Commentator's V-Day Special

commentator thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1

It was late. He sat on his bed and turned his shiny new ring round and round on his finger, looking blankly ahead of him at nothing in particular, and then, by chance, at the date on the wall calendar: the 14th of February. The Marathi TV people - flouting all Sena warnings - had been going on about Valentine's Day to their captive weekend audiences: cards with hearts on them and red roses and chocolate and dinners in candelight with girlfriends. He remembered a programme he'd watched tiredly one night a few months back, alone and unable to sleep, on some foreign channel, about where the custom had originated, and how, in that woman's opinion (she had a lot of opinions) it had degenerated into a respectable excuse to sell lacy thongs (what was a thong?) and sex toys. Lace, sex toys, cards, coloured candles, chocolate - all that seemed so far removed from his own life, the chawl, the garage, the endless desperate race to make ends meet, and now, this, this loveless new engagement.

He'd never been one for speeches, letting his hard work and his caring speak for themselves. And not everything about the culture that sent cards and roses appealed to him. But a day allotted, a whole day in which to declare or affirm one's love in words, to spoil a special person, to feel special oneself, without diffidence or embarrassment, without fear of his mother's anger and greed and jealousy crashing down on them like a vengeful chandelier let loose by a ghost in some old film.... And at the end of that day, wonderfully, to make love.

God. Never to have loved or touched a woman, and then to love one woman so desperately, yet never to touch her. He looked down at the bed he was sitting on, the bed on which he and Archana had never slept together. Here he was, with all his hopeless yearning. And there she was, where he had so often thrown himself down after a hard day, her slim and gracefully curved body stretched out on the living room divan, promoted there from the hard kitchen floor by that dreadful fall. On the living room divan, instead of here, where she should by rights have been, on his bed, by his side. She would never have bought lacy stuff; he almost smiled to himself. (Whatever a thong was.) And the pav bhaji place they used to be able to afford would never have coughed up for candles. He must create a more real fantasy. One in which he steps quietly into the living room, to where she is not asleep, but sitting up too, her arms clasped around her knees, looking out at the moon. He walks to her and she, hearing his careful steps, turns around to face him. He takes her hands in his and as she gets up, he draws her to his body, and lays his face on her hair and her cheek, innocent enough pleasures, but ones he has never known. They stand that way for long moments, savouring each other's closeness. Then she feels the tug of his hands, and her eyes are questioning but trusting as he pulls her gently towards the bedroom door. He knows that in real life he would never betray that trust, never allow himself to be pleasured for just one night with her and then leave her to lifelong regret and remembrance. Yet now, in this half dream, he leads her into his room, and shuts and locks the door. And she is standing by the bed that will soon be theirs, not turning away from him, or glancing shyly downwards as he might have expected, but breathing more deeply than usual, and gazing steadily at him, unafraid, unashamed, ready.

Edited by commentator - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

43

Views

4.4k

Users

10

Likes

26

Frequent Posters

nikitagmc thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Excellent commentator... I enjoyed it... do come up with more!!
LotusPetals thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Wow, wonderful Commentator .. loved it !! keep it coming :)
commentator thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Thank you, Nikita and Tasnime.
I suppose you'll have noticed one logical fallacy: it's very unlikely that Manav, who's probably been to a Marathi-medium school before dropping out, has enough of a grasp of English, particularly spoken with a US or British accent, to follow much on a "foreign channel". But there had to be some way for me to "give" him the information about V-Day that many of us take for granted. Therefore the literary license.... In any case, this IS a fantasy. We all know that sweet, nervous, nice-guy Manav would never take her into his bedroom, knowing he would ruin her life even further by doing so.
smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Consistency: Shining from all the facets.

One incomprehension: Would the Temperament permit continuance of a programme on G strings especially when breaths of nearer ones are almost audible in crowded environs? If a debate programme, then would the unfamiliarity of the language permit?

Almost a conclusion: Only she will have to lead the weaker one.[' He knows that in real life he would never betray that trust, never allow himself to be pleasured for just one night'.. and gazing steadily at him, unafraid, unashamed, ready ].

Edited by samarth_050 - 15 years ago
smrth thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Comprehension: Previous post was written before reading authors explanation.

Apology and thanks.
SweetFifi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
OKAY SO THIS IS WHAT I WANT TO SEE ON THE PAVITRA RISHTA I GOT HOOKED ON!!!...TRP'S HERE WE COME!
LotusPetals thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
ohh ya commentator .. but I thought he could more nd less understand english .. I think in class 10th, they are good at english, at least understand, aren't they ?

nd yes, the last part can never happen !! he'll only think that he'll further damage her life, nd also he's not that type of guy who only wants to "enjoy" with his wife .. Manav just wants her to be happy, nd eventually live together ..
bhavni88 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
well written but alas a fantasy...
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
Well written commentator but will it come true ?
I don't think we will ever get to see the human side of Manav where the man in him awakens and takes over all other finer feelings. I feel love is incomplete till we see those elements. They all make love the most complicated emotion out there. If feelings of responsibility , goodness , duties , this and that r constantly taking precedence it really isnt love at all . In my mind , when we fight all other emotions and become selfish for that one moment where we go crazily after the one we want , it is love . The Manav in the title song had allowed himself that one desire inspite of his hundred other adjustments. He had permitted himself that one luxury.......Archna , a girl not in his league . There he was being a man .........see his talks with Tarun then . Unfortunately this serial never developed that Manav fully . In their bid to stay in the TRP race , they introduced one sensational twist after the other and created a new Manav . We simply dont find him that adorable now .
As a viewer i wanted to see him getting all tongue tied in front of Archana on the suhaag raat and yet wanting her passionately from inside . I wanted to see him handling her tenderly like a flower in his rough , mechanic hands ! Unfortunately we never got to seeing that part of the garage mechanic . And now , after all this I doubt if that charm will ever come back . Sorry dear I know it is V day but i ........well , I feel this way only nowadays .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".