Priyanka Eliminating Raj??? - Page 2

Originally posted by: April2007

Does anybody know the rules of the show. Do parents have to agree to the wedding for wedding to take place.?

Originally posted by: axeion

Alrite, just happened to read ur post, and I don't agree with even single word of urs. I am sorry to tell u, but I don't find anything wrong in discussing it with others. The only rule set is that she has to make the whole decision herself, but there is nothing like she can not check out with the other girls About their opinions. She is asking the girls what they feel abt each of the guys present there. and not whom they want to eliminate. So that pretty much makes sense, as she is just trying to collect everyone's opinion. She is not asking them to directly tell which guy.
As I just posted in another topic :
I don't think there is anything wrong in talking about it, only thing she has to keep in mind is that she takes the final decision all by herself. And there was an episode teaser, where she confesses that she would make a note of everyone's views of everyone else. So I guess it's more like a rating system, where u j ust rate everything and then eliminate the least popular thing. And I don't see why she should not do it. it's just a simple tally marks system.
It's just how we look at things, like her sister had once mentioned in the chai meeting, looking at two sides of the coin. She might think it's a head, but it can be tails for the other person. In her POV. one of the guys might not be compatible with the girls, but for some girls that guy might be the best. Like if we take Pooja and Hitesh, or even Rumpa and Gaurav. Both Pooja and Rumpa are serious abt these guys(atleast Rumpa, if not Pooja), but again both of them would not mind these guys going out as they might look at other options too. So it's like analyzing if there is an alternative to everyone's first preference and would eliminating someone really affect someone or not.
It's always good make knowledge decision than hasty decisions, as they say No knowledge is better than Half-knowledge. But since she already knows a lil bit, she has half-knowledge. So why not convert it to full knowledge for better decision-making.
This is my opinion, and I won't mind if she even eliminates Raj. As such Raj doesn't have a real good chance with many girls. Most of them already know that he is really not keen on knowing anyone else.
And yes she can also eliminate Raj, if she has to be correct and just to everyone else. Just not eliminating Raj bcoz she herself wants to stick on the show, would be going against the actual purpose of coming on to the show. They are here to find a life-partner not win some reality show. So being fair to everyone by knowing their opinion does actually make sense. And she doesn't need to ask a guy to stay on the show, to be able to survive herself, if she is not faking. If she is being her true self, then I don't find anything wrong with eliminating Raj either.

nop..she's not gonna eliminate Raj!!!

its just illusion of yours!!

I agree with midnight shade that Priyanka was not allowed to discuss the elimination with anyone. Infact when she was doing so the narrator even mentioned the same that she's going against the rules ( not directly but it was along the same line). Its not just her I think majority of them suck at following rules/instructions. I don't think she'll eliminate Raj b/c if she does so then it'll make her look bad and it'll be selfish of her for not giving him the opportunity to do what his dad asked him to do, anyway there are other girls besides Priyanka that would love to know Raj. I think it'll be Vivek going out this week.

Originally posted by: strongirl

i rly dont understand wats going on here.priyanka kuch bhi karti hain aap logon ko galat hin lagta hain.even if she talks wid sum1 its wrong even if she asks others opinion its wrong then wat u all expect frm her.if she takes decision herself then u will say she is mean and rude if she gives chance for others to express their opinon even its wrong.agar woh saans leti hain shayad woh bhi app logon ko galat lagega.is se pata chel raha hain kisko sense nahi hain.