Mansi is raped!!! - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

19.2k

Users

28

Likes

296

Frequent Posters

naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#61
@serena297 - I am so sorry for your mother's and as her daughter, your personal experience with rape. You know how painful a subject this is.
Actually some of the writers of the comments you disdain, however, are also victims of rape and/or abuse, and these people, for the same reasons, feel the opposite.

The reason for the difference i believe, is knowing what Ekta has done so many times with her shows and with this very subject. Her message has NEVER been the strength of the woman to overcome this event. As someone mentioned the most descriptive word, she has exploited this very real and terrible problem for the purpose of raising TRP's in her shows...basically, that means, for money and for her own dramatic ambitions. If this is not morally corrupt I don't know what is.

Silence is also wrong, but showing the rapist as just another thing that boys do and no big deal is what is the wrong message. So far this is all that Ekta has ever shown and why the outrage.

Obviously you yourself will not want this message to be the one given. If Ekta would ever change her strategy and do what you are hoping for ...that will be a whole new thing. We can always hope she will wake up...it would be a very remarkable turn around for her. Anything is possible i guess, but so far it's not looking good and i am not holding out any hope for that. I would like to be wrong.

I actually have the feeling in the end - in the flashbacks - we will see that Mansi wasn't raped. But..this makes the exploitation of this kind of behavior for business and drama every bit as bad.

Again, i am sorry for your mother's trauma, and hope she has been healed and continues to be strong. G-d bless you too dear.
onirfans thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#62


Dear, I really feel for you but if you've ever watched EKTA kapoor stories then you'll know that she uses 'rape' to gain popularity of her shows. Nowhere, especially not in plain sight, is there a message.


here i am not agree with u that her every serial rape did not give a social massage...
in kSBKBT mein tulsi supported her daughter in law and for her happiness killed own son...
thats rerely shown that saas choseed bahu not son...this was also a social message to her lady that how she should behave when for her own son her bahu suffered...


in kukum also supported and gave strength to her daughter ...

ya i actually in her every serial lead fight for victim , she never show that herself a victim fight for her reputation... specially in pr its a second time ...first time girls keep quit and boys win her...but i hope this time they will be show a horrible punishment for raunak

muaaz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: onirfans



Dear, I really feel for you but if you've ever watched EKTA kapoor stories then you'll know that she uses 'rape' to gain popularity of her shows. Nowhere, especially not in plain sight, is there a message.


here i am not agree with u that her every serial rape did not give a social massage...

in kSBKBT mein tulsi supported her daughter in law and for her happiness killed own son...
thats rerely shown that saas choseed bahu not son...this was also a social message to her lady that how she should behave when for her own son her bahu suffered...


in kukum also supported and gave strength to her daughter ...

ya i actually in her every serial lead fight for victim , she never show that herself a victim fight for her reputation... specially in pr its a second time ...first time girls keep quit and boys win her...but i hope this time they will be show a horrible punishment for raunak


Not only KSBKBT tulsi support her Bahu and kill Ansh , In kahaani parvati also fight case agaist her grandson pranay who rape mathali and she won the case and sent pranay jail for 7 years and also in kasuti mukti rapist shared get punishment and sent to jail , mostly ekta serial rapist get punished.So i hope they show it again and Ankita fight for mansi and ronaq get punished 😡


ambolove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: naava

@serena297 - I am so sorry for your mother's and as her daughter, your personal experience with rape. You know how painful a subject this is.

Actually some of the writers of the comments you disdain, however, are also victims of rape and/or abuse, and these people, for the same reasons, feel the opposite.

The reason for the difference i believe, is knowing what Ekta has done so many times with her shows and with this very subject. Her message has NEVER been the strength of the woman to overcome this event. As someone mentioned the most descriptive word, she has exploited this very real and terrible problem for the purpose of raising TRP's in her shows...basically, that means, for money and for her own dramatic ambitions. If this is not morally corrupt I don't know what is.

Silence is also wrong, but showing the rapist as just another thing that boys do and no big deal is what is the wrong message. So far this is all that Ekta has ever shown and why the outrage.

Obviously you yourself will not want this message to be the one given. If Ekta would ever change her strategy and do what you are hoping for ...that will be a whole new thing. We can always hope she will wake up...it would be a very remarkable turn around for her. Anything is possible i guess, but so far it's not looking good and i am not holding out any hope for that. I would like to be wrong.

I actually have the feeling in the end - in the flashbacks - we will see that Mansi wasn't raped. But..this makes the exploitation of this kind of behavior for business and drama every bit as bad.

Again, i am sorry for your mother's trauma, and hope she has been healed and continues to be strong. G-d bless you too dear.



I agree with you. There was a lack of flashbacks during the incident, not even a flashback of a struggle.
I think he managed to knock her unconscious, which explains the lack of screaming when he told her what he had done.
Think what will happen is, Mansi will tell Ankita and Ankita will blame Raunak for everything, maybe even trying to kill him. He'll just smirk and say tell Mansi to have a medical examination. Which she'll do. The examination will be proof that she wasn't raped and then obviously this will cause problems for mansi and Ankita's life, with the entire karmakar family including Naren going against ankita.

The only way Ankita will get Naren back into her life will be to find Ahana and get rid of his instability.
Edited by ambolove - 11 years ago
onirfans thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#65


Not only KSBKBT tulsi support her Bahu and kill Ansh , In kahaani parvati also fight case agaist her grandson pranay who rape mathali and she won the case and sent pranay jail for 7 years and also in kasuti mukti rapist shared get punishment and sent to jail , mostly ekta serial rapist get punished.So i hope they show it again and Ankita fight for mansi and ronaq get punished 😡



yes that was happened but the fact is only lead fight for justice and other family go against her/his and finally after so much struggle they understand and support ...

but i want to see the victim herself fight for her own justice with lawfull way ... i want to see the rapist falls and cry for life on the foot of victim...and also some trick for girls who suffered like mansi
Sona_Chandini thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#66
I'm also very angry that the CVs chose to have Mansi raped. It's one thing if he slapped her but to rape her is going too far. I don't like how the story is shaping at all. 😡
rayadallie thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#67
After watching today's episode, it seem as though Mansi has been rape. There is no point in thinking otherwise. To besides, she will know if she was raped. The mere fact that she told ankita, it meant that it was real and the rape did happen.

What will ankita do? why did ankita not tell shashank the truth? She would allow shashank to marry Mansi not knowing the truth and decided at a later time when they will solemnized the marriage. What sort of rubbish is this. From one bad decision to another.

Mansi should just tell the truth and have ranaug arrested and face the full brunt of the law. She is keeping quiet for what? and have kinari taunting her from another side. This whole storyline is stupid
IKEAwizard thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: adishri

if we really start nitpicking as to what effect this show will have on the public who watch this show , then believe me , the damage has already been done from a long time.
first and foremost , ekta has never justified rapes in any shows and neither she is doing here. infact from rapes on the tv , females become more aware and how to deal with the issues. so i fail to understand why so much hullabaloo is being done for showing a rape on the tv.

if people are genuinely bothered about impact on younger generation then i have got many points to state here.
from the character of purvi , young girls can get the message that it is totally fine to have pre marital sex in any unconventional place. if at all you get pregnant then just somehow simply swap your illegitimate baby with the legitimate baby of your lover's wife.
do all sorts of raas leelas with a married man under the name of pavitrata and then very self righteously lecture the wife about trust in a marriage. the day is not far when mistresses will openly do tandav on the heads of legally wedded wives , just under the name of pavitra prem.

lets come to archana and vandita. archana was well aware that vandita was being beaten up in her sasuraal and tortured like anything. yet she conveniently hided all the things from manav as she wanted manav's money and resources to be used only for the benefit of her own maiden family. when her own sister was in problem then she manipulated entire world to snatch away the rights of dharmesh's first wife but during the case of vandita she happily ignored. what will such a show have impact on the young generation !!

purvi very well knew that soham is mentally torturing gauri. he was a perfectly potential rapist for all the acts he had done and his wild obsession towards gauri. as a woman it was purvi's duty to punish soham for torturing another woman. but purvi being purvi obviously saw her own benefit and profit. if she punished soham then who would support her in her own kaands ? afterall soham was always the lender of last resort for purvi and by going against him , she was going to loose her own biggest support.


I agree with everything you said except for the part in bold. Although Ekta does not justify rape, she is using it as an intriguing plot point in her romantic television serial, which I have a problem with. I've said it before on here, but I'll say it again: she's essentially exploiting the tragedy of rape by using it as a twist in her serial. You think she's trying to educate people about rape? Maybe. Or maybe she's using it as a juicy track in her slowly dying serial. I think, knowing Ekta and other serial writers, that the second statement is the true one. I simply do not think that rape is interesting or juicy and I really wish that Ekta and the other serial writers would stop using it as a plot point when they can't think of anything else.
Dabulls23 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#69
Mansi and Ankita both disappointed me big time..

Mansi not wanting to tell anyone and giving Ankita kasam to keep it to herself and Ankita bigger fool as she is keeping it from Mansi's fianc Shashank who has every right to know. Ankita is not even considering Shashank's suggestion for postponing the wedding but she wants it to happen as schedule..

What is wrong with these female leads??
onirfans thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Mansi and Ankita both disappointed me big time..

Mansi not wanting to tell anyone and giving Ankita kasam to keep it to herself and Ankita bigger fool as she is keeping it from Mansi's fianc Shashank who has every right to know. Ankita is not even considering Shashank's suggestion for postponing the wedding but she wants it to happen as schedule..

What is wrong with these female leads??


i think its very early to judge ankita ...may be sudden truth vanish her capability tp judge whats right or whats wrong ...may be she has fear that mansi could go in wrong way so first she has to do strong mansi to face world ...

so i am waiting to day episode for judging ankita

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".