Originally posted by: nightingale1234
Lol, it’s a bit embarrassing when people compare Yumna and Wahaj like that. They’re clearly one of the best pairs out there, and their chemistry together is unbeatable.
As for this show, I really don’t understand why there’s so much talk about chemistry between Ammar and Nashwa or Burhan and Nashwa when the show doesn’t focus on that at all.
I’m sorry, but not everyone is feeling the chemistry between Nashwa and Ammar. Apart from a particular Twitter and Instagram fangirls, I don’t see much talk about it. Many viewers actually hope Nashwa ends up with Burhan because, in their eyes, he’s a good person n it has nothing to do with usama, whereas Ammar is a criminal who doesn’t deserve any girl n that has nothing to do with nameer either. Honestly, I just want to see Nashwa free from that toxic household and living a happy life, whether single or married. I really don’t mind either way.
The only pairings of Yumna that I’ve never really liked are with Humayun, Gohar, and now in Qez, where I don’t think either Nameer or Usama match up to her. Usama lacks the screen presence n his dialogue delivery is too bad, and Nameer’s acting just doesn’t do it for me. I have seen good actors doing superlative work for the similar characters like ammar.
I don't understand why can't hum cast two good actors together. The whole cast is awesome except the supposed hero n the criminal boy. Imagine someone like zahid , wahaj, bilal etc would have done such a great job as burhan. N I can't help but think khushal as ammar. He would have nailed that character.
Nameer and Usama both need voice modulation training badly. I don't think hum can afford 3 A listers right now. They have put all their eggs in their Netflix basket by casting half the country's population lol
Nameer is one project old. We don't know if he's going to fade or hold on or even improve. No idea as only time will tell. Khushal was good in wehshi though it was a bad play. He would have been a great Ammar. Nameer is a lahori I believe? Sometimes his urdu is a bit off and not sharp. But Usama has been here since 2017. He doesn't have the solo ML aura or capability to carry a whole project on his back through a positive or negative role. Like no matter how much I dislike Feroze as a person or his acting, he has full presence with his character and can carry projects on his back
Usama is good in parallel or long good soaps. He is not there yet. Nameer and his comparison is moot. Usama has been here since 2017 and his contemporary is Bilal Abbas and not Nameer. Bilal is exceptional. He is 11/10. He is a noman ejaz of his time. I have seen the great Faisal Qureshi and fawad Khan improve and this bilal has been good since day one.
Gohar is a great actor. And GM was a bad project maybe that's why humaiuyn didn't work. Or may be both gohar and him doesn't work the magic for Yumna. That's fine.
Also, I feel Wahaj, Bilal, Sherry may have refused to do side supporting role if QeJ was offered to them. Who knows. The story is afterall totally about Nashwa Bisma and about females in a desi society.
Also, I know for a fact that other than a few teen girls no one is hoping for Nashwa to end up with Ammar. What they're saying is clearly different from shipping or chemistry. They're using the wrong word and some are just latching onto it.
I think they want to say that the dynamic and the chaos and the screen space Nameer and Yumna share is fiery and sizzling. It doesn't at all mean they're advocating for romance. Like how Saba and Bilal has a great dynamic and sizzling presence in Cheekh. So, if Cheekh was falsely advertised as a romance genre like SMD was then that would have been a problem. People loved Saba -bilal scenes.
Rabia, Amna, kya drama hai pointed out the same thing. I disagree with many of their takes and reviews but I know Rabia and Amna wouldn't romanticize an enable of a heinous crime. They're very vocal. And neither would majority of the viewers Sans teen girls.
What some are saying is Usama is making Burhan appear bland at times. The layering is not there. He's perfect but the performance doesn't give variation hence making it boring. We know he has layers as he's written in a fabulous manner.
It's important to make it clear that people enjoy Ammar Nashwa scenes but if one was to genuinely ask a viewer in a conversation they'd tell you that they'd want her to end up with Burhan. The other option is just not it.
Also, It is frustrating for some as we know Burhan is really a stunning and beautifully written character. It's a bit lost in translation from script to screen.
Edited by Alizba63 - 6 months ago
394