PSF All Dramas TRP Thread #3 - Page 117

Originally posted by: Aaaaaaa77

I feel other than KMKT all appeared dragged (my opinion)

And in Mein the direction was really bad(acc to me) because he couldn't reflect what the writer intended to

Zanzabeel mentioned she had portrayed Zain as a really strong person but it didn't reflect like that

I mean he didn't even react well to wife being harassed ,to say the least

He is def better than Ali but i was saying he is not gr8 himself and KMKT can't be attributed to his skills , it was more about the writer

Originally posted by: meandwho

During Mein, SH said its not being directed directly by Badar as he was ill or something. I dont know if they were serious or said it in jest

Even Nadia Khan said it during KMKT.

Originally posted by: meandwho

During Mein, SH said its not being directed directly by Badar as he was ill or something. I dont know if they were serious or said it in jest

Yeah i have heard this too but somewhere else ,there it was mentioned mostly his shows are directed by assistants ,he just gives his name

If that is the case then he is definitely better than what I think of him

Originally posted by: meandwho

blah blah, is it a trend to pretend you are not part of this forum discussion to appear cool? Coz your posts are up all over the trp threads this year

B: Dead slot isliye tha because no other show was airing on Saturday 8pm at Hum not because it replaced some low TRP drama.

I: Cheekh had Saba Qamars all relatives die, it started with rape and death of Ushna's character and still it is a commercial drama.

Do you consider a drama social only because yumna ji is doing it? I was giving her more credits, that she is an A lister now, and can lead a commercial project on her own.

Kuch dinon se apna aap villain jaisa lag raha hai when it was us who were called names like jobless, aunties for talking about features and all, karma will bite us etc. Kya hogaya dekhte dekhte just because some people turn a blind eye when members are targeted personally.

Originally posted by: Orphic

Yeh dil mera from the same writer fell flat because of weak direction which resulted into Sajal & Ahad overacting. Badar is not great but definitely a good director. Haseeb & Haissam couldn’t make SMD & GM work even though they are renowned directors.

Even Fahad didn’t talk about Badar much in interviews. I think it’s unfair to him.

Yeah I feel writer is the most important pillar of a drama ,then comes actors and directors

Agree about YDM but I will say it was not a good writing too ,90s movies inspired product it was

But because Farhat has the record of good writing more than bad I feel positive about the show

Although no hate to Ahad and Dananeer(i hope this projects does good) but i would have wanted actors like Sajal doing such a role along with someone like Ahmed Ali Akbar only because they would have looked really different than their recent projects

Originally posted by: meandwho

During Mein, SH said its not being directed directly by Badar as he was ill or something. I dont know if they were serious or said it in jest

I thought it was MPHT where Badar felt ill and the DOP took over.

Originally posted by: hypnotoad

I thought it was MPHT where Badar felt ill and the DOP took over.

Originally posted by: Orphic

Yeh dil mera from the same writer fell flat because of weak direction which resulted into Sajal & Ahad overacting. Badar is not great but definitely a good director. Haseeb & Haissam couldn’t make SMD & GM work even though they are renowned directors.

Even Fahad didn’t talk about Badar much in interviews. I think it’s unfair to him.

Originally posted by: blahblah131

The views of the new hum show will get higher. It's less than three weeks old.

Try to enjoy the content 😉, TRPs and views se apko paisey nahi miltey. Greedy producers ko miltey hai and tit for tats start hotey hai.

Theek hai, girl got raped and thrown on the side of the road bilkul dark theme nahi. Neither is brother in law making advances towards the widowed sister in law. Ap bilkul theek Keh rahey hai.

This was tit for tat response, I actually enjoyed MJ. It is in my list of one of the best shows content wise in 2024

B - you are contradicting yourself. Anyways good for yumzi if qej manages to get a bit better views because up until now the views have been disastrous.

I - okay so qej also deals with same concept of rape and court room drama, so by your logic it isn't a social project right? Cool then, if mj is a flop then qej is a disaster because it's airing on a non competitive slot and 5 time lux award winning actress headlining it couldnt bring views or trps for the show. I feel sad for yumzi, it's a hat trick disaster for her. Only tb2 can bring her out of this disaster era.

Good that you watched mj, I'm a bilal fan but I haven't watched mj. I haven't watched 22 qadam either because I just don't find shows like these interesting enough.

Originally posted by: meandwho

On imbd credits, Badar is credited for MPTH but not mein, so I assumed he didnt direct mein

I think it's not that he is not credited on IMDB but that no one has bothered to fill out all the credits info for Mein. Even Zanjabeel's name isn't there nor the rest of the cast besides Wahaj and Ayeza,