Brief Update : 13th Feb 2012 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

82

Views

10.9k

Users

20

Likes

299

Frequent Posters

Pinky1975 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#51
I dont think viewers prefers to see Manav and Archana as lovers. More than lovers they wanted to see them as matured couple and how they deals with their grown up kids. Instead of Archana is crying and doing just Manav jap they wanted to see motherly feeling of Archana towards teju and ovi. No one is interested in romance of Manav-Archana (Hiten-Ankita). What a bakwaas showing buddha-buddhi do romance in front of their kids. Why not CV showing Manav-Archana as matured couple, solving their misunderstanding and problems in a matured way. Today's SBS segment is just awful, 60-year-old couple getting again married, then again suhag rat, and then may be they will have another kid in their old age. Above all this they are repeating all old scenes of Sushita with Hiten-Ankita. I really not understanding why can't they show new matured scenes bet Arman considering their age. What Ekta has made with this beautiful concept. Show which was so close to reality turned out to be such a crap.
Edited by Pinky1975 - 13 years ago
suan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: Pinky1975

I dont think viewers prefers to see Manav and Archana as lovers. More than lovers they wanted to see them as matured couple and how they deals with their grown up kids. Instead of Archana is crying and doing just Manav jap they wanted to see motherly feeling of Archana towards teju and ovi. No one is interested in romance of Manav-Archana (Hiten-Ankita). What a bakwaas showing buddha-buddhi do romance in front of their kids. Why not CV showing Manav-Archana as matured couple, solving their misunderstanding and problems in a matured way. Today's SBS segment is just awful, 60-year-old couple getting again married, then again suhag rat, and then may be they will have another kid in their old age. Above all this they are repeating all old scenes of Sushita with Hiten-Ankita. I really not understanding why can't they show new matured scenes bet Arman considering their age. What Ekta has made with this beautiful concept. Show which was so close to reality turned out to be such a crap.

Pinky,
Great post.👍🏼 Agree with all that you said.
I don't even know if Ekta and Co. know what is giving higher trp's.
People may watch the show for reasons other than Archana and Manav romance, but Ekta interprets the numbers as fans liking the romance. She has repeatedly said that she doesn't care what the audience wants, as long as the show is doing well, that is all she cares about.
Probably Ekta wants to focus on the romance between Archana and Manav to give herself hope that she too will experience this kind of romance as she gets older.
naava thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: Pinky1975

I dont think viewers prefers to see Manav and Archana as lovers. More than lovers they wanted to see them as matured couple and how they deals with their grown up kids. Instead of Archana is crying and doing just Manav jap they wanted to see motherly feeling of Archana towards teju and ovi. No one is interested in romance of Manav-Archana (Hiten-Ankita). What a bakwaas showing buddha-buddhi do romance in front of their kids. Why not CV showing Manav-Archana as matured couple, solving their misunderstanding and problems in a matured way. Today's SBS segment is just awful, 60-year-old couple getting again married, then again suhag rat, and then may be they will have another kid in their old age. Above all this they are repeating all old scenes of Sushita with Hiten-Ankita. I really not understanding why can't they show new matured scenes bet Arman considering their age. What Ekta has made with this beautiful concept. Show which was so close to reality turned out to be such a crap.


Pinky...i know that you are joined by almost all the members of the forum in thinking this way..except of course for me !!!... honestly, i simply don't know where this idea comes from that 60 year olds cannot and do not have romantic sexual feelings absolutely no different than 30 year olds... it's a myth perpetrated by tv/movies and it looks like everyone here has bought into it...if one stays young in mind and body the feelings are just the same...!! honestly!! In the real world, this is true...why can't it be shown on the screen?

if Ekta can convince the viewers that it is not only realistic but a lot healthier, just as sweet and fun and exciting... then cheers to her. None of these feelings and encounters take away from maternal feelings.. as a matter of fact, children who watch their parents romantically expressive are statistically far far healthier than their counterparts who only see domesticity. I guess one can be old at 20 but this doesn't mean someone shouldnt' and can't be young at 60.

i know i stand alone on this forum on this subject...and i never thought i would be defending Ekta...😆 but there's a first for everything i guess.

PS...I think the issue is more what Poppy stated...that people don't want to see romance between Hiten and Ankita because the "romance" should be between Sushant and Ankita...they are willing to have a more mature Manav in Hiten but the romance should only be Sushita. I will bet dollars for doughnuts, that if Sushant were still playing Manav, and the 18 year separation happened, viewers would want and wait for the romance between Archu/Manav...in this way it's kind of like after a divorce, watching a parent romantic with a step-parent...that is very hard for kids to take sometimes... but let's not confuse this problem with age. 😉 😃
Edited by naava - 13 years ago
sushkita10 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#54

Pinky...i know that you are joined by almost all the members of the forum in thinking this way..except of course for me !!!... honestly, i simply don't know where this idea comes from that 60 year olds cannot and do not have romantic sexual feelings absolutely no different than 30 year olds... it's a myth perpetrated by tv/movies and it looks like everyone here has bought into it...if one stays young in mind and body the feelings are just the same...!! honestly!! In the real world, this is true...why can't it be shown on the screen?

if Ekta can convince the viewers that it is not only realistic but a lot healthier, just as sweet and fun and exciting... then cheers to her. None of these feelings and encounters take away from maternal feelings.. as a matter of fact, children who watch their parents romantically expressive are statistically far far healthier than their counterparts who only see domesticity. I guess one can be old at 20 but this doesn't mean someone shouldnt' and can't be young at 60.

i know i stand alone on this forum on this subject...and i never thought i would be defending Ekta...😆 but there's a first for everything i guess.
naava i want to say romance in 60 years is not wrong but the situation and the way of showing romance is wrong in PR now they showing a 56aged woman thinking dreaming her husband who left her 18years back and with her son and daughters .in this situation she should b thinking and imagining her not only her hubby but also kids and 1kid is missing for 18yeaRS FOR WHICH SHE WAS REPONSIBLE.IN THAT SITUATION HOW A WOMAN ONLY IMAGIN ROMANCE NOT THE SWEET LITTLE FACES POF HER KIDS WHOM SHE LOST😲that is reason audience cant accept it and another reason as the character manav acted by another actor so ekta should represent new manav in different way so ppl can like it but CV everytime trying to show previous famouse scene rerepetated by new one how ppl forget all those scene and easily accept it😕may b i can make u clear 😃
sushkita10 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: naava




PS...I think the issue is more what Poppy stated...that people don't want to see romance between Hiten and Ankita because the "romance" should be between Sushant and Ankita...they are willing to have a more mature Manav in Hiten but the romance should only be Sushita. I will bet dollars for doughnuts, that if Sushant were still playing Manav, and the 18 year separation happened, viewers would want and wait for the romance between Archu/Manav...in this way it's kind of like after a divorce, watching a parent romantic with a step-parent...that is very hard for kids to take sometimes... but let's not confuse this problem with age. 😉 😃

👍🏼👏absolutely u got my point
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#56

I meant romance for Manav and Archana ...not Hiten and Ankita or Sushant and Ankita .

Sushant and Ankita were a very popular screen couple and that is why TRPs were an all time high ...but Manav and Archana too have a strong fan following of their own .and Hiten on his own is a popular actor with his own fans .Even if he was acting in some other show , his fans would watch it .
Have you guys not noticed ...it is so obvious that deliberately now Manav and Archana are being shown as lovers and not as much as parents .I think in the begining when the leap happened , Manav was shown with his daughters a lot but now even that stopped .
Archu is shown thinking about the babies but not that much ...
I think maybe the writers now feel that they made a mistake by showing Manav and Archana so old because their romance was the USP of the show so now they are deliberately shown more as lovers ( crying and dreaming for each other ) and less as parents ...
And TRPs are better now ...
Those girls are just too old ..Even it looks ridiculous when they hug Hiten as Papa , forget about Ankita .
I ma also a much much bigger fan of Sush and Anki but to be honest , I want Ankita's show to do well and I want her to be the main heroine who looks beatiful and glamorous .Maybe I am not being realistic but then what else in this show is realistic ...
At least I get to see my fav star like this ..I am sure many others to ofeel this way .They would rather see a beautiful and youngish looking Archana .
Edited by Tanyaz - 13 years ago
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#57
To be honest I don't want Archana to dream and fantasise about a man who took her kids away and made them hate her ...
To be honest , Archana should hate Manav the most in this world ...in my opinion but I know that will never happen because this show is only about TRPs and better TRPs will come with the Manav and Archana's love story .
You can see yourself .The TRPs got better when Manav attended Punni's engagement .
I hope even some other love story in the show becomes popular but it seems that for now the CVs are only concentrating on Manav and Archana's story ..
Tanyaz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#58
Arrey guys , did you see SBS ..
Anki looking drop dead gorgeous ...😍
suan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#59

Pinky...i know that you are joined by almost all the members of the forum in thinking this way..except of course for me !!!... honestly, i simply don't know where this idea comes from that 60 year olds cannot and do not have romantic sexual feelings absolutely no different than 30 year olds... it's a myth perpetrated by tv/movies and it looks like everyone here has bought into it...if one stays young in mind and body the feelings are just the same...!! honestly!! In the real world, this is true...why can't it be shown on the screen?

if Ekta can convince the viewers that it is not only realistic but a lot healthier, just as sweet and fun and exciting... then cheers to her. None of these feelings and encounters take away from maternal feelings.. as a matter of fact, children who watch their parents romantically expressive are statistically far far healthier than their counterparts who only see domesticity. I guess one can be old at 20 but this doesn't mean someone shouldnt' and can't be young at 60.

i know i stand alone on this forum on this subject...and i never thought i would be defending Ekta...😆 but there's a first for everything i guess.

PS...I think the issue is more what Poppy stated...that people don't want to see romance between Hiten and Ankita because the "romance" should be between Sushant and Ankita...they are willing to have a more mature Manav in Hiten but the romance should only be Sushita. I will bet dollars for doughnuts, that if Sushant were still playing Manav, and the 18 year separation happened, viewers would want and wait for the romance between Archu/Manav...in this way it's kind of like after a divorce, watching a parent romantic with a step-parent...that is very hard for kids to take sometimes... but let's not confuse this problem with age. 😉 😃
Hi Naava,
I agee with most of what you said.
I'm one of those who can't see any other actor (not just Hiten), as Manav.
Sushant played Manav for so long. He and Ankita blended so well, and when they became a real life couple, that helped the chemistry alot, and this cannot be replicated with any other actor.
Having said that, I still wouldn't want to see just romance between Arman (always Sushita) at 50+ years old.
What has happend in their relationship since this latest leap, changes how they should relate.
Even when Sushant was still there, in some episodes when romance was shown, it seemed out of place considering the other factors that were occuring in their lives at the time.
In the same way, with Hiten as Manav, them being apart for 18 years with no contact at all, to now show them as a very romantic couple seems out of place and unreal, with all the other things happening with their family at this time, especially Archana not asking about her daughters and neither Archana nor Manav talking about Soham. Romance in this context is very off-putting to me.
sushkita10 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Tanyaz

To be honest I don't want Archana to dream and fantasise about a man who took her kids away and made them hate her ...

To be honest , Archana should hate Manav the most in this world ...in my opinion but I know that will never happen because this show is only about TRPs and better TRPs will come with the Manav and Archana's love story .
You can see yourself .The TRPs got better when Manav attended Punni's engagement .
I hope even some other love story in the show becomes popular but it seems that for now the CVs are only concentrating on Manav and Archana's story ..

that means manav may b hiten/sush there is no differenceppl liking there love story and romance may b next week PR will n in top5 bc ppl will see their as newly married couple and SR.it will increase TRP bc hiten has more fan following so now all PR fan will b happy with this remarriage and ankita have to continue this crap show more than 2years and all will forget arman as sushita and known archana manav as anki-hiten jodi👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".