Kool's Commentary : Sep 13 PR - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

85

Views

6.1k

Users

28

Likes

216

Frequent Posters

viram thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#31
[/B]Great commentary Kools.



Varsha is as usual on the wrong track. She hasn't learnt any lessons from her past. She still believes she is right. Why does she forget how blind she was to Ashwin's double game ? She walked out of a loving home not caring for her parents or her sisters. Now she is sure to act in the same arrogant way(a stubborn Mule) and ruin not only her life but also Satish's .She must realise how lucky she is to have such a loving mom -in-law and pa-in-law. I hope the CVs don't show anything like abortion as it will send a very wrong message to the younger generation.How can any one kill an innocent life which has just started its journey of life in this world? Totally inhuman . How come there is only one train,)one compartment) one restaurant, one vegetable market,one auto rickshaw and one mandir in Mumbai?? Which place do the rest of the mumbaikars frequent? I am very curious.
Edited by viram - 15 years ago
unknown18 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#32
One more thing. I dont understand y Jay and Archu didnt talk with each other before agreeing for the marriage Even sharmilay ArMan went on dates! Jay and Archu shud hav gone on some dates and talked about things b4. I get Jay's point too but he shud hav said this b4. Also, if they r going to reunite Arman (bcoz they r leads - I guess) then they shud not get Jay and Archu married. They can show Jay and Archu going on dates and Jay might show his true colours and then Archu can refuse or somehow the wedding stops. I wud hate it if they break Jay-Archu and Manav-Shravani marriage later on.
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#33
Hi people!

Nice commentary kools.

There are so many things that I wanna say today. Lots of things are going on in my head.

Ganpati Puja and Damo-

Exactly my thoughts on the Ganpati puja and Damodar scene. Whole year these people pester Bappa (not with genuine wishes and prayers but by taking foolish decisions and then blaming Bappa or cursing their fates, and when Bappa gives them a way to set things right, they still don't accept it and later blame Bappa again), at the time when he is being pampered by modaks and all, Damodar again spoilt Bappa's good mood.

Sometimes the CVs completely leave behind some good characters. For instance, what is going on in Damo's life? We are never shown this and I always wonder what he does (except for praying to Bappa for his foolish son and lovely daughter-in-law). If ArMan unite, then the serial will show that the Pavitra Rishta was between Bappa and Damodar- Bhagwan - Bhakt ka pavitra rishta.

Seriously, all the credit for ArMan uniting will go to Damo and Bappa. If he unites ArMan it will only be for Damo's sake, and not bcos ArMan are helpless/love each other/are good people/'sacrifice' for others/'used' by others.

I don't really want ArMan to unite in this manner, but no union would really give a wrong message about God betraying a devotee's trust(Damo). This serial has gone beyond the realms of the usual trash that daily soaps on TV portray. Cos some of the things are shown so seriously that it is impossible to ignore- they just leave the mark, like the tug of war in this 'should bappa unite them?'. Cos as we know Ganpati is the god of 'buddhi'- logic, reasoning- by all means of logic and reasoning, one can say ArMan have been unfair, especially Manav, to all and sundry. I wish we had a dream sequence or something, or Damo's death sequence (sorry but I had no other option coming in my brain) in which he asks God in a daze why he separated ArMan- (like it was shown in the film 'guide' in the end)- and some nice pearls of wisdom thrown by Ganpati bappa at how his two bhakts ArMan are terribly wrong and how he can't do injustice to the whole world due to them- it would be a nice change to show and accept that the leads are wrong for a change.

The debate is still going on my mind as to what I want to see- Bhakt's true faith winning or justice being meted out on the basis of the fact that MAanv is actually no victim. Cos the best that would have been- Ganpati Bappa looking into it that Manav realises his mistakes, makes a stand, makes penance, fights and wins- will never be shown in PR, cos the CVs don't want to show the leads as wrong.

Me in a strange mood today, please don't mind my ramblings.

Okay getting back to the main topic:

Satish- Varsha and abortion (sounds so much like Saas Bahu and saazish.... hehehehe)

What we are going to see right now in the Varsha- Satish scenario is a bit of realistic life, and so I'm glad that somewhere the serial is getting back to its roots. Problems do crop up between husband-wife in these things.

One should always plan best and not get into such problems later. If however, the baby has happened, then an analysis is required about why they don't really need the baby. If it is a genuine reason- such as in the middle of a difficult job training that takes up a lot of time and can't be abandoned midway or something else- then I would even understand, and expect the husband and family to understand as well (Although even in this situation I would prefer they work out some convenient middle route). But here Varsha is not really justified. She can easily wait for one more year at home since she is not working anyway, and wasn't ambitious enough to work in 2 yrs.

Plus Satish's wishes have to be respected. I agree that it is ultimately the woman whose life changes more bcos of the baby- and it is her body- so technically, yes, she is by all means justified in doing what she wants- but you should definitely have some consideration of what your better half wants- more important than the fact that its his baby as well and his right (and rightfully so) is the fact that his wishes must be respected as well, if you truly love him. Satish has done so much for Varsha, now if she does not respond back even in this tiny way by holding back her career ambitions a little, then I would be really disappointed.

There is a nice line that I read once, and I liked it so much that I used it in my FF as well-

"Career, growth, family etc. are all balls to be juggled. The problem is - first two are rubber balls- (they will bounce back)- third is of glass- (it may crash)."

Debatable, but reflects a woman's fear very well. And from I believe, very true too.

Varsha needs to remember this too. She needs to think about everyone this time, not just herself. And even this decision for herself will not be a right one. She will just be acting stubborn if she decides to go in for job now. It won't be a logical, rational decision AT ALL.

I won't blame Satish one bit if he gets superpissed with Varsha and hits out at her this time. Cos everyone has an upper threshold.

Finally, ArMan:
Any amount of rambling on them is actually useless. I will just say two things- 1.) Archana is really a very good person. I loved what she decided about the job today. A most sensible decision. She deserves the very very best in life. I'm so sad she let go of Satish and went back to the dunce called Manav. I hope Jaywant truly falls in love with her, not with her beauty etc. but with actually the beauty in her heart.

2.) Manav- I hate him. Go to hell. Get lost. Idiot!!!
Have anyone of you seen Astitva Ek prem kahani? It showed that the lead hero quietly goes away from everyone's lives when he realises that he has been unfair to both women- his ex-wife (to whom he had not been loyal) and his current wife- (he reads his wife's diary after death). I want something of that sort for Manav after Shravani walks out with child and Savita curses him for losing Sachu. I want Manav to think, that staying and trying to come back in Archu's life after when she is actually trying to make a new beginning- is wrong. I want him to quietly step out of the picture and focus on his growth, and help his family and Archu quietly whenever in need by staying invisible. A second leap later, we can have Archu deciding on whether she wants him back, (after she has said no to marriage with Jaywant that is)

How does it sound????

Ok enough. Gotta get back to my research work. Deadline is two days. Please pray for me guys, I really could do with a bit of good luck right now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#34
Superb post Niki...Loved your example of Astitva ek kahani...👏 Manav does need to have gone thru that for ArMan to be ever together...
I thought Niki walia and Abhi's marriage was unrealistic...She being so mature and him being young and immature...I had expected a little better decision from her but oh well...
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

Jasmine
Fathers younger bro is called Kaka.
There is no specific name for Fathers sisters hubby .Generally he is called as Kaka or by adding a RAO as a suffix only ..........Like Mohanrao , or Vikasrao etc .



In our Marathi circle, we call Father's sisters hubby as Mama. Atya and Mama, though I've heard RAO too, my Dad uses it for his dad's sisters hubby. Mother's sisters hubby is called Kaka. Maushi and Kaka.

Everyone in PR says Kaki, but frankly speaking, even though I'm Maharashtrian, I've never heard 'Kaki.' We always say Kaka and Kaku. (For father's bro's wife)

nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Superb post Niki...Loved your example of Astitva ek kahani...👏 Manav does need to have gone thru that for ArMan to be ever together... Thanks Varsha Di, for days I have been trying to think about what can resurrect Manav. And the only way I think the audience will ever accept him back truly is to show him introspecting, becoming wiser, realising his faults and if/when he finally returns to Archu's life- it should be as a stronger, wiser man, and to help Archu out of some serious problem that makes coming back inevitable- truly a knight in shining armour. I would have written it out in detail, but not getting that much time nowadays.

I thought Niki walia and Abhi's marriage was unrealistic...She being so mature and him being young and immature...I had expected a little better decision from her but oh well... Still it was a nice serial. I didn't watch it continuously, but my Mom watched it everyday without fail. It was a wonderful, mature story. Now if Ajai Sinha had been the writer for PR, I'm sure this serial would have got some really big awards. With such an excellent cast, a wonderful initial plotline and scope for so many social issues- PR could have been an entertaining, romantic, emotional social saga.

Sigh!!! Dreams on fire!!

toothbrush13 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Gotta get back to my research work. Deadline is two days.

Good luck Nikita! I hope your research endeavor is highly successful!
It was really nice to read such a lengthy post from you again. I would have preferred that after the leap they had followed your idea rather than this current track which has made matters worse.
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: toothbrush13

Good luck Nikita! I hope your research endeavor is highly successful!
It was really nice to read such a lengthy post from you again. I would have preferred that after the leap they had followed your idea rather than this current track which has made matters worse.

Yep agree wish ArMan both had done some interospective soul searching during leap time and come back...What they have shown post leap is nothing different...same o same o...
Niki good luck with your research dear..
nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: toothbrush13

Good luck Nikita! I hope your research endeavor is highly successful!
It was really nice to read such a lengthy post from you again. I would have preferred that after the leap they had followed your idea rather than this current track which has made matters worse.



Hey TB!! Where's your analysis for today? Me waiting.

I don't know TB, after the one year leap it wouldn't have been that suitable, cos Manav had not really been very unfair to Shravani back then. His mistakes were very human and he was still in a slightly sympathetic phase. But now, they have crossed all boundaries and he has made the life of both women hell. No sympathies come from any corner. Any sympathy is actually for Sushant who cries so well.

If they wanted to end this track after one year leap, they should have done it the way Sid had pointed out in her OS- refused to marry shravani but not gone back to Archu. But now the mountain of his mistakes is too big. This time I want him to be left without anything, Savita to curse him for losing Sachin, he being left all alone- and finally going away to some place in solitude, until some urgent need or Archu falling in some serious trouble forces him to come back.
Edited by nikitagmc - 15 years ago
toothbrush13 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Hey TB!! Where's your analysis for today? Me waiting.

I don't know TB, after the one year leap it wouldn't have been that suitable, cos Manav had not really been very unfair to Shravani back then. His mistakes were very human and he was still in a slightly sympathetic phase. But now, they have crossed all boundaries and he has made the life of both women hell. No sympathies come from any corner. Any sympathy is actually for Sushant who cries so well.

If they wanted to end this track after one year leap, they should have done it the way Sid had pointed out in her OS- refused to marry shravani but not gone back to Archu. But now the mountain of his mistakes is too big. This time I want him to be left without anything, Savita to curse him for losing Sachin, he being left all alone- and finally going away to some place in solitude, until some urgent need or Archu falling in some serious trouble forces him to come back.

I haven't bothered analyzing anything for a while, I barely even read the update. 😆
As much as I would love for them to reach logical solutions, we all know the writers love to create all sorts of unnecessarily dramatic situations. A few things that I still would like to see - in regards to the major issues of the show - are: a) Shravani realizing she can have a much better, emotionally and financially secure life than the one Manav's giving her; b) Some type of retribution for Savita's evil deeds; c) Marriage not being forced on Archana, whether it's with Jaywant or Manav; d) Introspection with Manav with some type of ensuing mature decision process; and finally e) both Manav and Archana happy - most likely together - after taking their own decisions about the course of their life. The likeliness of all that happening seems low, though.
In English today we started Hamlet, and when the teacher told the premise that a widowed woman married her brother-in-law, I thought OMG OMG OMG because the first image I thought of was PR. 😆 Then when I realized that, wow, the first thing I thought of was TV show, I had a really hard time controlling my laughter. At least now if I get tired of their character names I have other names to call them. 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".