Is it right for a Man to slap a woman? - Page 2

Manav was wrong, but his reaction was understandable.

well.. slapping is not the solution to anythng... b it for men or women...

i dont think Slapping is a solution for any problem infact it helps in raising aggression in dat person even moree...

but in dis case i would say Varsha deserves dis and if you are in love wid something crazily and if anyone causes a small problem also to dat den one defoo loses dere cool..personal experience

and the way she pushed Archana very hard..wen i saw the clipping i was like ouch..and during initial days of pregnancy such accidents may lead to miscarriage also..

so i dont find manav's action a wrong thing but it'll help in moree drama in the show..dats it

A person is slapped so that his/her brains fall in the right place and he/she thinks logically without being biased or carried away by emotions...😆😆
Man to woman, woman to man, woman to woman and man to man all are fine as long as the person who is slapping is right. We should not unnecessarily fight over gender here...Varsha deserved it..If Manav wasn't there , Sulochana would have done the job..
At the end of the day we need to ask ourselves did Varsha deserve that slap or not?
And my heart says she deserves more..ek se mera kya hoga kaaliya...😉
😉

Originally posted by: Tanyaz

Satish too slapped her once . She really knows how to push someone beyond their limits

And strangely, no one brought up a poll talking about this. Or when Sulochana slapped Varsha after learning that she had an abortion.

Why is that Manav doing it is all of a sudden wrong?

And if people can defend Varsha pushing Archana by saying that it's an accident, why can't the same be said for Manav?

thanks for your feedback.

Man has no right to slap a woman...even if the woman makes mistakes.

it is very rare to see woman slapping a man

it totally depends on the situation. in a situation like this i am in neutral state because as a husband, manav was angry on varsha, who being a sister, cannot see anything in her anger. i agree with manav. he made a point when he told her to adopt those kids. but i wud also say that slapping her was a bit much. well she deserved it i give that but i wud say that it should have been archana who should have slapped her instead of manav. that wud have been better.

ofcourse i do not believe in domestic violence. totally hate it

Varsha is a drama queen most of the time...She never listen to her Tia...and Anchu will do anything for them...
She was the one who aborted her baby...now she wants to have one because she was pressured at one point by Satish mom...
Manav is right you so want to be a mother adopt one the the street kids...show how much love you have and give it the the kids that needs it the most...This is a child who wants to be loved...stop blaming your Tia for your mistakes...

Originally posted by: sherma

d slap was uncalled for,she dint intentionally pushed archu,it was a similar case wich happened wid shravni,wen she was 6 to 7 mth preganant but nobody eveen manav dint slapped archu nor did he slapped archu wen savita was pushed by archu in fire,i know armaan love each other a lot but that doesnt mean others dont ahve feelings or emotions.

if i wld be varsha wldnt have forgiven manav ever,he slapped her on road,and if i wld be satish wld break all relations wid a person called manav who slappd his wife.

I agree she desvered it.

manav was wrong.

I think violence of anyform is wrong. not just slapping.

it does not matter if it is a man, woman, elder, child or anyone it is wrong.

the other day damodhar beat savita - that was wrong - irrespectve of whether it was done in jest or anger - irrespective of whether it was done to a person we as viewers have a bias against - there are no exceptions to support violent acts.

slapping or pushing or beating someone is an act committed when one loses control over their emotions and logic. It deserves no accolades, no recogniton. yet this is probably not the forum to mention that violence is not to be praised as there are always knowing or unknowing "archana related" exceptions to this rule.

damodhar's wife beating incident was apprecaited as the person being beaten needed to be taught a lesson by someone for her ill treatment to archana

varsha's slap by a man is probably also considered ok as someone needs to teach her a lesson for being ungrateful to archana and wishng her ill for her pregnancy (one where she volunteered to give away her child on a whim).

archana slapped people several times - she was wrong

sulochana has slapped several times - she was wrong

savita tried to burn archana - she was wrong


being from the gentler sex does not make a violent act permissible in my regard

i his wife was pushed and he was upset he sould have behaved like an adult in front of the immaturely acting Varsha and walked away with archana. archana gets this kind of reaction becauses she forces herself on people. he should first control his wife before chastising others.

she latches on in a very saccharine sweet kind of way which suffocates one as the viewer - you can just pity the poor character who she imposes herself on.

archana has to learn to cut the umbilical cord from people who she develops an attracton towards for their ill-feelings towards her.