forward to how he'll interact with Barsine once he ousts Darius (unless the makers skip this bit altogether). I wonder if he'll be attracted to her beauty and I'm curious to see him in lover mode.