TERE BIN THREAD- EPISODES DISCUSSION ONLY - Page 17

Created

Last reply

Replies

709

Views

118.1k

Users

80

Likes

3.1k

Frequent Posters

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

This is actually a good focus on how cousins should behave around cousins.

Namaharm is namaharam regardless. For murtasam this should be a big issue specially he was like my wife don't go village without covering!


The slap bcs she danced in front of everyone.


Meerab is being caged to the point she can’t go out without her husband.


Now that Murtasam alone with haya contradicts everything!!


Again this misunderstanding could have shown in an accidental way! Instead of like this. Episode 24 was a blunder from the writer's POV.


idk my opinion: murtasam is a capable man who is surrounded by his gang, why … like why he needs to take haya out of everyone????

If she wanted to show misunderstanding: show that in your own home. Or like murtasam goes out for a walk and haya being behyaa, could have followed him out as she looks for any excuse and then this type of scene and meerab catches them red handed.


Or Murtasam takes everyone for a vacation and misunderstanding happens.


or even more logical ; murtasam leaves to his job. Behaya also follows without anyone’s request.

Maa began us easily manipulated she could have made up some excuse!!

I can think of 100s of way but not this what we saw in episode 24!!! 😂

Heeba thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Liked (May 2023) Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: FireSafireFiree

This is actually a good focus on how cousins should behave around cousins.

Namaharm is namaharam regardless. For murtasam this should be a big issue specially he was like my wife don't go village without covering!


The slap bcs she danced in front of everyone.


Meerab is being caged to the point she can’t go out without her husband.


Now that Murtasam alone with haya contradicts everything!!


Again this misunderstanding could have shown in an accidental way! Instead of like this. Episode 24 was a blunder from the writer's POV.


idk my opinion: murtasam is a capable man who is surrounded by his gang, why … like why he needs to take haya out of everyone????

If she wanted to show misunderstanding: show that in your own home. Or like murtasam goes out for a walk and haya being behyaa, could have followed him out as she looks for any excuse and then this type of scene and meerab catches them red handed.


Or Murtasam takes everyone for a vacation and misunderstanding happens.


or even more logical ; murtasam leaves to his job. Behaya also follows without anyone’s request
.

Maa began us easily manipulated she could have made up some excuse!!

I can think of 100s of way but not this what we saw in episode 24!!! 😂


this would have been much better.. like murtasim leaves and then ma begum sends haya since she is worried and they could have shown ma begum being manipulated by haya like always.. it would have made much more sense then murtasim agreeing to bring haya and not his uncle


this is where i blame the writer.. no consistency in character..

SherDilNetaji thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Episode 24


We all have some problems with this episode, but I think it was a good turn to the story. I am trying to understand this with the literary view and would try to refrain from being partial.


Meerub is yet to realise her love, so it’s the only good time for MU, cause after she claims that she loves Murtasim, Rohail’s entry doesn’t make sense. And to make any drama hit, MU is an important concept just talking from literary pov, no one likes the drama which goes smoothly. We all look for a escape in these shows and books and the struggle of the character is what give us that escape. So MU was necessary and it is the only good time because if they both are in love then these stupid things are not going to matter.


Many things in the episode looks like they don’t make any sense, but they do like with the first scene Haya threatened her maid who was on her side with this she lost the support of that person who knew her darkest secret.


Second scene, The death of Murtasim’s people under his supervision on his land, the crisis is in his professional life, direct attack on his position as a leader.


Third scene MB sending Haya with Murtasim so that she can be in touch with him through her, that was the reason but did she contacted haya? No, she didn’t. Then why did she send her? I can find many reasons, one is she wanted to keep her out so that she can permanently keep her out, if she is planning something against haya like her wedding then her presence could be a hindrance, another reason could be that she wanted to prove it to Meerub that May be Haya loves Murtasim but he doesn’t and even if they are alone, Murtasim is not going to give in to haya and if this is the reason then her plan clearly failed cause Meerub did see them in a compromising position. You all are thinking that MB has no brain but the lady who ruled everyone’s life can’t be that dumb according to me.


Fourth Scene, Murtasim who actually cared about Meerub, agreed to take Haya with him, what could be the reason? The fan in me would give him the benefit of doubt that it’s because he was thinking for the safety of his people and Haya/Meerub angle can be discussed later, he was in hurry and his mother was halting him as he was going alone. But the literature fanatic in me knows that it was for no reason except to create misunderstanding, they showed that man as the brain of this empire and suddenly he became dumb? Doesn’t make sense, I am still waiting for his pov so that we can have an insight what he was thinking while agreeing with it.


Fifth scene, Meerub was ill and MB thought she is pregnant. MB is an old school lady so I don’t find any problem with her thoughts getting only one direction but she should have asked Meerub, and that’s where the theory of literature comes into picture, she would have definitely asked her if it was a real life but it is not so it is important to set the base for MUs.


Sixth scene Haya making the fake call to mislead Murtasim, but he didn’t believe her words.


Seventh scene, Meerub asking about haya and she is the main reason why she is continuing this drama, Haya left no chance to show her that she is the outsider so now she wants to show Haya that who is the outsider.


Eighth scene Murtasim is doing his duty, he is trying to correct his decisions which according to him were bad but I don’t think Malik jr. is behind these murders, they gave the message that forgiveness is the thing we need in this bitter world so why would they nullified this message by showing that forgiveness is a bad thing.


Ninth scene Meerub ignoring Rohail’s call but worried about Murtasim’s leave, so why she didn’t call her that’s easy to guess if she would have then there would be no story. Or May be she has no balance and can only receive calls but Murtasim was unable to contact her as well, has she blocked his number??


Fast forward to the scene where she agreed to meet Rohail and now is meeting him, she told Rohail about the contract and her relation with Murtasim which many found as wrong and it is, but then she is not wrong cause Rohail was the one who provoked her by praising her that you are the Meerub and now it was about her image, she needed to defend her and the only way she could defend herself was to tell the truth.


Then the scen me where MB tells Murtasim about Meerub’s absence and Anwar saw her with Rohail, i don’t think that Anwar will ever tell Murtasim about this but he would definitely tell this to waqas and Murtasim would overhear their talks and would connect the dot.

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Heeba


this would have been much better.. like murtasim leaves and then ma begum sends haya since she is worried and they could have shown ma begum being manipulated by haya like always.. it would have made much more sense then murtasim agreeing to bring haya and not his uncle


this is where i blame the writer.. no consistency in character..

yes 100% agree. This would have fitted better as murtasam he do not need protection.


knowing murtasam character if Haya appeared he wouldn’t just kick her out. This would have been much more logical.

Writer probably didn’t think through this!


Heeba thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Most Liked (May 2023) Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: FireSafireFiree

yes 100% agree. This would have fitted better as murtasam he do not need protection.


knowing murtasam character if Haya appeared he wouldn’t just kick her out. This would have been much more logical.

Writer probably didn’t think through this!


Exactly!!! We think more logical as we are invested in these characters.. story wise this would make so much more sense

FieryLioness thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: FireSafireFiree

This is actually a good focus on how cousins should behave around cousins.

Namaharm is namaharam regardless. For murtasam this should be a big issue specially he was like my wife don't go village without covering!


The slap bcs she danced in front of everyone.


Meerab is being caged to the point she can’t go out without her husband.


Now that Murtasam alone with haya contradicts everything!!


Again this misunderstanding could have shown in an accidental way! Instead of like this. Episode 24 was a blunder from the writer's POV.


idk my opinion: murtasam is a capable man who is surrounded by his gang, why … like why he needs to take haya out of everyone????

If she wanted to show misunderstanding: show that in your own home. Or like murtasam goes out for a walk and haya being behyaa, could have followed him out as she looks for any excuse and then this type of scene and meerab catches them red handed.


Or Murtasam takes everyone for a vacation and misunderstanding happens.


or even more logical ; murtasam leaves to his job. Behaya also follows without anyone’s request.

Maa began us easily manipulated she could have made up some excuse!!

I can think of 100s of way but not this what we saw in episode 24!!! 😂


Namaharm means ???


Actually him allowing Haya's advances are not making any sense. Either take the conservative approach they hv for women or take it as him being a married man nd being very well aware of her intentions. Him not stopping her at 1st step is encouraging haya more. She is getting bolder for her declaration of love. How come they hv not shown him reprimanding her for whole gajra fiasco. It takes no genius to know she did it to create misunderstanding.


It was so stupid of them to show haya going along. Considering what happened to meerab there nd now the killings, no sane person will take women of his house along. That was a silly scene. Like you said, there were many ways to show this misunderstanding, but the move they took is stupidest of all.

Moreover murtasim is a no kid. He knows this setup well. How is haya gonna be any help there . Kuchh bhi🤷‍♀️

Kumuda-123 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Moonks

Episode 24


We all have some problems with this episode, but I think it was a good turn to the story. I am trying to understand this with the literary view and would try to refrain from being partial.


Meerub is yet to realise her love, so it’s the only good time for MU, cause after she claims that she loves Murtasim, Rohail’s entry doesn’t make sense. And to make any drama hit, MU is an important concept just talking from literary pov, no one likes the drama which goes smoothly. We all look for a escape in these shows and books and the struggle of the character is what give us that escape. So MU was necessary and it is the only good time because if they both are in love then these stupid things are not going to matter.


Many things in the episode looks like they don’t make any sense, but they do like with the first scene Haya threatened her maid who was on her side with this she lost the support of that person who knew her darkest secret.


Second scene, The death of Murtasim’s people under his supervision on his land, the crisis is in his professional life, direct attack on his position as a leader.


Third scene MB sending Haya with Murtasim so that she can be in touch with him through her, that was the reason but did she contacted haya? No, she didn’t. Then why did she send her? I can find many reasons, one is she wanted to keep her out so that she can permanently keep her out, if she is planning something against haya like her wedding then her presence could be a hindrance, another reason could be that she wanted to prove it to Meerub that May be Haya loves Murtasim but he doesn’t and even if they are alone, Murtasim is not going to give in to haya and if this is the reason then her plan clearly failed cause Meerub did see them in a compromising position. You all are thinking that MB has no brain but the lady who ruled everyone’s life can’t be that dumb according to me.


Fourth Scene, Murtasim who actually cared about Meerub, agreed to take Haya with him, what could be the reason? The fan in me would give him the benefit of doubt that it’s because he was thinking for the safety of his people and Haya/Meerub angle can be discussed later, he was in hurry and his mother was halting him as he was going alone. But the literature fanatic in me knows that it was for no reason except to create misunderstanding, they showed that man as the brain of this empire and suddenly he became dumb? Doesn’t make sense, I am still waiting for his pov so that we can have an insight what he was thinking while agreeing with it.


Fifth scene, Meerub was ill and MB thought she is pregnant. MB is an old school lady so I don’t find any problem with her thoughts getting only one direction but she should have asked Meerub, and that’s where the theory of literature comes into picture, she would have definitely asked her if it was a real life but it is not so it is important to set the base for MUs.


Sixth scene Haya making the fake call to mislead Murtasim, but he didn’t believe her words.


Seventh scene, Meerub asking about haya and she is the main reason why she is continuing this drama, Haya left no chance to show her that she is the outsider so now she wants to show Haya that who is the outsider.


Eighth scene Murtasim is doing his duty, he is trying to correct his decisions which according to him were bad but I don’t think Malik jr. is behind these murders, they gave the message that forgiveness is the thing we need in this bitter world so why would they nullified this message by showing that forgiveness is a bad thing.


Ninth scene Meerub ignoring Rohail’s call but worried about Murtasim’s leave, so why she didn’t call her that’s easy to guess if she would have then there would be no story. Or May be she has no balance and can only receive calls but Murtasim was unable to contact her as well, has she blocked his number??


Fast forward to the scene where she agreed to meet Rohail and now is meeting him, she told Rohail about the contract and her relation with Murtasim which many found as wrong and it is, but then she is not wrong cause Rohail was the one who provoked her by praising her that you are the Meerub and now it was about her image, she needed to defend her and the only way she could defend herself was to tell the truth.


Then the scen me where MB tells Murtasim about Meerub’s absence and Anwar saw her with Rohail, i don’t think that Anwar will ever tell Murtasim about this but he would definitely tell this to waqas and Murtasim would overhear their talks and would connect the dot.

Love this analysis♥️. This is perfect set up for misunderstanding.

Wish makers handled it differently instead of changing core characteristics of almost all characters.

Better this misunderstanding lead to good outcome.

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: FieryLioness


Namaharm means ???


Actually him allowing Haya's advances are not making any sense. Either take the conservative approach they hv for women or take it as him being a married man nd being very well aware of her intentions. Him not stopping her at 1st step is encouraging haya more. She is getting bolder for her declaration of love. How come they hv not shown him reprimanding her for whole gajra fiasco. It takes no genius to know she did it to create misunderstanding.


It was so stupid of them to show haya going along. Considering what happened to meerab there nd now the killings, no sane person will take women of his house along. That was a silly scene. Like you said, there were many ways to show this misunderstanding, but the move they took is stupidest of all.

Moreover murtasim is a no kid. He knows this setup well. How is haya gonna be any help there . Kuchh bhi🤷‍♀️


typo: na merham: idk how to spell that. Muslim girls should be infront of someone who is close to you. Is an Islamic rule. And the drama emphasized that allot. That’s why I am questioning: for meerab such a rule then why not for Haya!

MB constantly tells her put ur dupatta on your head.

And murtasam follows the old tridition like you do in jamidar, they are not backwards minded but follows some spiritual value however he blooming contradicts the whole thing with Haya 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️.


one rule for your wife while another for your cousin.

Murtasam legally responsible for his mum, wife and sister. Haya is someone lives so he is indirectly also responsible for her but that does not mean he should forget his duty ans an man and he has been doing all the weird thing for wrong reason. Bru I wouldn’t even touch my cousin. I am not even that conservative and even I wouldn’t do that.

Now that I am thinking: murtasam did say in early episode stop being behaya!!! So I wonder what happened now???

he is leading her on and meerab pointed that out many time but murtasam is not understanding that. Unless writer trying to show how murtasam lacks knowledge at this level.

I will wait for next few episode maybe we will get some justification. Hopefully

gajra scene was done well. he explains that he felt awkward to ask for it back Bcs she wore it. I think that scene was done well Bcs later MB comes in and tells her on her face to take it off. She cries and feels insulted. MB also points out, meerab is not stupid she understand your game plan unlike murtasam.

Edited by FireSafireFiree - 2 years ago
SherDilNetaji thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Kumuda-123

Love this analysis♥️. This is perfect set up for misunderstanding.

Wish makers handled it differently instead of changing core characteristics of almost all characters.

Better this misunderstanding lead to good outcome.

It would lead to good outcome only cause nothing happens in a story with bad purpose unless it is written with that purpose.

And I don’t think the core characteristics are changed as Meerub’s character was strong and stubborn which she still is and Murtasim was the man who viewed everything traditionally and by keeping relationships in mind, Nothing has changed except the situation and they didn’t know how to react aptly according to the situation.

FireSafireFiree thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Moonks

It would lead to good outcome only cause nothing happens in a story with bad purpose unless it is written with that purpose.

And I don’t think the core characteristics are changed as Meerub’s character was strong and stubborn which she still is and Murtasim was the man who viewed everything traditionally and by keeping relationships in mind, Nothing has changed except the situation and they didn’t know how to react aptly according to the situation.

Myra characteristic didn’t change. The character is still responding the way they should. Just a silly way to set out your misunderstanding.

Could have done it better!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".