PR this week: O Tempera! O Mores!

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Folks,

It is proof positive of the fatal attraction that PR, and commenting on it, has on me (it is really like the Siren Songs in the Odyssey, except that I do not seem to have the good sense that Ulysses had, in having himself tied firmly to the mast!) that I am taking advantage of my charges having discovering the hitherto unknown joys of carrom (there being no video games here, much to their initial disgust) to reconnect, at least briefly, with all of you. Having managed, by dint of a ruthless exercise of authority, to grab the TV for the half hour of PR, I am at least clued in on all the excitement dished out over these last few days.

I could see all the ebb and flow of high emotion in the forum, from hope to despair, and from fairly widespread (if knee-jerk) anger at Arjun-Purvi's apparent lack of concern for Manav (despite the attempts in their defence by the APP, with valuable back up from Janhvi, looking out for her ladli and her future damaad) to even stronger anger directed now at Ovi, plus rejoicing over the latest Arjun-Purvi oh so chweet love scene. I thus decided that you needed to be rescued from this emotional overload by a healthy dose of my standard issue cynicism, and so here I am.

The kidnap fiasco: This was very clumsily handled by any standards, and I mean by the CVs.

Manav: He is brave, very responsible, and generous to a fault, but I am 100% with (our) Varsha in feeling that Manav was extremely stupid in going to meet a clutch of hardened criminals without any (secret) backup at all. If I had been Vishnu, I would have grabbed the cash, then kidnapped Manav in turn, probably releasing Purvi so that she could carry the message to the folks at home, and held out for another Rs.3 crores. Manav had proved to be so facile a bakra that the temptation to show off to Balan would have been irresistible. DK's black briefcase would have come in handy then, as Archana would have wept another bucket of tears, and DK could not have failed to come to the rescue of his sambandhis to be.

Arjun was equally goofy. No, not in tailing Manav, for that showed good sense, though I doubt if he acted from anything but the gut instinct to be there for Purvi when the actual dealing came. Nor in trying to get her out of the car (after having wasted precious seconds in kissing her hands and telling her not to cry). Arjun does that only when Vishnu, having heard the other (police) car approach, and naturally assuming that they had come at Manav's behest, snarls that that the deal is off and commands his acolyte 'Ladki ko laao', indicating a very likely intention to shoot Purvi in front of Manav to show him where he got off. Where Arjun came a cropper was when, instead of trying to hide behind the gang's van with Purvi, he started running with her across the open field, with no cover at all. It is clear that no commando outfit would recruit our boy, he seems to have zero crisis thinking ability! In fact, as soon as he is well enough again, the APP is getting out a collect to send him to a motivating course to teach him Crisis (and Time) Management.

He recovers some lost ground later, when he does that suitably bloodstained crawling act and rescues Purvi, in coordination with Manav. This time he has no choice but to get shot again, since Manav's boodhi haddiyan are not up to fending off Vishnu's resurgent attack, and he fails to retain his hold on the gun. Well, at least Arjun got to be dubbed a hero for taking the two bullets, so it was not a bad deal for him, all in all.

The police: One cannot really blame Sr. Inspector Sameer Rane (the mere Inspector salutes him, and he looks too young to be a Dy. SP) for anything much. At least he does not arrive siren blaring, as they are often shown doing. Neither he nor his men cave in and drop their guns at the first threat from Vishnu, as they are so often made to do, even in the Bruce Willis film The Jackal, not to speak of desi phillums. He and his cohorts inch in relentlessly, and they nab all the gang except for Krishna. And I have no objection at all to his not looking like an Adonis. He looks what he is supposed to be, and that is enough for me. Teju should suit him just fine; she has the same spirit and the same lack of looks; and we really need to look for a chap for her if PR is ever to end. As for Ovi, I would not wish her on Sameer Rane!

The Hospital: Since our boy is a lead (we of the APP do not quibble about whether he is the first, second, third or whatever), he was obviously not about to kick the bucket (which, incidentally, would have triggered off a bucket shortage, what with Archana, Ovi, Purvi, Sulochana and probably even Savita and the stoic Teju getting into the act all at once). So I was not at all worried, and I got set for the Grand Hospital Scene, with the whole gang of the Ds and the Ks and the K (DK) clogging the corridor in true TV soap fashion.

In the event, what stirred me up was not Ovi telling Purvi off, or trying to block her from getting into Arjun's room (that was par for the course for her), nor the touching scene of DK talking to his unconscious son and to Aashana, nor even the very neatly done little interlude between Arjun and Purvi. Very nice, that last, especially as it was extremely emotional while being determinedly low key (How could I think of myself when you were in danger? And then he closes his eyes for even better impact), and both the actors played off each other superbly.

It was rather, firstly, something that I expected as a dead cert, and which was inexplicably missing: The Great Blood Donation Scene. If Manmohan Desai could have three full grown men donating blood for what looked like a minor injury to their mother in Amar Akbar Anthony, Arjun, with all the bleeding that 2 bullet wounds would have entailed, could have used the whole crown outside his room. Alternatively, his blood group could have been a VERY rare one, AB+ve Rh-ve, and lo and behold, Purvi would have the same group! So she could have been stretched out on a bed next to his, gazing soulfully at her (still) unconscious beloved. Neat, no? I cannot for the life of me understand why this golden opportunity for high melodrama was passed up by the CVs. Now, even if they happen to read this on the forum and wake up, it would be too late, because of the second startling happening.

This was the Instant Discharge. Here we have a young man who has been shot twice, lost a lot of blood, and has been operated upon. How is it that he is to be discharged after just one night in the hospital? It is unheard of, and what was worse, it deprived us, at one fell swoop, of the openings for very many charming Arjun-Purvi scenes in the hospital room.

All this because the CVs wanted Arjun to say that he would not go home yet as he still had to fufil the shart, so that Archana could say on Monday that he has more than fulfilled it, and now had nothing more to do to prove himself. They are going to tone down the Arjun-Purvi track now and move to the tensions and the confrontations between Manav, Archana, Varsha, Vishnu/Soham and Balan. Over the next few weeks, I suspect that we will see much more of these people, with only bits and pieces of Arjun-Purvi cooing at each other.

Vishnu: I am beginning to take to Vishnu in a big way. No, Janhvi, I am not going to compete with you in developing a soft corner for him. I like him more and more because he is so true to type that he could give Robert de Niro in Cape Fear a run for his money.

They have chosen Ankit well. I liked the brash arrogance with which he circles Manav in that van, just to rile him. I liked the way he snarls at him - Nazarein neechey! Hamko aankhon mein itna gussa dekhne ki aadat nahin hai!! (Lower your eyes! I am not used to seeing so much anger in (a victim's) eyes!). I liked the volatile temper, which switches in an instant from joking to menace, and hints at a lurking instability that is more frightening than overt harshness. It is vintage Bad Guy, and is in sync with his shooting at the fleeing pair, not just once but again, and the second time when he has no way to escape. I do not see why anyone should be surprised at the way he is. One cannot have a very dangerous dhanda like kidnapping and avoid having to kill someone every now and then. It is not a vegetarian career, you know!

Pranati, we were slightly mistaken, you and I: you in identifying the roots of what Vishnu is, and I in endorsing it. It is not Savita aaji – who has, moreover, since done a 180 degrees about turn from the earlier stereotype of her. It is his mayee Varsha. After all, she is his maasi by blood, and her favourite pastime was also kidnapping, if of a different kind (my tongue is almost in my cheek now!). She has further reinforced the inheritance from her with the upbringing she gets him under Balan's aegis, thus taking care of both the nature and nurture aspects at one go.

I suppose they will do a Valmiki on Vishnu one of these days, but for now, I am quite content to have such a splendid Bad Guy. Having been caught red-handed on a kidnapping charge, there should normally be no chance of bail for him. So I suspect he will escape, probably with Balan's connivance, when they are transporting him from the police lock up to a regular jail. Such transits are meant for one of two express purposes: 1) for a staged hold up, followed by an escape, as in the afore-mentioned AAA and so many other films or 2) for staging a major accident to the van, in which the accused escapes, as in Harrison Ford's The Fugitive or, even better, is (supposedly) killed, as, most recently, in Ekta's BALH. Let us see if either of these happens. Phir to Manav ki khair nahin! (Manav should then look out!).

Now, if I don't look sharp and push off to rustle up lunch, meri khair nahin! Bye, folks, and have a nice weekend, to which I hope (for at least some of you) to have contributed in some small measure.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

PS: When Archana and Purvi were borrowing the Second Sari from the temple priest's wife, I felt anew the ridiculousness of making Archana play Purvi's mother, for she looked then more like her elder sister. Yesterday, in the closing shot of her at the hospital, I felt it was even more ridiculous, for Archana, with her hair loose and framing a piquant face, could almost have been taken for Purvi's younger sister. She should look sharp, and move from PR to a serial in which she can play her age and not have to tone down her looks.

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

3.9k

Users

15

Likes

118

Frequent Posters

jamkarajj thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Hi Shama, glad you're back!!!!! and your analysis...bravo...😊

Jam

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Folks,

It is proof positive of the fatal attraction that PR, and commenting on it, has on me (it is really like the Siren Songs in the Odyssey, except that I do not seem to have the good sense that Ulysses had, in having himself tied firmly to the mast!) that I am taking advantage of my charges having discovering the hitherto unknown joys of carrom (there being no video games here, much to their initial disgust) to reconnect, at least briefly, with all of you. Having managed, by dint of a ruthless exercise of authority, to grab the TV for the half hour of PR, I am at least clued in on all the excitement dished out over these last few days.

I could see all the ebb and flow of high emotion in the forum, from hope to despair, and from fairly widespread (if knee-jerk) anger at Arjun-Purvi's apparent lack of concern for Manav (despite the attempts in their defence by the APP, with valuable back up from Janhvi, looking out for her ladli and her future damaad) to even stronger anger directed now at Ovi, plus rejoicing over the latest Arjun-Purvi oh so chweet love scene. I thus decided that you needed to be rescued from this emotional overload by a healthy dose of my standard issue cynicism, and so here I am.

The kidnap fiasco: This was very clumsily handled by any standards, and I mean by the CVs.

Manav: He is brave, very responsible, and generous to a fault, but I am 100% with (our) Varsha in feeling that Manav was extremely stupid in going to meet a clutch of hardened criminals without any (secret) backup at all. If I had been Vishnu, I would have grabbed the cash, then kidnapped Manav in turn, probably releasing Purvi so that she could carry the message to the folks at home, and held out for another Rs.3 crores. Manav had proved to be so facile a bakra that the temptation to show off to Balan would have been irresistible. DK's black briefcase would have come in handy then, as Archana would have wept another bucket of tears, and DK could not have failed to come to the rescue of his sambandhis to be.

Arjun was equally goofy. No, not in tailing Manav, for that showed good sense, though I doubt if he acted from anything but the gut instinct to be there for Purvi when the actual dealing came. Nor in trying to get her out of the car (after having wasted precious seconds in kissing her hands and telling her not to cry). Arjun does that only when Vishnu, having heard the other (police) car approach, and naturally assuming that they had come at Manav's behest, snarls that that the deal is off and commands his acolyte 'Ladki ko laao', indicating a very likely intention to shoot Purvi in front of Manav to show him where he got off. Where Arjun came a cropper was when, instead of trying to hide behind the gang's van with Purvi, he started running with her across the open field, with no cover at all. It is clear that no commando outfit would recruit our boy, he seems to have zero crisis thinking ability! In fact, as soon as he is well enough again, the APP is getting out a collect to send him to a motivating course to teach him Crisis (and Time) Management.

He recovers some lost ground later, when he does that suitably bloodstained crawling act and rescues Purvi, in coordination with Manav. This time he has no choice but to get shot again, since Manav's boodhi haddiyan are not up to fending off Vishnu's resurgent attack, and he fails to retain his hold on the gun. Well, at least Arjun got to be dubbed a hero for taking the two bullets, so it was not a bad deal for him, all in all.

The police: One cannot really blame Sr. Inspector Sameer Rane (the mere Inspector salutes him, and he looks too young to be a Dy. SP) for anything much. At least he does not arrive siren blaring, as they are often shown doing. Neither he nor his men cave in and drop their guns at the first threat from Vishnu, as they are so often made to do, even in the Bruce Willis film The Jackal, not to speak of desi phillums. He and his cohorts inch in relentlessly, and they nab all the gang except for Krishna. And I have no objection at all to his not looking like an Adonis. He looks what he is supposed to be, and that is enough for me. Teju should suit him just fine; she has the same spirit and the same lack of looks; and we really need to look for a chap for her if PR is ever to end. As for Ovi, I would not wish her on Sameer Rane!

The Hospital: Since our boy is a lead (we of the APP do not quibble about whether he is the first, second, third or whatever), he was obviously not about to kick the bucket (which, incidentally, would have triggered off a bucket shortage, what with Archana, Ovi, Purvi, Sulochana and probably even Savita and the stoic Teju getting into the act all at once). So I was not at all worried, and I got set for the Grand Hospital Scene, with the whole gang of the Ds and the Ks and the K (DK) clogging the corridor in true TV soap fashion.

In the event, what stirred me up was not Ovi telling Purvi off, or trying to block her from getting into Arjun's room (that was par for the course for her), nor the touching scene of DK talking to his unconscious son and to Aashana, nor even the very neatly done little interlude between Arjun and Purvi. Very nice, that last, especially as it was extremely emotional while being determinedly low key (How could I think of myself when you were in danger? And then he closes his eyes for even better impact), and both the actors played off each other superbly.

It was rather, firstly, something that I expected as a dead cert, and which was inexplicably missing: The Great Blood Donation Scene. If Manmohan Desai could have three full grown men donating blood for what looked like a minor injury to their mother in Amar Akbar Anthony, Arjun, with all the bleeding that 2 bullet wounds would have entailed, could have used the whole crown outside his room. Alternatively, his blood group could have been a VERY rare one, AB+ve Rh-ve, and lo and behold, Purvi would have the same group! So she could have been stretched out on a bed next to his, gazing soulfully at her (still) unconscious beloved. Neat, no? I cannot for the life of me understand why this golden opportunity for high melodrama was passed up by the CVs. Now, even if they happen to read this on the forum and wake up, it would be too late, because of the second startling happening.

This was the Instant Discharge. Here we have a young man who has been shot twice, lost a lot of blood, and has been operated upon. How is it that he is to be discharged after just one night in the hospital? It is unheard of, and what was worse, it deprived us, at one fell swoop, of the openings for very many charming Arjun-Purvi scenes in the hospital room.

All this because the CVs wanted Arjun to say that he would not go home yet as he still had to fufil the shart, so that Archana could say on Monday that he has more than fulfilled it, and now had nothing more to do to prove himself. They are going to tone down the Arjun-Purvi track now and move to the tensions and the confrontations between Manav, Archana, Varsha, Vishnu/Soham and Balan. Over the next few weeks, I suspect that we will see much more of these people, with only bits and pieces of Arjun-Purvi cooing at each other.

Vishnu: I am beginning to take to Vishnu in a big way. No, Janhvi, I am not going to compete with you in developing a soft corner for him. I like him more and more because he is so true to type that he could give Robert de Niro in Cape Fear a run for his money.

They have chosen Ankit well. I liked the brash arrogance with which he circles Manav in that van, just to rile him. I liked the way he snarls at him - Nazarein neechey! Hamko aankhon mein itna gussa dekhne ki aadat nahin hai!! (Lower your eyes! I am not used to seeing so much anger in (a victim's) eyes!). I liked the volatile temper, which switches in an instant from joking to menace, and hints at a lurking instability that is more frightening than overt harshness. It is vintage Bad Guy, and is in sync with his shooting at the fleeing pair, not just once but again, and the second time when he has no way to escape. I do not see why anyone should be surprised at the way he is. One cannot have a very dangerous dhanda like kidnapping and avoid having to kill someone every now and then. It is not a vegetarian career, you know!

Pranati, we were slightly mistaken, you and I: you in identifying the roots of what Vishnu is, and I in endorsing it. It is not Savita aaji ' who has, moreover, since done a 180 degrees about turn from the earlier stereotype of her. It is his mayee Varsha. After all, she is his maasi by blood, and her favourite pastime was also kidnapping, if of a different kind (my tongue is almost in my cheek now!). She has further reinforced the inheritance from her with the upbringing she gets him under Balan's aegis, thus taking care of both the nature and nurture aspects at one go.

I suppose they will do a Valmiki on Vishnu one of these days, but for now, I am quite content to have such a splendid Bad Guy. Having been caught red-handed on a kidnapping charge, there should normally be no chance of bail for him. So I suspect he will escape, probably with Balan's connivance, when they are transporting him from the police lock up to a regular jail. Such transits are meant for one of two express purposes: 1) for a staged hold up, followed by an escape, as in the afore-mentioned AAA and so many other films or 2) for staging a major accident to the van, in which the accused escapes, as in Harrison Ford's The Fugitive or, even better, is (supposedly) killed, as, most recently, in Ekta's BALH. Let us see if either of these happens. Phir to Manav ki khair nahin! (Manav should then look out!).

Now, if I don't look sharp and push off to rustle up lunch, meri khair nahin! Bye, folks, and have a nice weekend, to which I hope (for at least some of you) to have contributed in some small measure.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

PS: When Archana and Purvi were borrowing the Second Sari from the temple priest's wife, I felt anew the ridiculousness of making Archana play Purvi's mother, for she looked then more like her elder sister. Yesterday, in the closing shot of her at the hospital, I felt it was even more ridiculous, for Archana, with her hair loose and framing a piquant face, could almost have been taken for Purvi's younger sister. She should look sharp, and move from PR to a serial in which she can play her age and not have to tone down her looks.

soapwatcher1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Folks,

It is proof positive of the fatal attraction that PR, and commenting on it, has on me (it is really like the Siren Songs in the Odyssey, except that I do not seem to have the good sense that Ulysses had, in having himself tied firmly to the mast!) that I am taking advantage of my charges having discovering the hitherto unknown joys of carrom (there being no video games here, much to their initial disgust) to reconnect, at least briefly, with all of you. Having managed, by dint of a ruthless exercise of authority, to grab the TV for the half hour of PR, I am at least clued in on all the excitement dished out over these last few days.

I could see all the ebb and flow of high emotion in the forum, from hope to despair, and from fairly widespread (if knee-jerk) anger at Arjun-Purvi's apparent lack of concern for Manav (despite the attempts in their defence by the APP, with valuable back up from Janhvi, looking out for her ladli and her future damaad) to even stronger anger directed now at Ovi, plus rejoicing over the latest Arjun-Purvi oh so chweet love scene. I thus decided that you needed to be rescued from this emotional overload by a healthy dose of my standard issue cynicism, and so here I am.

The kidnap fiasco: This was very clumsily handled by any standards, and I mean by the CVs.

Manav: He is brave, very responsible, and generous to a fault, but I am 100% with (our) Varsha in feeling that Manav was extremely stupid in going to meet a clutch of hardened criminals without any (secret) backup at all. If I had been Vishnu, I would have grabbed the cash, then kidnapped Manav in turn, probably releasing Purvi so that she could carry the message to the folks at home, and held out for another Rs.3 crores. Manav had proved to be so facile a bakra that the temptation to show off to Balan would have been irresistible. DK's black briefcase would have come in handy then, as Archana would have wept another bucket of tears, and DK could not have failed to come to the rescue of his sambandhis to be.

Arjun was equally goofy. No, not in tailing Manav, for that showed good sense, though I doubt if he acted from anything but the gut instinct to be there for Purvi when the actual dealing came. Nor in trying to get her out of the car (after having wasted precious seconds in kissing her hands and telling her not to cry). Arjun does that only when Vishnu, having heard the other (police) car approach, and naturally assuming that they had come at Manav's behest, snarls that that the deal is off and commands his acolyte 'Ladki ko laao', indicating a very likely intention to shoot Purvi in front of Manav to show him where he got off. Where Arjun came a cropper was when, instead of trying to hide behind the gang's van with Purvi, he started running with her across the open field, with no cover at all. It is clear that no commando outfit would recruit our boy, he seems to have zero crisis thinking ability! In fact, as soon as he is well enough again, the APP is getting out a collect to send him to a motivating course to teach him Crisis (and Time) Management.

He recovers some lost ground later, when he does that suitably bloodstained crawling act and rescues Purvi, in coordination with Manav. This time he has no choice but to get shot again, since Manav's boodhi haddiyan are not up to fending off Vishnu's resurgent attack, and he fails to retain his hold on the gun. Well, at least Arjun got to be dubbed a hero for taking the two bullets, so it was not a bad deal for him, all in all.

The police: One cannot really blame Sr. Inspector Sameer Rane (the mere Inspector salutes him, and he looks too young to be a Dy. SP) for anything much. At least he does not arrive siren blaring, as they are often shown doing. Neither he nor his men cave in and drop their guns at the first threat from Vishnu, as they are so often made to do, even in the Bruce Willis film The Jackal, not to speak of desi phillums. He and his cohorts inch in relentlessly, and they nab all the gang except for Krishna. And I have no objection at all to his not looking like an Adonis. He looks what he is supposed to be, and that is enough for me. Teju should suit him just fine; she has the same spirit and the same lack of looks; and we really need to look for a chap for her if PR is ever to end. As for Ovi, I would not wish her on Sameer Rane!

The Hospital: Since our boy is a lead (we of the APP do not quibble about whether he is the first, second, third or whatever), he was obviously not about to kick the bucket (which, incidentally, would have triggered off a bucket shortage, what with Archana, Ovi, Purvi, Sulochana and probably even Savita and the stoic Teju getting into the act all at once). So I was not at all worried, and I got set for the Grand Hospital Scene, with the whole gang of the Ds and the Ks and the K (DK) clogging the corridor in true TV soap fashion.

In the event, what stirred me up was not Ovi telling Purvi off, or trying to block her from getting into Arjun's room (that was par for the course for her), nor the touching scene of DK talking to his unconscious son and to Aashana, nor even the very neatly done little interlude between Arjun and Purvi. Very nice, that last, especially as it was extremely emotional while being determinedly low key (How could I think of myself when you were in danger? And then he closes his eyes for even better impact), and both the actors played off each other superbly.

It was rather, firstly, something that I expected as a dead cert, and which was inexplicably missing: The Great Blood Donation Scene. If Manmohan Desai could have three full grown men donating blood for what looked like a minor injury to their mother in Amar Akbar Anthony, Arjun, with all the bleeding that 2 bullet wounds would have entailed, could have used the whole crown outside his room. Alternatively, his blood group could have been a VERY rare one, AB+ve Rh-ve, and lo and behold, Purvi would have the same group! So she could have been stretched out on a bed next to his, gazing soulfully at her (still) unconscious beloved. Neat, no? I cannot for the life of me understand why this golden opportunity for high melodrama was passed up by the CVs. Now, even if they happen to read this on the forum and wake up, it would be too late, because of the second startling happening.

This was the Instant Discharge. Here we have a young man who has been shot twice, lost a lot of blood, and has been operated upon. How is it that he is to be discharged after just one night in the hospital? It is unheard of, and what was worse, it deprived us, at one fell swoop, of the openings for very many charming Arjun-Purvi scenes in the hospital room.

All this because the CVs wanted Arjun to say that he would not go home yet as he still had to fufil the shart, so that Archana could say on Monday that he has more than fulfilled it, and now had nothing more to do to prove himself. They are going to tone down the Arjun-Purvi track now and move to the tensions and the confrontations between Manav, Archana, Varsha, Vishnu/Soham and Balan. Over the next few weeks, I suspect that we will see much more of these people, with only bits and pieces of Arjun-Purvi cooing at each other.

Vishnu: I am beginning to take to Vishnu in a big way. No, Janhvi, I am not going to compete with you in developing a soft corner for him. I like him more and more because he is so true to type that he could give Robert de Niro in Cape Fear a run for his money.

They have chosen Ankit well. I liked the brash arrogance with which he circles Manav in that van, just to rile him. I liked the way he snarls at him - Nazarein neechey! Hamko aankhon mein itna gussa dekhne ki aadat nahin hai!! (Lower your eyes! I am not used to seeing so much anger in (a victim's) eyes!). I liked the volatile temper, which switches in an instant from joking to menace, and hints at a lurking instability that is more frightening than overt harshness. It is vintage Bad Guy, and is in sync with his shooting at the fleeing pair, not just once but again, and the second time when he has no way to escape. I do not see why anyone should be surprised at the way he is. One cannot have a very dangerous dhanda like kidnapping and avoid having to kill someone every now and then. It is not a vegetarian career, you know!

Pranati, we were slightly mistaken, you and I: you in identifying the roots of what Vishnu is, and I in endorsing it. It is not Savita aaji ' who has, moreover, since done a 180 degrees about turn from the earlier stereotype of her. It is his mayee Varsha. After all, she is his maasi by blood, and her favourite pastime was also kidnapping, if of a different kind (my tongue is almost in my cheek now!). She has further reinforced the inheritance from her with the upbringing she gets him under Balan's aegis, thus taking care of both the nature and nurture aspects at one go.

I suppose they will do a Valmiki on Vishnu one of these days, but for now, I am quite content to have such a splendid Bad Guy. Having been caught red-handed on a kidnapping charge, there should normally be no chance of bail for him. So I suspect he will escape, probably with Balan's connivance, when they are transporting him from the police lock up to a regular jail. Such transits are meant for one of two express purposes: 1) for a staged hold up, followed by an escape, as in the afore-mentioned AAA and so many other films or 2) for staging a major accident to the van, in which the accused escapes, as in Harrison Ford's The Fugitive or, even better, is (supposedly) killed, as, most recently, in Ekta's BALH. Let us see if either of these happens. Phir to Manav ki khair nahin! (Manav should then look out!).

Now, if I don't look sharp and push off to rustle up lunch, meri khair nahin! Bye, folks, and have a nice weekend, to which I hope (for at least some of you) to have contributed in some small measure.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

PS: When Archana and Purvi were borrowing the Second Sari from the temple priest's wife, I felt anew the ridiculousness of making Archana play Purvi's mother, for she looked then more like her elder sister. Yesterday, in the closing shot of her at the hospital, I felt it was even more ridiculous, for Archana, with her hair loose and framing a piquant face, could almost have been taken for Purvi's younger sister. She should look sharp, and move from PR to a serial in which she can play her age and not have to tone down her looks.

So glad to see you back!! Liked the reference to Odysseus and the mast.😊
Now to respond in no proper order - I held my breath for a moment in glad anticipation of having one more Soham fan, ah, but you like him for all the wrong reasons!! I especially liked the way he told his dad to drop his glance. Fanciful as I am where this lad is concerned, it was kind of befitting that Manav glared at his boy (it is a father's duty and right to get angry at his child when the child strays), it was symbolic of a father's disapproval and also when Manav continued to glare, he showed the lad who was parent. Far fetched, maybe but plausible!😉
As for Archana, I thought the same, with that loose braid, she looked stunning.
The instant discharge was a little sudden but perhaps the CVs want to be done with this kidnapping theme and delve straight into discovering Soham. Clever connection there, Varsha's kidnapping habits tied in with Soham's dhandha.
I am so glad the blood transfusion did not happen. What if there had been a twist, what if Ovi's blood was the only one that matched? I would not have been able to stomach her gazing soulfully at Arjun nor her tooting the horn later saying she saved his life and so he belongs to her.
Not only "our Varsha" but I think a couple of us said it too that Manav should have taken back-up and not trusted some strange goons. And yes, please do send my damaad to that training, he is badly in need of it. 😆
Edited by soapwatcher1 - 13 years ago
_OrChiD_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
[QUOTE=sashasthe

PS: When Archana and Purvi were borrowing the Second Sari from iest's wife, I felt anew the ridiculousness of making Archana play Purvi's mother, for she looked then more like her elder sister. Yesterday, in the closing shot of her at the hospital, I felt it was even more ridiculous, for Archana, with her hair loose and framing a piquant face, could almost have been taken for Purvi's younger sister. She should look sharp, and move from PR to a serial in which she can play her age and not have to tone down her looks.



thats good point ,,,arcanas get up is not well from janmastami ,,this is not like a mother .this is like just new graduation complete student and mor e important her hair style ,,its not suit her character,,,where purvi is like distress look and there is arcana more fresh than purvi,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

i hope cv will give some attention with this and when they will decide their scene then plz what arcanas character and wt arcanas age in this situation now,,,,,,, 1st think,,,,,,,, is this and then decide
susithaarman thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
[QUOTE

PS: When Archana and Purvi were borrowing the Second Sari from the temple priest's wife, I felt anew the ridiculousness of making Archana play Purvi's mother, for she looked then more like her elder sister. Yesterday, in the closing shot of her at the hospital, I felt it was even more ridiculous, for Archana, with her hair loose and framing a piquant face, could almost have been taken for Purvi's younger sister. She should look sharp, and move from PR to a serial in which she can play her age and not have to tone down her looks.



WHEN PR story going are not perfect ..after 18 year leap PR story is not true only time pass story ... PR moving only by actors her looks ...
...
purethought thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Dear Shyamala Ji,
Lovely post as always. :)
Yes, even I thought Vishnu is doing justice to his role. Very convincing.
I disagree with one thing. I agree Ankita is very beautiful, but Asha is also very charming, and stands besides a handsome Rithvik quite well on her own.
Whenever I see Asha and Ankita in the same frame I feel Ankita is Asha's elder sister. I have never found her looking younger than Asha. This is my personal perception so wanted to share it.
😊
Trish
Edited by purethought - 13 years ago
archverma10 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: soapwatcher1

So glad to see you back!! Liked the reference to Odysseus and the mast.😊
Now to respond in no proper order - I held my breath for a moment in glad anticipation of having one more Soham fan, ah, but you like him for all the wrong reasons!! I especially liked the way he told his dad to drop his glance. Fanciful as I am where this lad is concerned, it was kind of befitting that Manav glared at his boy (it is a father's duty and right to get angry at his child when the child strays), it was symbolic of a father's disapproval and also when Manav continued to glare, he showed the lad who was parent. Far fetched, maybe but plausible!😉
As for Archana, I thought the same, with that loose braid, she looked stunning.
The instant discharge was a little sudden but perhaps the CVs want to be done with this kidnapping theme and delve straight into discovering Soham. Clever connection there, Varsha's kidnapping habits tied in with Soham's dhandha.
I am so glad the blood transfusion did not happen. What if there had been a twist, what if Ovi's blood was the only one that matched? I would not have been able to stomach her gazing soulfully at Arjun nor her tooting the horn later saying she saved his life and so he belongs to her.
Not only "our Varsha" but I think a couple of us said it too that Manav should have taken back-up and not trusted some strange goons. And yes, please do send my damaad to that training, he is badly in need of it. 😆

Shyamala well written as always :) Been a long time since I have been consistenly active on the forum...feels good to be back. Jhanvi I know my beta is not the most tactical warrior hero out there...he obviously doesnt lack for courage but I agree...could certainly use some help in the strategy/logical analysis department!!

It stands to reason that of course Manav should not have gone alone into a situation like that, As inspectors Rane himself pointed out..he thought he would be endangering Purvis life if he asked for backup. Again the movie Ransom does come to mind,,,,which I am very proud to say that my boy pointed out immediately. Manav failed to realize that there was no guarantee that once having received the $$ he would have let Purvi or Manav leave alive...why let them go so they can then run to the cops with a full description about everything? Especially Purvi? Who could have overheard anything...any casual bits and pieces of conversation while stuck with them for a whole day and night...that could give them away and risk them getting caught?? Although ur idea of kidnapping Manav is ingenious Shyamala I doubt Vishnu and his ragtag gang have the capacity to think that far ahead.

I agree that he is a good villain though. As I mentioned in an earlier post of mine (remember Jyothi?)... He is quite ruthless...and I don't buy any idea of softness in him whatsoever, when he had Manav in front of him with a gun pointed to his head, and the police were already there... he showed himself perfectly capable of shooting Arjun again...the first time to prevent escape...,understandable. 2nd time...no need when the outcome was inevitable anyway...that was done for no other purpose than to simply shoot to kill out of rage. The CVs are going to have to come up with a very interrsting track to explain the paradigm shift on this one I feel...

I think kissing her hands was just to calm her down since she was quite hysterical by the time he pulled the tape off of her mouth (either that or the romantic in me just loved seeing the way that went down :))))

Will be interesting to see where we go from here, I also had another point. My boy seems to have taken now whole life force of his own when it comes to that 10000K challenge as Jyothi, Jay, and I were discussing yesterday...,I have a strange feeling that even if Archana excuses him from it...he may have acquired enough of this "I have prove myself" spiel that he may end up going forward anyway despite what anyone has to say about it...
jdronamraju thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Shyamala,
Looks like the lure of PR, rather the forum or its members, have brought you back even for a short while 😊... glad to see your post..have been missing it for past few days...
I thought that Manav going alone to the rescue was never the wise decision, although I do understand his intentions. Things tend to go haywire in these operations, and being alone is never the answer. Both, Purvi and manav could have been in more danger. So, I am all for Arjun going there to get Purvi, as otherwise, I would be very disappointed in our boy... It is expected of him, and rightly so. How can he sit at home twiddling his thumbs when she is in danger...It is not becoming of a hero..:)..As to the kissing of Purvi's hands etc, I disagree with you on this. He was just trying to calm a frantic Purvi, not wasting time. the girl has been through so much, a momentory comfort is definitely needed. As to the way it all went there after, all I can say is...Arjun is no gali ka munda, just a yuppie dude, who acted on impulse than with any particular plan. it was all knee-jerk momentary reactions, so I am going to put the blame on the CV's on this..!!...Well, he did come back, crawling, to do the final rescue act, and got shot for her too.. What else do we want the hero to do?? He took two bullets for her...😃
I have said enough in another post of mine ,"Crunch Time: Archana Aunty" about Ovi Maam. Let us not even go there now... I balme it all on the family now that they let her go in this crazy delusion of hers.
I loved the DK-Arjun and Arjun-Purvi scenes at the hospital. Hardly a minute, bu that is all you will remember at the end of the day...A very simple conversation, with very simple words of wellbeing, but carried a wealth of love and emotion that touches your heart like nothing else did yesterday. It is like Jahnvi said in her post "Friday finale" ;
"The two were ensconced in a private little universe even as the others looked on".....
I will stop gushing now ...😊
As far as the hospital scene, i did want him to stay for a few more days, so we can see some nice hospital dhabba scenes, and not shift him off to DK's house, where this is not possible. But, alas, doesnt look like it..They are in a hurry to discharge him !!
I am in two minds about this. On one hand, I want Archana to give her consent to Arjun on Monday, for what more does the boy have to do to prove his love, he risked his life for her. It is still a test for Archana on Monday, to pass, if what everyone claims her to be is what she is..But, I do not want her to give it out of gratitude or sympathy for saving her daughter. He deserves it the right way. It is silly to make him earn the money again. I very badly want him, like all of us, to get back to his old life and glory. But, On the other hand, I want to see Arjun plonk that 10k in Archana Aunty's hand and say "here u go..". For me that is the final vindication for what Arjun had to go through for this. This is probably very childish of me, but I would really like to see that. Because, I cannot forget that harshness in her words and those nails of that day...I am not going to go into whether she was right or wrong now. But, I would really like to see that. I know I keep harping on this, been doing it for a while, but that is what will do it for me. Arjun will probably be ok with the first choice, more than me !!😊..

Vishnu, is definitely the good BAD BOY !! He has proved some of us right, who have been saying it from the begining, although in minority. Yes, I do agree now, his acting as a bad boy is impressing me in some scenes, not all, one of them being, because of the fact that he really repulsed me the way he was taunting manav, driving around him..and the way he was holding Purvi with a gun to her head. He was the real bad boy then. He does talk a lot, which does not go well with a villain..his bihari accent seems to have speeded up in his kidnap scene, doesnt drag the words as much as before..hmm..But, I do not see any tenderness, kind-heartedness, brotherly love in him as some have claimed. He is the ultimate bad boy. there is a ruthlessness in him, that will not go away. He did not care who he was shooting at Arjun or Purvi. where is the soft heart in him that everyone else saw? It would take a miracle for the CV's to convince me otherwise. It will probably shown that way anyway, as it is a tv serial..
And that reminiscensing about his mother, was so out of place. In the middle of a kidnap, for gods sake.. which bad boy does that? It just looked stupid, did not show his love for his mother in anyway...

You are right.they seem to be dwindling arjun purvi story, alas...for the big one coming..Varsha/baalan/vishnu/Archana/manav are gonna go strong now.. It is bound to shift focus at some point anyway...Let us see how that goes..more buckets to cry, high melodrama, more shrill dialogues from one and all...got to get my jandubalm in hand for the headaches I am sure gonna have watching them..:) no more going into raptures at Arjun-Purvi, I guess 😊

Archana, is definitely, young and beautiful, but she does not look like Purvi's younger sister though..elder yes...but definitely not younger for me...

Well, Shyamala, keep trying to break your hiatus, for we love it when you do...hoping to hear from you soon again...
Edited by jdronamraju - 13 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Dear Trish (and Jyothi too on this point),

No, no, I seem not to have made myself clear on this, Ankita is here supposed to have at least a passing resemblance to a well preserved 50+ woman, for that is Archana's age. She tries hard, or her makeup team tries hard, but it is an uphill task, and as you both say, she mostly looks like Purvi's elder sister, and I too had noted (wrt the saree borrowing scene).

But if you look at that very last frame of yesterday's episode, Ankita looks unusually young, and not just very pretty. At the other side of the hospital bed, Purvi has to look very tired and bedraggled. So the age factor seems, at least to me, to shift ground, and make Archana look the younger of the two just then. It need not be impossible; after all, the age difference between the actresses must be very little.

Trish, there is no question of Asha not being charming. In fact, when they shoot her well, in soft focus, as in parts of her engagement episode, she can look lovely. But of course Ankita is much prettier, though I hold that Asha has the more elegant and interesting face and bones.

Shyamala

Originally posted by: purethought

Dear Shyamala Ji,

Lovely post as always. :)
Yes, even I thought Vishnu is doing justice to his role. Very convincing.
I disagree with one thing. I agree Ankita is very beautiful, but Asha is also very charming, and stands besides a handsome Rithvik quite well on her own.
Whenever I see Asha and Ankita in the same frame I feel Ankita is Asha's elder sister. I have never found her looking younger than Asha. This is my personal perception so wanted to share it.
😊
Trish

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Dear jam,

Thanks ever so much as always.

This is rather different from my usual stuff, and much more satirical in both tone and content, and so I am glad you liked it all the same. I am not really back, but I will try to peep in from time to time, till I am really liberated come August 23!

Shyamala

Hi Shama, glad you're back!!!!! and your analysis...bravo...😊

Jam

[

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".