When Exactly DID REva go Mad??? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.8k

Users

11

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

croziaxx thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
don't know wo shubh din kab aayega jab sug ke samne rewa ki schchai ayegi.. lagta hai iske liye mannat magni padegi... 😛 😆
Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
This is an open ended question which I stressed earlier, needs to be addressed. Writers need to tell audience what , when and how it all went wrong with Reva. The character sketches are half baked for all the actors in the show.
As per Vikram, she was always insane, that is what he discovered after marriage. This was ample enough for him to seek divorce from her on the grounds of fraud committed against him in the name of marriage.But he put up with her for so many years.. Why? Reva even got pregnant with his child.How was it possible with a woman totally insane right from the day one of marriage?
Aditya never knew earlier that his mami was suffering from some mental disorder but Amrita seems to know 😕???
Dhanuma tells Gulabia that Reva is the worst wife one can ever have but on the other hand requests Vikram not to go ahead with Sugni since that would be unjust to Reva. Also she has stated that Reva can be cured fully.
Vikram's sister has conceded that his marriage had not been a happy one...
Reva can paint nicely, knows how to arrange pooja articles and appears in OK state of mind to me at times which shows that she is not that much insane and that her disorder can be cured.
Atleast writers can tell what exactly is the name of that psychological disorder she is suffering from?
However, I emapthise with Reva's character because from my POV, in this melee she really does not have any hand consciously apart from one thing that her parents got her married in that state to Vikram if he is to be believed.
Saviosaraff thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
croziaxx don't know wo shubh din kab aayega jab sug ke samne rewa ki schchai ayegi.. lagta hai iske liye mannat magni padegi... 😛 😆
👏👏👏👏
I doubt it will ever come before Sugni and if it does it will be shown that because she lost her baby which will increase Sugni's sympathy for her. But for us viewers it will keep us wondering whether Reva was pregnant before marriage?😲😲
Saviosaraff thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
Sweet_Krishna
However, I emapthise with Reva's character because from my POV, in this melee she really does not have any hand consciously apart from one thing that her parents got her married in that state to Vikram if he is to be believed.
It wasn't her parents but Vikram's sister (Jiji) who got him married to Reva. In India it is the custom that the elders meet the girl and approve of her for the marriage, surprising Jiji did not notice her insanity (though Reva appears loud but not insane many a times) only a person living with her day in and day out would realise the extent of her insanity.
What surprises me is that Jiji could not tolerate Reva continously asking her about her baby so takes her to the hospital and tells the doc to tell Reva everything is ok, but expects Vikram to remain true to her for the rest of his life, what Jiji could not tolerate for a few hours Vikram should tolerate for the rest of his life.
Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Saviosaraff

Sweet_Krishna
However, I emapthise with Reva's character because from my POV, in this melee she really does not have any hand consciously apart from one thing that her parents got her married in that state to Vikram if he is to be believed.
It wasn't her parents but Vikram's sister (Jiji) who got him married to Reva. In India it is the custom that the elders meet the girl and approve of her for the marriage, surprising Jiji did not notice her insanity (though Reva appears loud but not insane many a times) only a person living with her day in and day out would realise the extent of her insanity.
What surprises me is that Jiji could not tolerate Reva continously asking her about her baby so takes her to the hospital and tells the doc to tell Reva everything is ok, but expects Vikram to remain true to her for the rest of his life, what Jiji could not tolerate for a few hours Vikram should tolerate for the rest of his life.

Of course from Vikram's side his jiji(his elder) was involved but who could be Reva's elders according to you? I do not think that Jiji knowingly got her brother married off to an insane woman. What Reva's condition was before marriage only her parents( if existing)/ relatives would be knowing.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Sweet_Krishna

This is an open ended question which I stressed earlier, needs to be addressed. Writers need to tell audience what , when and how it all went wrong with Reva. The character sketches are half baked for all the actors in the show.

As per Vikram, she was always insane, that is what he discovered after marriage. This was ample enough for him to seek divorce from her on the grounds of fraud committed against him in the name of marriage.But he put up with her for so many years.. Why? Reva even got pregnant with his child.How was it possible with a woman totally insane right from the day one of marriage?
Aditya never knew earlier that his mami was suffering from some mental disorder but Amrita seems to know 😕???
Dhanuma tells Gulabia that Reva is the worst wife one can ever have but on the other hand requests Vikram not to go ahead with Sugni since that would be unjust to Reva. Also she has stated that Reva can be cured fully.
Vikram's sister has conceded that his marriage had not been a happy one...
Reva can paint nicely, knows how to arrange pooja articles and appears in OK state of mind to me at times which shows that she is not that much insane and that her disorder can be cured.
Atleast writers can tell what exactly is the name of that psychological disorder she is suffering from?
However, I emapthise with Reva's character because from my POV, in this melee she really does not have any hand consciously apart from one thing that her parents got her married in that state to Vikram if he is to be believed.

I cracked up when I read this sentence. It tells me you are not very knowledgable about mental illness. To assume that because a person can paint nicely and arrange pooja articles must not be suffering is very naive on your part. People with mental illnesses can actually be very high functioning; Tim Burton suffers from bipolar disorder but look at the artist work and creativity he contributed to "A Nightmare Before Christmas" and other movies. Also the term "insane" is not used anymore and neither is the term "cured" as no mental illness is necessarily cured. It is called symptom reduction and then the actual symptoms.
Reva's mental illness - or whatever it is - does not exist in any manual...it is all made up by the writers because they have not taken the time out to find a formal diagnosis. All they have done is have Reva act strangely and pray that no-one with a psychology education watches their show.
Vinnie79 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
Thanks so much guys for your responses!!!
@ Sweet_Krishna I agree that on Reva side she must have some family member to finalize the marriage. Unless jiji picked her up from the road side lol.

@ Laila ...we may not have a psychology degree,but we can spot inconsistency in a story, I don't think the writers thought the audience had a brain.!

Ohh yes Jiji can't stand Reva for more than a few hours but expects her brother to stay with her, get abused by her, any person who hits another person with a vase on his head is abusive , mad or not, and be happy about it...! On grounds of HUMANITY?? Oh please how much more human you want the man to be, he is taking care of her in all the ways he can think off, what else you want his head on a platter?



Saviosaraff thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
Sweet_Krishna
Yes Reva's parents should be shown to explain her mental illness but our CVs are trying to project the baby angle as the coz for mental illness believing we will forget the conversations with Jiji, Amrita & Dhanuma. They are trying to make Vikram negative but the viewers find everyone else negative except Vikram.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Saviosaraff

Sweet_Krishna

Yes Reva's parents should be shown to explain her mental illness but our CVs are trying to project the baby angle as the coz for mental illness believing we will forget the conversations with Jiji, Amrita & Dhanuma. They are trying to make Vikram negative but the viewers find everyone else negative except Vikram.

Aditya Sugni fans and the new viewers are relishing in this...and the writers are trying hard to erase the TVS and story we knew and bringing a whole new show to us. That works well with an unsophisticated, passive, illiterate and, I hate to say, ignorance audience. PSH appealed to a more intelligent group of fans...and they tried to pull one over on us and it didn't work. The ratings have dropped .6...if all goes well, they could fall further next week.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".