How PSH has messed up. - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

3.6k

Users

21

Likes

182

Frequent Posters

radev24 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#21
Laila, a very interesting and thought-provoking topic indeed, because I have been wondering myself if I am watching PSH or some other show or two opposing serials mixed up in one without any logic connecting the two 😕😕 If CVs had to introduce a unique, a different track to move the story forward, why a bhoot-bangla-type, wolf-crying type of dark backdrop ? If let's say TVS does have a daughter, or somebody else's daughter, it could have been depicted like a normal occurrence rather than a spooky scary storyline.
Yes, until the point this sudden change came along, the trials, tribulations, the societal injustices, the poverty, the atrocities faced by these Bednis ... all of these vagories were moving along smoothly, convincingly along with their unpredictabilities, vulnerabilities, their struggles and conflicts. TVS characterization of a kind, caring, non-thakur-like demeanor became so endearing to fans and he started resonating and meshing with our whims and fancies !😃 But bang, as if we suddenly woke up from a bad dream when the same TVS portrayed a fearful, unsure, guilty, insecure, almost powerless kind of person. Wonder what CVs have cooking up in their minds !😕🤔👎🏼
Yes, so true when you say "Challenges should be a natural development of a storyline ... now they seem forced" , and almost same terminology can be used for TVS-Sug love as well. Unka pyar parwaan chadhna chahiye tha, na ki zabardasti and imposed. Sug is still an innocent and impressionable kind of girl and it almost seems as if those qualities of hers were "USED" by TVS for his own ends and purpose. I'm actually relieved to notice that Mai is always there like a "DHAAL" looking after her welfare like Durga Ma ! 😃
But I do notice slight improvement in SE's acting, expressions, concerns and esp in today's epi, I dont know if it's just me, but he appeared having even more confidence, better screen presence and as if holding the fort better than the way TVS always has.
All that said, since me an eternally optimistic kinda gal and incorrigible, I still have hope and still feel strongly that TVS is going to emerge as a decent good thakur much before the conclusion of the serial ! However, I just fail to understand the hold dhanuma has over him and why he's shown to be so oblivious of her dirty character.
And like Nu_adu I dont believe even for a sec that there will be a Sardhakai of Sug by TVS, no way jose!
Great points and POVs and ideas by Vinnie, RF and everyone else too! 😆
Guess we have no choice but to see which way the wind blows (oonth kis karwat baidhta hai ! 😕)
P.S. BTW your other thread re TVS weight gain, I made a mention of it in some other thread esp because I have been an old fan of his as a slanky and of course much younger hunk. Years do add some weight but not if VB has been a regular cricket playing actor and plus the fact that actors in their chosen profession do make sure to maintain their appearance, weight, looks, etc etc (look at Big B at his age !! Somebody ought to remind his slender pretty actress wife ... to do something about it ! 😉)
Edited by radev24 - 13 years ago
kamala2012 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: suresh555



BAD idea, but I have learnt not to trust most Indian serials to continue to stay in focus

If they are going with the Sardhakai then what's with all this initial track about Sugni's dream of living with dignity and erase the Bedni torture parampara? It defeats the purpose of this show.

They might as well change the title to

Phir Subha Kabhi Nahin Hogi



Don't know whether this information is correct or not. But i don't think there is any reason to feel sad. So what if Vikram does Sugni's sar dakai? That means the marriage didn't happen. How did the marriage stop? who stopped it? Why did Sugni, who hates the idea of a sar dakai, agree to it? Why Vikram who also hates it equally does sar dakai to Sugni? Is he trying to protect her? If Sugni has agreed to sar dakai, that means she is very angry or very disappointed with Vikram. How is he going to regain her trust? Why sardakai means there is no subah? He can still marry her. Sar dakai is just a ritual, not a law. Sugni can always remove the mangalsutra and say she refuses to accept this relation.

I think the story still has lots of potential. We should not rush. We should sit back and watch what the CVs are showing.
Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Gewels

I actually think u have made my point. I am not talking about the various jodis, people r polarised enough about that! On this thread alone there r various options given on how people want the show to proceed-or how the show should have gone. There are differing views-which of course is normal. This constant barrage of conflicting views is part and parcel of forum life but writers have to be able to see through it in order to get their own story out, because letting us as fans have too much influence on the story is a ticket to nowhere for the show. We'll just all get confused and quit watching!

Actually, I didn't answer your question or lend support to your view that the fans should NOT be heard, so I would appreciate if you did not twist my post to suit your point because you might be a supporter of Aditya and Sugni. Actually these shows ARE about jodis. We are not just watching a show about Bednis but a romance as well and it does matter who is romancing the lead especially when TVS and Sugni have the better chemistry. The bulk of the people here want TVS-Sugni, so the polarization is pretty limited. There is no much conflict here; we are all fans of the show and simply have different viewpoints. For us, as long as TVS and Sugni are together, we are open to many things - some more than others. I think the writers know that and if they don't then that is disappointing.
Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: radev24

Laila, a very interesting and thought-provoking topic indeed, because I have been wondering myself if I am watching PSH or some other show or two opposing serials mixed up in one without any logic connecting the two 😕😕 If CVs had to introduce a unique, a different track to move the story forward, why a bhoot-bangla-type, wolf-crying type of dark backdrop ? If let's say TVS does have a daughter, or somebody else's daughter, it could have been depicted like a normal occurrence rather than a spooky scary storyline.
Yes, until the point this sudden change came along, the trials, tribulations, the societal injustices, the poverty, the atrocities faced by these Bednis ... all of these vagories were moving along smoothly, convincingly along with their unpredictabilities, vulnerabilities, their struggles and conflicts. TVS characterization of a kind, caring, non-thakur-like demeanor became so endearing to fans and he started resonating and meshing with our whims and fancies !😃 But bang, as if we suddenly woke up from a bad dream when the same TVS portrayed a fearful, unsure, guilty, insecure, almost powerless kind of person. Wonder what CVs have cooking up in their minds !😕🤔👎🏼
Yes, so true when you say "Challenges should be a natural development of a storyline ... now they seem forced" , and almost same terminology can be used for TVS-Sug love as well. Unka pyar parwaan chadhna chahiye tha, na ki zabardasti and imposed. Sug is still an innocent and impressionable kind of girl and it almost seems as if those qualities of hers were "USED" by TVS for his own ends and purpose. I'm actually relieved to notice that Mai is always there like a "DHAAL" looking after her welfare like Durga Ma ! 😃
But I do notice slight improvement in SE's acting, expressions, concerns and esp in today's epi, I dont know if it's just me, but he appeared having even more confidence, better screen presence and as if holding the fort better than the way TVS always has.
All that said, since me an eternally optimistic kinda gal and incorrigible, I still have hope and still feel strongly that TVS is going to emerge as a decent good thakur much before the conclusion of the serial ! However, I just fail to understand the hold dhanuma has over him and why he's shown to be so oblivious of her dirty character.
And like Nu_adu I dont believe even for a sec that there will be a Sardhakai of Sug by TVS, no way jose!
Great points and POVs and ideas by Vinnie, RF and everyone else too! 😆
Guess we have no choice but to see which way the wind blows (oonth kis karwat baidhta hai ! 😕)
P.S. BTW your other thread re TVS weight gain, I made a mention of it in some other thread esp because I have been an old fan of his as a slanky and of course much younger hunk. Years do add some weight but not if VB has been a regular cricket playing actor and plus the fact that actors in their chosen profession do make sure to maintain their appearance, weight, looks, etc etc (look at Big B at his age !! Somebody ought to remind his slender pretty actress wife ... to do something about it ! 😉)

Thank you for your response. I think you said it very well...the fact that TVS has secrets need not come out as a thriller or ghost story. It's even more odd if she's alone in a house. I hope she has other people taking care of her - a young child by herself alone in a house? I think, because of this "Fear Files" opening to high ratings, all this is being done to increase TRP ratings in India. Mom is suspicious because she was probably deceived herself. I hope the CVs shed some light here to validate these assumptions. Did TJS also promise her many things, say he loved her etc?
Today TVS showed his sharpness again today when Sugni questioned him. I also hope this raaz is one that's well worth it. May be this raaz is our TVS' weak spot. Romancefan proposed a good idea in another thread - perhaps TVS was attracted to Sugni because he knew about the child and that an illegitimate child would be stigmatized...perhaps he felt compassion for Sugni...perhaps she'd be a good choice for a mother OR perhaps he will have her pose as a mother for this child. We can only speculate. Somehow, whatever their plans, I hope they keep with the storyline - so many shows lose focus after three months.
Yes, VB as TVS really needs to shed a few pounds and I say this in the nicest way possible because he is pretty nice looking and this weight gain is not working to his advantage. I want to see TVS and not his double chin.
Laila2009 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: media_man7

ATTENTION !!!!!!!!!!!!


laila... i just had a word with the ppl involved in the makin of the show... yes the show has changed its Path... Guess with one line what i will say is... Vikram Thakur Does Sugnis Sardhakai... (not Shaadi)

So i hope the SHow gets interesting for u now

Now why do I have a tough time believing you here? 😕😉
romancefan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26
As for Jwala Singh Thakur, i don't think CVs are side-lining him. He's an important figure in the show and time will come when the spot light is shone on him again. Some actors do double duty. They take on 2 roles in 2 different serials at the same time. So maybe the actor is currently busy with other projects. Read in IF news that Jyoti Gauba(wife of TJS) is also playing another role in a Sony drama, and Priyanka Panchal(Amrita) too is busy with 2 shows.
swathitv thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27
i feel the story is about struggle of bedini , but now it is all about mystery with a kid i understand it sounds intersting and the kid is tvs's kid but why is he hiding it ??? it sounds good suspense but the ultimate life of story sugni's struggle is somewer missing!!!
romancefan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: swathitv

i feel the story is about struggle of bedini , but now it is all about mystery with a kid i understand it sounds intersting and the kid is tvs's kid but why is he hiding it ??? it sounds good suspense but the ultimate life of story sugni's struggle is somewer missing!!!

Sugni's struggle hasn't really begun. The main story is yet to come. The best is yet to come. Be patient and continue to watch the show. Sure you'll enjoy it!
romancefan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: pritirays


Hey I totally agree with what you have written in the quoted post! Till the unexpected love confession, I was in love with the show! But somehow the love confession spoiled it for me and I left watching the show! 😆 I was a Vikram-Sugni fan, but dunno why their love confession unhooked me from the show! 🤣

Most of us Sugvi fans were floored by the love confession. The trps even went up to 2.5 which was a real achievement. Why didn't you enjoy it? Don't you like romance?
survi035 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30
how do you know that the CVs are not going to go with Adi and Sugni's jodi. Anything can happen and as far as i know, Aditiya is the male lead of the show.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".